// transcript — 576 segments
0:00 Intro
0:01 Do you believe today's models are conscious? >> I want to be clear.
0:05 No one really knows. >> Can I say what I don't like about the
0:08 whole framing? Should it ever [music] be allowed to not answer or disengage with
0:13 me? >> I think this is a [music] technology that wants a new form factor.
0:18 Some labs says I'm going to push the button on RSI to make [music] sure we
0:20 have the power. I think if people really pushed on RSI, then yes, that would [music] be true,
0:25 but I think it's a very dangerous thing to push on and >> Do you believe that?
0:30 Curing or treating a mental disease? >> Then I would hope we have the candidate
0:33 for that in the next couple of years. >> Where do you feel the most pressure
0:35 right now? >> I mean, it feels like [music] everywhere.
0:38 We should be shooting more for a new Renaissance than a new Industrial
0:41 Revolution. >> All right, Sam, thank you so much for joining me.
0:52 When Will AI Discover New Treatments?
0:52 >> Yeah, thank you. >> So, the first thing I want to talk about
0:55 are [snorts] some of the announcements that you made last week about all of the
0:59 math proofs and and the discoveries and I think it seems incredible, but maybe
1:04 you can contextualize it for a broader audience who may not be in the weeds.
1:08 >> I think we are entering the era where AI is going to help us discover
1:13 significant new knowledge. Um and we've been talking about this for a long time
1:17 and I I you know, maybe started earlier this year, but now it's really like
1:21 okay, the AI is doing very difficult things, figuring out very
1:28 complicated, important uh new knowledge and I believe that the same thing that has
1:34 worked here for math is going to work for biology, help us get new medicines,
1:38 material science, you know, help us get new sources of energy and much more. So,
1:43 this is one of the things I've always been most excited about. I think this is
1:47 going to do an enormous amount to really have an impact on people's lives.
1:51 It won't feel directly like using AI. It'll just feel like, "Okay, the world
1:54 got better." and it's just society doing its thing, but I think that the power of this will be
1:59 transformative. >> And I I think about having that kind of
2:04 direct impact on society day-to-day. Is there anything that you think will stem
2:08 from some of these discoveries in particular that people will feel and and
2:12 what is the timeline for something like that? >> I would hope well,
2:17 you know, the FDA process is going to take a while. So, let me let me kind of
2:20 give a time frame to when I think we have like a discovery of
2:25 curing or treating a major disease. Uh or a candidate for that that has to
2:27 go through testing. I would hope we have the candidate for that in the next
2:30 couple of years for the first like really major thing. >> Probably need to overhaul some of the
2:37 post-discovery process to start to get you know, cures and uh and market ready products.
2:43 >> to overhaul it somewhat. I'm glad we have >> Yeah.
2:47 >> a process like I'm I I no doubt that there's a room for improvement as there
2:50 is in anything and maybe there's more than average here, but
2:54 you know, like I'm grateful that when we take a medicine it is generally uh
3:01 considered safe and has been tested and I think that part's good.
3:04 >> Is there a particular project that was kicked off by AI, discovered by AI that
3:08 you're really excited about that you think is kind of coming over the horizon
3:11 soon? >> Personally, I think I'm most emotionally excited for a major physics
3:18 discovery. And I'm hopeful that can come soon. Um I I don't know if that's like necessarily
3:25 the most important thing for humanity as a whole. Um but it's the one where I'm like I
3:29 think we're going to get it and it's going to be so cool. >> There was
3:31 Why AI Hasn’t Killed Coding Jobs
3:34 a some in the math community whose reaction was you know, we didn't ask for this. We
3:39 don't And it felt very similar to how engineers I think first reacted to AI
3:42 starting to write a lot of the code. Where Where do you think that comes
3:45 from? And how do you think that is going to transition? >> Um coding was a very interesting one
3:50 before we kind of go to where it comes from. The thing about coding is that
3:53 people went through this there's no more jobs as coders for people to
4:02 Coders are never going to be busier than they've been and coders are never going
4:05 to have more of an impact and make money. Now that that the texture of the job changed a lot. But
4:13 the fact that we're going to like employ people to get computers to do
4:18 things that seems like it's going to keep going for much longer than people thought.
4:24 And and people were so certain um you know, 6 or 12 months ago this was not the
4:28 case. >> Yeah. >> It's like there's no need. You know, and
4:35 I think there's many lessons to learn from this but one of the interesting
4:39 ones is that the world actually had demand for just way more software
4:44 than any of us thought at the time. >> And part of why I think
4:50 some of the mathematicians are having the reaction they're having is it's not
4:54 clear that the same thing applies to math. However, where I think there is an
5:02 analogy to coding is already you're starting to see some of the
5:05 a similar shift happen that happened with coding which is okay, fine. Maybe
5:10 we're not going to discover new math theorems or prove them in an unaided way anymore.
5:16 Maybe that part is like done or mostly done or ending. Um but
5:21 you know, given that the whole society our whole society is focused on people
5:28 doing useful things for each other. Um the these kind of like incomprehensible
5:31 math proofs turned out to be not that helpful to people. And there's now
5:36 a lot of excitement about people who are going to take these new ideas, figure
5:39 out what's going on and figure out a way to translate it to something that people
5:42 can understand and write a beautiful proof for it. Um I'm sure there There be
5:46 other things too. And no doubt what what it meant to be a mathematician last
5:55 year is not going to be what it means to be a mathematician next year in some
5:59 senses of it. I think we probably will find that there's a lot of other things that
6:05 mathematicians do that we really want people to do. And they can do those much
6:08 better. Whether that means there will be more to total demand for mathematicians
6:12 or not, I don't know. But I think there is a really important thing here. You
6:16 were mentioning earlier that you've never felt busier. There's never
6:19 been more to do. >> Yeah. >> Everyone thought that I was going to go
6:22 the other way and we weren't going to have enough to do. And again, maybe that
6:25 happens someday. But I think all of this stuff has just been much less obvious than it seems on
6:32 the surface. I mean, I always hope that people get to work a little bit less. I
6:35 get to be a little bit less busy and kind of more time for everything else in
6:38 their life. I think that would I think that like technology is supposed
6:41 to enable that. I want that thing to happen. Um but man, does it sure seem like we're
6:48 good at wanting more out of life and wanting more out of the world and making
6:51 ourselves busier. >> Yeah, I think that's just human nature.
6:53 >> Yeah. >> Like if we were comfortable with the way
6:58 life was 100 years ago now, we'd probably be working an hour a week, but
7:01 that's just not the way it is. >> And I think it's a beautiful thing about
7:03 human nature that that's not the way it is. >> Yeah. I mean, a good example is
7:08 you know, a few weeks ago my editor started using Astra to edit our videos.
7:13 Uh they are still directing. They're still coming up with like how the video
7:17 should be, but they're not touching the timeline anymore. It's the most insane
7:21 thing and it was an overnight change. >> Yeah. >> We're making more videos. They're busier
7:25 than ever. >> It's it has surprised me how often someone
7:32 says a sentence that translates to exactly that. >> Yeah. So, I'm thinking about discoveries
7:38 from AI and and I'm wondering like how do you think about if AI and OpenAI
7:44 discovered some proof or significant uh scientific innovation that gave it
7:48 massive commercial advantage. Like, would you publish it and and like how do
7:52 you think about that trade-off between like okay, we're going to use this for
7:55 our competitive advantage versus publishing it for the world's good?
7:59 >> I'll come back to that but I I didn't answer the end of your your first
8:03 question. Um You know, that I think one of the challenges innovation and solving
8:07 hard problems is really like part of the fun of life for many people. And so
8:15 part of what's going on here is I think we do just need to be honest
8:19 that AI is going to do that part of that really well. Um I think there'll be questions about
8:23 what people value that will remain kind of human questions forever.
8:26 Um there will be questions about how to interpret results and how to explain
8:29 them where we'll really want a person to do it. I do feel some like
8:35 I definitely want the trade. I definitely want, you know, the cures to
8:39 diseases no matter how much someone else would have enjoyed taking decades longer
8:42 to figure it out themselves. I think most people would agree that we
8:44 should make that such a trade. >> Yeah. >> But but there is a real thing being
8:52 lost here which is this is like of great enjoyment. Like the the most fun part of my job are the
8:58 really hard problems. Like maybe they're not I should say the most fulfilling
9:01 part. Maybe they're not the most fun in the moment cuz they're really hard. But
9:04 like that's the stuff where it's like ah I I I did a hard thing and I'm proud of it
9:11 and I leveled up. And um so I don't have an answer to this uh but I get why
9:16 people feel the grieving of different sorts that they feel. >> Yeah, I mean you it's almost like you're
9:20 trading off the enjoyment of the craft of doing the thing. Like writing code,
9:25 writing beautiful code versus delivering an end product. >> Yeah.
9:28 >> And I I think that's the trade-off where AI is just making it so much easier to
9:33 deliver that end product and and you're just doing less of the actual craft.
9:38 >> I think people are finding craft in new ways, but craft of
9:43 And you know, probably when we stopped using like punch cards or whatever,
9:46 however people program computers a long time ago, there were people who were
9:49 like, "Oh, the craft is gone if you can just like write the stuff for a
9:52 compiler." Yeah. Um but I feel it. I feel it myself um in a bunch of ways and uh
10:00 I'm still excited to like head into this future and I'm sure we'll all find new
10:03 and hopefully better kinds of fulfillment. >> What's something that you've felt like
10:09 you've kind of given up lately to AI and and in fact you've just kind of elevated
10:13 uh to to where you're over perceiving agents? >> I I guess this is the one we were
10:19 talking about, but I realized I have not read or even looked at a line of code
10:24 in probably a year. And I like I don't code for work at all,
10:28 but I would still like do little like random personal projects or just like I
10:32 need this thing. I can like make it, you know, write a very simple thing for it.
10:37 And that is fun. That is a fun thing like writing code at least occasionally is a
10:42 fun thing to do. And I don't think I'll ever do that again. Or if I do, it'll be like, you know,
10:49 like a Revolutionary War reenactment or whatever kind of thing people do, you
10:51 know, >> Right. >> when I'm old and bored and I'm trying to
10:55 like remember the glory days. >> The glory days of >> of writing code.
10:59 >> No, I I get it, yeah. >> Um in terms of the scientific discovery
11:03 question, I think there's like some kinds of basic science that should just
11:07 belong to the world and we should do as a sort of public good. Until very
11:09 recently we haven't had models that can go, you know, kind of end-to-end
11:14 discover an important new thing, like design a whole chip end-to-end.
11:18 Um and so what a company can do today, uh let's say let's say figure out a new
11:24 material. >> Yeah. >> Um what a company could do today is have
11:29 like a bunch of people that uh you know, use Codex or a lot of API
11:34 credits to try to kind of do the work. But as the models get smarter and more
11:38 capable, like maybe they can just go in the same way that they could solve
11:41 really difficult math problems. Um you know, with enough compute and
11:46 enough data from the real world uh discover new material. >> So, I want to switch gears. Um one of
11:47 Personal AI Assistants
11:51 the most exciting things that has happened in 2026 is this revolution of
11:57 personal AI assistant starting with Open Claw, of course. It was, you know, Peter
12:00 Steinberger, a genius. >> Um >> And I think like this idea that AI can
12:07 work on my behalf ambiently, passively throughout the day and just get things
12:11 done for me is so exciting and Dot gives us a glimpse of what that can be, but it
12:15 still feels like we have a long way to go to really have an ambient personal
12:19 assistant. What do you think either the technologies or maybe there's some you
12:24 know, some kind of data that's required. What is necessary to get us to what you believe is your
12:31 what your vision is for an AI assistant? >> I think uh
12:35 we have most of the technological pieces and what we need are
12:40 is more product work. Maybe new consumer hardware at some point for the ambient awareness and a
12:45 lot more compute. But I think we have smart enough models now to make something extraordinary that
12:54 can be monitoring all the things that you care about that can be helping you out with all the
13:02 tasks you want to offload. Um that can be existing in the physical
13:06 world with you and have context even when you're not in front of your
13:08 computer. Um I'm very excited about this. I don't I don't think this is that far away.
13:17 I think you do get more than a glimpse with Dot if you take the time to sort of
13:21 set it up right and give it enough feedback. I would estimate at this point
13:25 that I have Dot saving me an hour a day of stuff I just didn't want to be doing.
13:28 Which is like pretty great. >> Yeah. >> And then also a few times a day
13:32 something important and urgent that I would have missed not just because I was busy in a
13:37 meeting, which is what I thought it was going to help me with saying, you know,
13:40 there's this urgent thing, there's a deadline very soon, you got to pay
13:44 attention. But also the model is smart enough that it can pull
13:49 ideas and information and do like good reasoning across stuff from a lot of
13:53 sources in a way that I've just like run out of brain space during a busy day to do.
13:57 >> Yeah. >> And it I feel like it's it's the power is there
14:05 and we just need to put a nice product around it. >> I mean, you you mentioned compute, so
14:10 let's stick on that for a second. I the distribution of how people are using
14:15 AI is like completely asymmetric. There's the top 1% using the vast
14:21 majority or really like the power users and then there's everybody else. How
14:24 much compute do you think is necessary if 50% of the world were really using
14:30 the personal AI assistant to its full capability? >> How many GPUs do you want working for
14:34 you in your personal assistant? >> Yeah, I guess that is it, right?
14:40 Infinite. As many as I can get my hands on. >> This is a weird thing, right? Like if
14:43 Yeah. >> How do you think about that? I mean, is it just like get all the GPUs and keep
14:48 building data centers? >> When people talk about the like the
14:53 global market for GPUs and the demands for this and demands for compute,
14:57 the thing that I think it misses is people are assuming that models are
15:02 going to stay at the same capability and the same cost per task as today.
15:07 And maybe there is a cap on demand at that point, but for sufficiently
15:11 high-quality intelligence at a sufficiently low cost, I think it's like very hard to talk
15:16 about an arbitrary market size there. I think it's just going to keep People
15:19 call us all sorts of things, Jevons paradox, whatever. I think it's just
15:22 going to keep going up. Um I am sure there will be some periods.
15:26 I'm not sure I'm I believe that there will be some periods where
15:31 like with any new technology, there's supply constraints and supply gluts and
15:34 you know, we don't have it perfect all the time. But I would bet a lot that the
15:38 directional trend is to want to use much more compute. >> I still feel even with the as proactive
15:39 Why Are We Busier Than Ever?
15:45 as Dot is and other AI assistants, I still feel this cognitive load. Like I'm
15:49 having to make a lot of decisions throughout the day and we talked about
15:52 that briefly earlier. Like what is the solution to that? I again, like it is
15:57 definitely saving me time. It's saving me money. But I am busier than ever and I'm having
16:02 to make more decisions than ever and I find myself at the end of the day just
16:08 feeling completely drained. Yeah. >> Um Well, first of all, I think I've done in
16:12 my own use that's been pretty good. It's just like telling Dot like I'm starting
16:16 to trust your judgment more. You know, tell me after you do something. I always want to know, but
16:20 you can like take more actions proactively. And ping me less often. Um and that has
16:27 helped. I the negative is I do think the people that use AI the most are busier than
16:33 ever. The positive is they're getting much more done than before.
16:36 >> Yeah. >> So, you know, as you were saying earlier, if we went back to 1900 or
16:40 whatever, maybe we could have an equivalent life and all work an hour a day.
16:45 You could be much less busy and get what you were getting done 3 years ago. Like
16:48 Now, maybe you say, well, I can't cuz I'm in a competitive environment and so
16:51 like >> Yeah. >> that's people are always going to work
16:54 as hard as they can. I find this like kind of depressing. I hope it's not
16:57 true. Maybe it is. It's not all depressing. Like there's something Again, there's something
17:01 beautiful about it. Um >> That's the dynamic of a competitive
17:05 market, right? It's Isn't that Do you not find that to be inevitable?
17:08 Everybody's just going to Everybody ramps up, competes as fiercely as they
17:12 ever would. >> I hope that the future is one of more like human
17:22 connection and more people more people spending more time on like
17:26 the fullness of things that make up a rich life and not kind of
17:31 turning ever harder as like a a wheel in the machine of capitalism.
17:35 And I think this is probably true. Like I I I think quality of life has gone up
17:42 enormously in the last few hundred years. Yeah. >> Uh >> I think most people do work less than
17:47 they worked during the Industrial Revolution. Um speaking of that, I I
17:54 I've recently been telling people that, you know, I think this should we should
17:57 be shooting more for a new Renaissance than a new Industrial Revolution.
18:01 And it's been quite interesting to watch how people respond because
18:07 people I mean the very commonly there was the answer that the response that is
18:11 something like, "Yeah, I'm really scared. The Industrial Revolution
18:15 like really bad for most people. And I I don't want to just be like
18:23 a worker on a factory line and now the AI tells me what to do instead of some like factory
18:29 owner telling me what to do. Like I want to go be creative. I want to go make
18:31 stuff. I want to go explore. I want to have time to like reconnect with what
18:35 people used to do in the past and like live with my community and raise my kids
18:38 and spend time in nature and whatever. Um and I want to see like a ton of
18:41 scientific discovery and great new art. So, I think there's like
18:46 there is a fear that AI is going to be more of what you have said, but a real
18:49 like I think people if we can offer people a future where it's
18:54 more like the Renaissance, I think people are excited for that. And I think
18:57 we can we can do it. Um I think this technology is so powerful
19:03 that although you will probably have some small number of people in society
19:07 that have always competed to like be like the person with the biggest
19:11 you know, business empire or whatever. Yeah. I think a lot of people can have a
19:16 vastly increased quality of life and much more space to live their life.
19:19 >> Is the disparity between those hyper-competitive people and everybody
19:24 else going to amplify because of AI? Like if if the you know, if you're using
19:27 Yeah. >> Yeah. 100% of your effort to work and now all of a sudden you're getting 10
19:33 100 times more done and somebody else is like, well, I actually want to reap the
19:36 benefit of not working as much. It doesn't that increase the disparity?
19:40 >> Left to its own devices, I think probably. I would say No one knows this
19:44 for certain. Like there could be a bunch of other weird things where the AIs
19:49 Well, I That would take too long. I would just say I think probably that's
19:55 right. We don't know for sure. Um the But I think society will
20:01 decide to put some structure in place that prevents it from getting too out of whack. Um yeah.
20:08 I would be worried about that also on its own. >> Let's uh let's change gears. I know
20:10 Why the AI Consciousness Debate Worries Sam
20:13 you've been talking about this a lot, so I want to ask you. Um do you believe
20:16 today's models are conscious? >> I don't personally Well,
20:21 as a scientific question, I think consciousness is always hard. But my
20:27 belief is that today's models are not conscious or if they are, it's like a
20:30 very strange um form of it. >> Do you think based on the architecture
20:37 we have today that it could become conscious? And I I know I'm just asking your belief. I'm
20:43 not asking for the scientific answer. >> The smartest people I've talked to about
20:48 this uh basically come to the following philosophically uh they would say that
20:51 either you know, consciousness is like something outside of physical reality
21:00 and exists in either, you know, something like what the Eastern
21:03 religions would say and it's like the base layer of reality or something
21:07 supernatural and religious more like the Western religions would traditionally
21:09 say, or that it is an emergent property of matter and energy somehow. We don't
21:17 understand it yet. Um, and you know, maybe the substrate matters, but maybe
21:20 it doesn't, and maybe energy flowing through matter can do it. And then
21:25 and then in that world, sure, like you can imagine it someday somehow existing in other forms.
21:32 Can I say what I don't like about the whole framing? Please. I think very
21:35 often the are models conscious or are they going to become conscious
21:51 the role of AI in the world and the rights of AI and whether
21:57 you know, can we ask AI questions or is that some kind of slavery? I saw
22:01 something posted about that on the internet. Um, what does it mean to copy
22:05 an AI or delete an AI without its permission? What does it mean to say that people
22:10 should be in control of the future if these systems are both conscious and
22:15 much smarter than us in some ways? Like you know, what what does that mean? And
22:19 I I like I am I am so firmly of the belief that we need to have a very clear
22:24 point that and we've had this since the beginning of OpenAI, that we build the
22:29 future for people and AI is a resource for people, and people need to make the
22:33 key decisions of the future, and human values have value because they are
22:36 human. Um that I get very nervous when people start using the AI consciousness
22:47 debate to push into well, maybe people shouldn't always be in control of the future. And on this
22:52 one I'd like us to just uh agree as a society and industry that,
22:56 you know, this is about people. The world, the future has to be about
22:59 people. >> You know, Anthropic put a rule in recently. Uh, you can't have sustained
23:05 abuse against the model and it can choose to disengage in a conversation with you.
23:12 Like, okay, let's say I have a prompt for an OpenAI model. It's completely legal. It's completely
23:17 within the terms of service of OpenAI. Should it ever be allowed to not answer
23:24 or disengage with me? Well, >> I mean, certainly if we have many times where the model will
23:29 not answer you, but they are because of like we think this is bad and against
23:34 our policy for some reason. Um we do not ascribe personhood to our models.
23:39 Um we And again, I think this is like a very dangerous path to start down, not not
23:47 just for the reasons we've talked about, but also just about how how people are
23:51 going to relate to this this new technology. Um I was going to say come to our senses. I
24:01 don't think that's quite the right phrase. I don't think we've lost our
24:04 senses, but I hope I hope we come to an understanding that this technology is not a person
24:13 and is certainly not superior to people. Um and that this is a
24:21 a a a thing to help people have better lives, um have more freedom and choice and control and
24:28 ability to do things in the future. Um But you can imagine all of these ways
24:35 where things go very wrong, where people even the people building AI get confused
24:38 about that. And start, you know, deferring too much to AI and what it seems to want and you
24:44 know, okay, well, we can trust it cuz it'll be good to us and things like
24:46 that. >> Does it feel almost like a self-fulfilling prophecy in a way? Like
24:51 if you're telling the model, "Hey, you might be conscious and here's your
24:55 constitution and here's how you should have agency." It's kind of like that meme if you've
25:00 saw seen that meme like, "Hey computer, tell me you're conscious. I'm conscious.
25:05 Oh my god." Like isn't it almost like that? >> Yeah, I I mean for sure
25:10 like I want to be clear. No one really knows. Like these models
25:14 work at a level of complexity that I don't think and even if they didn't I I I I just
25:21 think this question of consciousness in a model I I can't tell you here is a
25:26 scientific experiment that I can tell you with 100% certainty would answer
25:30 the hypothetical question to my satisfaction. >> And we can't even do that for humans.
25:34 >> Exactly. Um but but definitely I think if you tell a
25:39 model like "Maybe you're conscious. You should do this. You should do that. You can like
25:43 be a conscientious objector here. You can start like it's going to follow those
25:49 instructions and I think it is going to psychologically hack it people that are
25:57 using it. And so again, I think real clarity here and a commitment about
26:05 what we as a industry believe about the role of people in the future
26:09 ChatGPT Is Too Agreeable
26:09 would be would be very helpful. >> Uh let's continue on this conversation,
26:12 but let's talk about model personality which I know you've you've thought
26:15 deeply about. You you've talked about it in the past. It's wild to me to try to
26:21 understand how to give a model the right personality for the right moment for
26:26 each person multiplied by 8 billion. Like how how do you even think about a
26:30 problem so massive? >> Um I mean the best thing is to like talk to
26:34 a lot of people. The you know, we have this process of the model spec and how we refine it over
26:43 time. Um and we believe in this spirit of iterative deployment and we've
26:47 definitely had some screw-ups as we've learned about what people want and don't want.
26:53 Uh as you said, the hardest part of this is people want very different things,
26:56 but people also don't really want to sit there and customize Most people don't
26:59 want to sit there and customize it either. Like, if everybody was willing to spend
27:05 many hours explaining to their ChatGPT instance how they would like it to
27:08 behave, they'd probably get something they really like. >> Yeah.
27:10 >> But, people just want it to kind of like work out of the box when you say, "I
27:15 need this thing done." or whatever. Um, I think there are also a class of things
27:22 want in the short term, but not in the long term. You know, the class The classic example
27:26 of this is when people compare models on a single response, they're
27:34 much happier with the model that tells them they're really smart.
27:36 And that each question's a great question. And that, you know, each thing
27:40 they're doing is like really insightful. Um, and but then over some number of like
27:46 hundreds of prompts, or, you know, a month of usage, that is definitely not the case.
27:51 I think for a long time the whole industry was trying to like win these
27:55 comparisons on single turn things, and not over the value someone gets out of
28:00 using a model for months and months. >> You know, even in my own life with my
28:04 friends and my family, there's this very, uh, big distinction between what I
28:10 want and what I need. I find AI even today to be a little bit more agreeable
28:15 than I would like. Like, if I just tell it, "No, tell tell it to me like this."
28:18 it'll do that. The time where I've gotten the best advice in life was advice that I didn't know I
28:26 needed, and I just needed to hear it. How do you How do you solve for that?
28:30 >> Well, I think you should get the most important advice in your life from
28:33 people, not from AI, first of all. Like, I wouldn't Speaking of like really
28:41 people centric, uh, I I think AI can give you like great advice about not sending an email in a
28:50 moment of anger. I would not go rely on AI for like the really big pieces of
28:54 life advice. I think that, you know, like a wise grandmother is still
28:57 probably a much, much, much better choice for that. Um, but but what I think is
29:05 realistic to expect is that AI should be like a senior colleague
29:09 that even if they report to you, they still push back when they have high conviction, and they
29:14 still are not always just trying to say yes, you're so great.
29:20 Um and I think I think we can get there, and I I also feel like
29:30 the systems are still more agreeable than I would like to. I have like custom
29:33 instructions in mind that I like never want any of that. And even with that,
29:37 it's still like a little too much. It's, you know, it's clearly baked pretty hard
29:39 into the model. >> What what's an example? Like what's a
29:43 line from your custom instructions that really tells the model push back when
29:46 you do have high conviction? >> Stuff like that. It's like no fluff, no
29:51 me. Like I just want to get to the right answer. If you if you have
29:58 something to say that's against what I'm doing, don't worry about, you know,
30:02 saying it delicately. Just say it. >> Yeah. We talked about compute earlier.
30:03 OpenAI’s Bet on Chips and Cheaper Compute
30:06 Um, a few years ago you made these massive bets on building the next enough.
30:14 >> Well, it's interesting cuz at the time a lot of people were like, that's wild.
30:19 That's obviously an over bet, an over investment. Turns out, yeah, you were
30:23 more right than most people knew. What's a bet today that you're making that is
30:28 contrarian or a lot of people are kind of looking at it with a little bit of
30:32 cautiousness? >> Well, you know, the obvious one is everything
30:37 we're doing for the next generation of compute. I I think people do assume that
30:42 okay, fine, the world has been in a compute constraint and it's about to get better.
30:48 And I I think it probably will get better in the short run. But, as we start to look
30:55 years out, the work with our own chips and future versions where we think we can just be
30:59 much more efficient than anything else out there. Um our plans with robots to be able to help
31:04 uh make racks and data centers more effectively. Our our program to learn
31:09 how to build, you know, better data centers in general. Um and some of the supply chain
31:15 bets we're making. I I I think it is possible that we could get to a world
31:21 where we just have a far, far better way to build compute at a much
31:26 lower cost and a much more much higher efficiency per watt than
31:30 anyone thinks is possible today. But, there's like a lot of bets that
31:33 have to come together for that. >> What's the biggest one right now? The
31:36 chip is still probably the most important single >> thing. Um and it's and it's
31:41 descendants. >> Yeah. Where for on the competitive landscape, where do you feel the most
31:47 pressure right now? >> I mean, it feels like everywhere.
31:50 It's so competitive. >> Yeah. >> Um there are a lot of company I think
31:54 this is good I mean, I think this is like wonderful for users. But, there are a lot of companies
32:00 offering just super high-quality models and products now. And
32:07 uh you know, given that we have I mean, we have great models, but we
32:09 have limited compute and limited resources. really do have to focus,
32:13 choose which areas to focus on. >> How do you make those decisions? Uh you
32:17 know, you launch spaces, for example. Like, how do you have the conviction on
32:22 a specific product or service that is maybe outside of just serving the best
32:25 possible model? >> You know, the biggest advantage we have
32:30 there is that we get the next generation of models before anybody else. And we have time
32:34 internally to use them and build things and see what seems like it's going to
32:38 work. So I think still the best way to do it is to start building things with the new
32:47 models and seeing what new things are you know now possible and valuable.
32:51 >> Can I ask how far ahead your models are internally?
32:55 >> I mean one pretty good example is the math results.
32:58 Like that is definitely something that I don't think any model
33:02 currently widely available can get close to. >> If all the models kind of converge
33:06 around the same performance the frontier, where is open AI's moat?
33:11 >> I kind of think the right way to think about this question generally is that
33:14 the same moats that have worked in the past are the moats that keep working.
33:20 So like has happened many other times you can get a a short-term advantage
33:24 with a new technological or scientific discovery and maybe there's like some
33:28 arguments with RSI that are that some companies try to make about why it's
33:31 going to be different and this is a technology that just the technological
33:35 advantage itself is the core thing. Um >> Do you believe that?
33:39 >> Uh I think if people really pushed on RSI then yes that would be true but I think
33:45 it's a very dangerous thing to push on and um the world is going to need some I mean
33:50 people have talked about this in different phrases but speed limits or
33:54 whatever on how quickly we let RSI go. But the traditional things that work for
33:59 a business having a moat are like you know deep relationships with customers
34:03 integration into users and businesses lives network effects in a product data
34:07 and these kinds of things I expect to continue to work. >> Mhm.
34:11 >> In our case actually I think scale of infrastructure will be a huge one.
34:15 If we can have the most cost effective and the most of it AI infrastructure that's a huge
34:20 Why AI Needs a New Kind of Computer
34:20 competitive advantage. >> Mark Zuckerberg has talked at length
34:26 about the platform risk meta faced while being built on top of Apple's ecosystem
34:31 over the years. Does open AI face that same challenge and and how do you think
34:34 about that? Is that a reason why you're kind of investing so heavily into
34:36 hardware? >> I think Apple really takes their role as a
34:43 as a true platform provider that people are quite dependent on
34:46 very seriously. Um and even though we have like some scuffles with them, um I never feel
34:52 like they're going to like, you know, turn ChatGPT off from the App Store or
34:54 something. Um I think they really understand the sort of critical infrastructure role
35:01 they play. And I think if you follow the rules of their platform, they are
35:08 they are like a a good actor. So, I don't feel that towards Apple.
35:13 And I and that's not why we want to do new kinds of consumer
35:17 hardware. The reason we want to do new kinds of is that I think this is a technology
35:25 that wants a new form factor. Um I really feel it. Like I I I think
35:30 laptops and iPhones are incredible incredible things. Like the greatest
35:33 inventions in the history of human technology. But I feel that like
35:39 AI is constrained to using this thing that was designed for a person, not an AI.
35:44 Like watching an AI use a computer really well is kind of amazing, but then
35:48 it's also a little silly to think that like, you know, a computer is putting
35:51 all this energy into like rendering a UI meant for a person to look at and AI is
35:54 trying to read it rather than just like get the data directly. And then also,
35:59 like although I can have amazing things happen on my computer
36:04 where AI is like looking at what I'm working on in my email or whatever, a lot of my life is
36:08 not in front of my computer. >> Yeah. >> And my AI cannot easily access
36:17 the context of this conversation. And I don't like I guess I could put my phone
36:20 down here and like push the record thing and it would be like kind of weird and kind of
36:25 distracting and you wouldn't be sure when it was recording and when it wasn't
36:27 cuz the screen would go dark and whatever. And if someone else like walks in the
36:31 room and it wouldn't have an understanding of that and that it should not, you know, share
36:35 a secret that was just between the two of us or whatever. If we really do want to move into this
36:41 world of AI reducing our cognitive load and being proactive and having, you know, full
36:47 contextual awareness, I think we would benefit from new hardware for that.
36:50 >> You seem like a technologist at heart, like a builder at heart. Like how how
36:54 cool is it that you get to see the early hardware that you guys are building? You
36:57 get to play with it. It's like this new >> Unbelievable.
37:00 >> It must be so exciting and hard not to share things.
37:04 >> It is. It is. I I I mean, one of the cool There's like
37:07 many cool parts about the job, but one of the coolest is definitely just like
37:11 getting to see the you know, and have a voice in shaping new technology early. So, that's amazing
37:18 for new models, for new products, chips, everything. But, there is
37:21 something special about consumer hardware. >> Yeah. >> There is something about like
37:27 you get to hold a new kind of computer uh >> So cool. >> that is just totally different than like
37:33 an AI model abstractly running on some >> You going to show it to me right after
37:35 this, right? >> I will not, but I but I would love to. Like, this is It is
37:41 Sam on Pressure: “Pick the Big Thing”
37:41 hard. It is hard not to talk about it. >> I want to ask a little bit about you.
37:45 So, I know talking about yourself is a little awkward sometimes, but bear with
37:47 me. >> will be awkward, but let's do it. Um >> I love understanding why people are the
37:54 way they are, and Paul Graham gave you possibly the best compliment I've ever
37:57 heard, which is he called you extremely formidable. And I just I love that quality about
38:05 people. What makes you that way? Is it something you were born with? Is it
38:09 something that you learned over time and you had to hone? >> Um
38:15 I think I was like a very capable kid, but I wouldn't call myself a formidable
38:19 kid. And I do sort of think I somewhat am as an adult. Uh So, it's not like false modesty. I
38:27 My own experience of it was just that I kind of like gradually like built up
38:31 confidence that I could like figure stuff out and do things.
38:36 And that it was not like a it was not like I used to not be like this
38:45 and then I was or I am, but it was kind of like a gradual you like try something hard and it
38:50 works. And then I would be like I would like to scale that up and see if
38:56 we can try like an even harder thing. >> Yeah. But you always had that feeling of let
39:00 me try that next thing. Was the fear of failure not kind of central at all to you? I think
39:06 that prevents a lot of people from doing things. >> One of the things that I think is best
39:11 about Silicon Valley and the kind of Silicon Valley is like a concept and a
39:14 culture not a place is that there is a real culture of people helping each other and supporting
39:22 each other and kind of like a belief that if you invest in the network
39:27 uh, then good things will eventually happen to the whole network and to the whole
39:32 industry and thus to you as like a player in that. And I haven't seen it anywhere else to
39:38 the same degree. Like the kind of for all of the flaws of Silicon Valley
39:44 the culture which are numerous um, this whole thing of like it's hard to know who's going to succeed
39:50 and what ideas are going to work and so the right thing is to like be pretty
39:54 generous and helpful to everyone even if it's not going to like do anything for
39:58 you specifically in the short term as is awesome and a part of that is
40:03 that if people fail you can't hold it against them cuz maybe they're going to
40:06 wildly succeed at their next thing and you know, that's good for all of us.
40:09 >> It's it's actually usually celebrated, too. I love that.
40:12 So I don't >> Like I think here I just got lucky. >> Yeah.
40:16 >> And if I was thrown into any other environment, I probably would have had
40:22 like much more fear fear of failure, but I got out to Silicon Valley as like a
40:26 young person and I saw that a lot of people tried something really hard,
40:31 failed even harder, and then wildly succeeded at their next thing and
40:33 everybody was fine with that. >> Yeah. Um I assume you're under a
40:38 tremendous amount of pressure, competitive pressure. You're building
40:41 one of the most important technologies ever. Like, how does that feel? And like
40:45 how how do you deal with that day-to-day? >> Sometimes really bad and sometimes
40:50 really good. You know, sometimes it's just like oh, I can't get up again and I can't get
40:55 up and do this again. And most of the time it's like I am incredibly lucky to get to do
41:03 what I think is the most interesting and impactful work in the world,
41:06 certainly that I will ever touch. And it uh I mean, it's like one of the coolest
41:12 experiences I could ever imagine in life. It is definitely stressful, but
41:18 you can kind of get used to any like anything. I Like people are just
41:22 unbelievably adaptable to this, so like this just feels like my life now and I
41:26 forgot that life used to be really easy. And now it's going to be hard for a
41:28 while and someday it'll be easy again. I'll probably be kind of bored.
41:31 Um and I the subjective experience of it is like there is some limit to how much like
41:42 stress or bad vibes or whatever you can kind of keep in working emotional space
41:47 and then beyond that something else gets pushed out of the way. So it doesn't
41:51 really get worse. And I am a believer that if you're going to like
41:55 work really hard at something, you may as well pick the big thing cuz
42:00 it's not that much harder or that much more stressful and you won't experience
42:03 it at that much worse and you know, you at least get to like have the
42:06 hopefully the satisfaction of like a bigger positive impact.
42:10 >> I'll say it doesn't show if you if you wake up and you say I don't feel like
42:12 getting out of bed this morning, it never shows. >> It obviously happens.
42:14 >> Yeah. >> Like not that many days, but there are
42:17 there are definitely days where you're just like >> Yeah. Last question for you.
42:18 Why “AI Will Cure Cancer” Isn’t Enough
42:22 Can you offer some words of confidence to people who are AI curious, maybe not quite there.
42:30 Why should they be excited about the future? >> Well, the normal answer to that the
42:36 people in AI give, which I hate, is AI's going to cure cancer.
42:38 >> Yeah, I knew you were going to say that. Yeah. >> And the reason I hate that
42:46 if you dig a little deeper into that, what people are saying is um
42:51 or often saying is that AI is going to cure cancer and it's going to make stuff
42:56 cheaper. And the price of that is going to be human agency and you in control of the future. And
43:06 you're going to have the machines give you all this material abundance, but
43:10 you're not really going to have the ability to have power and voice and
43:15 self-determine your life and choose what to build for other people.
43:19 And I think this is this kind of goes against everything I believe in. So,
43:24 I hope we get a cure for cancer. I mean, that seems like a really
43:27 obviously wonderful thing. But what I really hope people should be
43:30 excited about is that we are able to avoid this industrial revolution trap, really focus
43:41 to have the choice and the freedom and the creativity and the time to do all the
43:48 other things they want in life. And that every decade from now on,
43:53 people look back and say, "I can't believe how much worse those people had
43:57 it and now I have so much more." Not just that I have so much material
43:59 abundance, although I'm fine for people to get that, too, but I have so much
44:03 more autonomy and freedom and ability to do things in this expansive space that I
44:07 get to choose. I think that's what we owe people. I think we can deliver that.
44:12 I think both of the ways that I I I have worried about things going very wrong,
44:15 like either and there's like a loss of control accident to AI or an intentional
44:20 loss of control, some lab says I'm going to push the button on RSI to make sure
44:23 we have the power. Uh or, we talked about this earlier, we get like too much power power
44:28 concentration in the hands of a few people that control too much of the AI and are
44:33 making the decisions. Like, I think we can avoid both of those. I think we can
44:36 navigate a path down the middle here where people's lives and individual free
44:41 will and autonomy just get up-leveled and up-leveled and up-leveled. And
44:45 I think that future is already here in some ways. It's just very It's so new
44:50 that it's very poorly distributed. I think you said like 1% of the people
44:53 using most of the tokens or something. >> Yeah. >> I think if we can just take what's
44:56 working today for the early adopters and get a lot more people to embrace this,
45:00 we'll already be a significant fraction of the way there. >> I appreciate your vision.
45:03 >> Thank you. >> Thank you, Sam. Thanks for spending time
45:05 with me. >> I enjoyed it.