0:03 We're talking uh Facebook today, but I think we'll go a little broader in terms
0:07 of what's impacting that as well. >> This stuff is so much more simple than
0:11 SEO. The days of copy and pasting on Facebook are over as from this month.
0:16 >> What type of revenue can people look at when it comes to moving into a Facebook
0:19 environment, running a bunch of pages? >> I've made $750,000 organically, but
0:23 that's [music] across all. If you're just starting out, you you'll maybe make
0:27 $10 a day. But as you scale up, potential is there to make 2030,000 a
0:30 month. >> I've talked to a lot of people that have kind of given up on trying to get their
0:36 page into the monetization program because they don't understand it.
0:40 >> Highquality, organic, original content. That that's what Facebook wants and
0:43 that's what it's going to reward people for. >> What What type of approach are you
0:46 taking to buying those followers for? So, >> we found out some techniques. You can
0:50 actually buy followers, quality followers in the US for around about a
0:54 cent. Is there a conflict of interest in terms of publishing the same type of
0:55 stuff? >> There's no such thing as oversaturation. You can have 10,000 camping pages and
1:01 you'll do absolutely fine. >> What is upsetting to Facebook?
1:11 >> All right, welcome back to the Niche Proceeds podcast. My name is Jared
1:15 Bowman. Today we have a returning guest, Andy Scrago with um hikeyoulikes.com.
1:20 Andy, welcome back. >> Hey, it's good to be back Jared. Nice to
1:22 see you again. >> Good to see you as well. You know, your
1:26 um episode Oh, I should have pulled it up. Probably two years ago, two and a
1:28 half years ago, maybe. >> Yeah, about >> Yeah, two years ago, summertime. I
1:32 remember summertime. A little bit different seasons right now, but
1:35 >> it was uh it was it was really wellreceived. One of the most popular
1:37 ones of the year. We got a lot of people commenting, a lot of questions on it.
1:41 And a lot has changed in the landscape. >> Yeah. >> Uh these last years have been crazy.
1:45 >> Each of these years, the last couple years has been crazy and now we've got
1:48 to try to catch up on a couple of them. But we're talking uh Facebook today. But
1:52 I think we'll go a little broader in terms of what's impacting that as well.
1:57 Before we get into, you know, today's topic, all that. Catch us up on who you
2:00 are, especially for people who might not have heard the first episode. We will
2:03 link to it, but just give us a little backstory on yourself.
2:07 >> Yeah. So, I've been involved in web development and SEO for about well over
2:12 20 years, but I got into Facebook about 12 years ago, and I got pretty obsessed
2:16 with it. It was it was such a quick way to kind of make money online at the
2:20 time. So back then it was basically merchandise and links is what we were
2:24 making money from. So everything from linking to a monetized website to I used
2:30 to sell t-shirts on then um affiliate links that kind of thing. And over 12
2:34 years obviously has evolved massively to to the point we're at now where it's
2:38 changed a lot. >> I mean I'll kind of summarize last time
2:44 for us just to give us a little context. We talked about and you really broke
2:48 down some of the strategies, most of the strategies you were using to drive
2:51 millions of visitors, pure Facebook organic traffic. >> Um, we got into why SEO style posts
2:57 weren't working there. They don't work there. This was right after HCU. So, a
3:01 lot of people looking, what do I do with my HCU, my SEO posts that are now no
3:06 longer getting organic traffic perhaps. Um, so we talked about, you know, h how
3:10 to adapt that content. um how to get your first 10,000 uh followers, link and
3:15 comment, these types of things. So, I'd say today we're picking up where we left
3:18 off, but there's a lot of new stuff. We've got the the the new content
3:23 monetization program, we've got AI, content production, and really where is
3:27 that at in terms of Facebook. Um we'll get into your numbers, but maybe talk
3:31 from your vantage point about where we're picking up from that last
3:34 interview two and a half years ago. What has changed and what do we need to talk
3:38 about today from a high level? Yeah. So two years ago, people are very focused
3:43 on getting their traffic from Facebook rather than Google because obviously the
3:46 HCU hit and there was all these updates to Google. So most people are actually
3:50 interested in getting traffic from Facebook. But they just then they
3:56 introduced the performance bonus. So it was just starting to come around about
4:02 2024 summer 2024. I started seeing people earning six grand a month just
4:07 just from that not not from the links. >> So they were basically doubling up the
4:11 traffic. They were doubling up their revenue from traffic to bonuses. So what
4:15 happened then is that this content monetization came about from performance
4:19 bonus. They basically rebranded it and just started making this thing more and
4:23 more of of a thing. I mean it's still in beta at the moment but it's about to go
4:28 into production I'm sure this year maybe early next year. And people are really
4:31 starting to wake up and notice because this is making Facebook more like
4:35 YouTube where you become a content creator and you get rewarded for putting
4:39 it putting some original content on there. >> So that's really been my focus and last
4:44 year it's really focused on content monetization more so than links.
4:49 >> Tell us where you're at in terms of Facebook and and just to give people
4:52 context in terms of what you're involved in. um share it however you want.
4:56 Whether it's in terms of dollars, whether it's in terms of number of of of
5:00 of Facebook, uh you know, pages, groups you're running, whatever it is, give us
5:03 some context so we can go into this understanding where you're coming at it
5:05 from. >> I like to keep things really simple. I just run pages. I don't really run
5:11 groups. I've got around 25 pages across different niches. So, I was always
5:16 involved in quizzes for kind of the past six, seven years and viral sites. So,
5:19 like general viral pages, that kind of thing. So the quizzes are basically the
5:23 thing that I've been doing the the most, but they they've actually been doing
5:27 really well. So under content monetization, I've been making three
5:30 times the revenue on the post and I have been for the links. So I start thinking
5:35 maybe I should branch out into other niches, which is what I'm doing now. So
5:38 there's some really good niches you you can do for content monetization that may
5:43 not necessarily be so good for links. So stuff like nostalgia, kind of fishing,
5:48 hobbies, that kind of thing that work really well. you get so much engagement,
5:51 you can actually make some some really good money on Facebook itself and you
5:55 don't have to worry about building a website or anything like that.
5:59 >> So, I think we'll get into keeping people on Facebook versus pushing people
6:02 off of Facebook and the different approaches there. From a high level,
6:06 like what type of um what type of revenue are you talking about from like
6:09 25 pages? Because I know that's taking you a long time to build up. So, to be
6:12 fair, like if if you're just listening to this and you've got one page, um
6:15 that's going to be very different. But what what type of revenue can people
6:20 look at when it comes to moving into a Facebook environment running a bunch of
6:23 pages? >> Well, it's been a bit of a moving target because they kind of change stuff all
6:27 the time, especially because it's in beta. But what we're seeing is for
6:30 around a million views, people are earning about $100, which doesn't it
6:34 sounds like a lot of million views, but on Facebook, you know, I got a million
6:38 views on one reel the other week over 24 hours. So, so the potential there is to
6:43 get millions of views a day across multiple pages. So, if you're just
6:47 starting out, you you'll maybe make $10 $20 a day, but as you scale up, the
6:52 potential is there to make 20 $30,000 a month. I mean, there's some people
6:56 making six figures a year at the moment. There's maybe more. Some of them are in
7:03 my group, but one person got 765 for for one post. So, the potential is
7:07 there to earn really good money. You don't have to build a website. So, for a
7:09 lot of people, that was the kind of barrier to doing Facebook traffic, but
7:13 now that's gone. You can just earn traffic directly from content on
7:16 Facebook. >> Hey everyone, Jared here. Just a quick word before we get back into the
7:21 interview. So, we talk a lot on this show about how AI is reshaping search.
7:26 And the reality is if tools like Chat GPT, Perplexity, or Google's AI don't
7:30 recognize your brand, you're going to be increasingly invisible going forward. As
7:34 you might know, I run a digital marketing agency called 2011 Creative.
7:37 And my team and I just built something brand new, the GEO Snapshot Audit. It
7:42 shows how AI is seeing your business across five essential categories and
7:46 what's missing so you can start showing up in AIdriven results. For a limited
7:51 time, I'm offering Niche Pursuits listeners a free GEO snapshot complete
7:55 with your visibility score and next steps on how to improve it. So grab
8:03 Again, that's Spots are limited, so don't wait to grab yours now. All right, back to the
8:14 podcast. Is there a bit of a standard? You got 25. Are they incredibly variable in
8:20 terms of what they earn, or is there some sort of norm of sorts where they land after a
8:26 period of time? >> The theory is, and it's not been proven,
8:30 that if you're in a niche like auto or finance where there is a potential to
8:34 make money, then you get paid more. But it's not proven. I've actually seen like
8:39 fishing pages that do really well. So, I don't think it's so much like SEO where
8:44 you have to be in like very high paying niches. I think it's more complex than
8:49 that. But yeah, I'm generally seeing higher quality pages with with no um
8:54 kind of restrictions on the page tend to earn most. That's what I'm seeing. So,
8:58 high quality organic um original content that that's what Facebook wants and that's what it's
9:05 going to reward people for. You can't just copy content from a different page
9:07 and put it on anymore. It's not going to work. They've got an algorithm change
9:12 that rewards originality very strongly. And even today, I've seen a post on
9:16 Twitter. Somebody's figured out that the originality scoring is very strong. So,
9:22 the days of copy and pasting on Facebook are over as from this month.
9:27 And where where are you at in terms of earnings or in terms of revenue when it
9:30 I know there's a lot of you know there's costs that go into it but in terms of
9:34 the content monetization program 25 sites where does that land for you?
9:38 >> Almost every page has been invited even ones with about 12,000 followers and on
9:44 those my best pages they earn about maybe $10 for 100k views. So it's it's it's
9:51 pretty good. I mean it's thousands of months and it's growing. I'm actively
9:54 building more pages and niches are good for content monetization, which is the
9:59 best thing to do, you know, to try and figure out what pages are are the
10:02 easiest to create original content for and and paid pretty good. And then just
10:05 double down because you need to scale horizontally. You need about five to 10
10:09 pages to actually earn thousands a month. And you know, but it's quite
10:13 quite straightforward. As I said on my previous podcast, it's this stuff is so
10:17 much more simple than SEO. There's so much less to worry about. It's really,
10:21 it's very good fun because you're basically just a pure content creator
10:25 and you can focus on creating quality original content and it's not so
10:30 technical. Not anymore. >> Okay. So, let's let's get into the the
10:33 nitty-gritty of it and and maybe the best place to start is the, you know,
10:38 the content monetization program. Uh, it's under it's undergone a lot of
10:41 changes. A lot of people will be familiar with the idea of trying to get
10:46 a Facebook page to be monetized by them. And again, the idea there is then that
10:50 Facebook is paying you based on the amount of traffic that you're
10:53 generating, the amount of clicks that your posts are getting, the amount of
10:55 engagement they're getting. That's gone through a lot of changes. A lot of
10:58 people, I will say, I'm just going to say this from the outside. I've talked
11:00 to a lot of people that have kind of given up on trying to [clears throat]
11:04 get their page into the monetization program because they don't understand
11:07 it. They don't understand what triggers happen. So maybe >> yes, what's changed? Yes. Where are we
11:12 at now? But also talk to talk to that person who's maybe a bit frustrated in
11:16 terms of not understanding what it looks like to get their page accepted.
11:20 >> Yeah. So basically, you need to have a page that's um that's healthy to start
11:24 with. So if you've got a history of violations on Facebook, you're probably
11:28 not going to get accepted. You need to grow the page in the way that you would
11:32 grow it for traffic. So you basically need to buy followers up to 10 12,000,
11:37 which is actually not very expensive these days. We found out some techniques
11:41 you can actually buy followers, quality followers in US for around about a cent.
11:44 So that's really good. That means you can grow the pages quite cheaply and
11:49 quite quickly. So the main thing is that you need to be posting uh consistently
11:53 engaging content. That seems to be the biggest problem. So people who are
11:58 actually finding old pages and not getting accepted into content
12:01 monetization, the best thing to do is start posting original content. That
12:05 seems to be the thing that's getting the invites. And I think the reason I got
12:09 invites on all of my pages was because I was consistently posting original
12:13 content. So that that's the main thing to do. Just be active on Facebook and
12:17 make sure you have enough followers. Those seem to be the two biggest things
12:21 that we're seeing at the moment. And it can be frustrating. You do have to wait.
12:25 It is an invite program, but I've seen that people that actually have enough
12:30 followers and do post are getting those invites eventually. Is it a lot of people will experience a
12:36 page that gets a viral, you know, a post will go viral and it will really pad the
12:41 stats in terms of um views and potentially, you know, the engagement
12:45 metrics. Um, is it more a case of building that consistent engagement on a
12:49 per post basis that helps you get accepted? >> Yeah. Yeah. I mean, you have to have a
12:53 certain amount of engagement. If you've got zero engagement on every post,
12:56 you're not going to get invited. But, I mean, the thing is with Facebook, it's
13:00 it's a case of you're always chasing those viral posts. So, what I'm looking
13:04 for is one or two viral posts a day because that makes 95% of of the of the
13:09 income. It makes 95% of the new followers to the page. But, I mean, just
13:12 to get invited, you're going to have to make sure you're getting a decent amount
13:17 of engagement on every post. And even if that means dropping back to maybe I
13:22 mean, six to 12 posts a day is plenty to get invited. So, you don't have to put
13:26 24 posts a day on, not not if you just want to get invited onto the program.
13:29 It's also um quite easy to get kicked off of it. So, you want to make sure
13:33 that you you're very white hat because when you get kicked off, it's the
13:36 biggest suck. So, you want to make sure that you're very white hat and and you
13:39 need to avoid anything that's going to be upsetting to Facebook. And they also
13:45 don't like certain things like uh like videos made from images that don't
13:48 really move, that kind of thing. That's also going to get you demonetized. So,
13:52 it's good to know that the rules before you get into this so you don't
13:55 accidentally get kicked off of it because you're not getting invited back
13:58 on if you are, especially been waiting a couple of months, you know.
14:02 What is I know there's no typical but just to give people a framework. I'm
14:06 starting today or I've been running a page but doing it all wrong. Not
14:09 breaking rules but not doing the proper engagement tactics. Like if I'm posting
14:14 6 to 12 a day assuming I'm doing a decent job at creating original content.
14:18 Are we talking months or are we has that changed since the program has has
14:20 changed? Is it >> changing constantly? But they've they
14:24 we're way more rapid now in the last couple of months than they have been for
14:28 years. So, so many people in my mastermind are saying, "Oh, I've finally
14:32 been invited." And and then, you know, it it's really happening now for people
14:35 and and I've seen that you you don't need a huge amount of posts or a huge
14:39 amount of followers anymore that you used to have to have. So, I think for
14:43 people who are who are joining now, they're going to be maybe two to three
14:46 weeks as long as they're posting content, you know, as long as the page
14:50 is more than kind of 12K followers. That's what I've seen. So, I mean, some
14:54 of my pages are like 14K and they're all all been invited. time.
14:58 >> So, to get started, we need we need to buy our way to 10,000. The reason is
15:01 because it's quicker, because it's easier. It's way quicker. Do I need to
15:05 do any targeting when I do this? You know, because here's a question I I hear
15:08 from time to time, and I think it's a valid question. It's a question I've
15:13 had. Like, if I'm doing a uh Facebook page all about hiking, I'll put that out
15:15 there because I'm I'm going to go for a hike this afternoon, and I'm doing one
15:19 all about hiking. Um, do I need to target people who are interested in
15:23 hiking so once I hit that 10 12,000 they are going to be engaging with my content
15:27 or am I getting a page to 10 to 12,000 because that's what Facebook needs to
15:30 even think about accepting me and then their algorithm will do the work of
15:33 finding all the people to engage with it. >> Yeah, you don't want to go too broad.
15:36 You don't want to go too narrow. So you want to kind of basically target people
15:40 who are into hiking for sure, but don't get too niche about it. So we want to we
15:45 want to get our followers um from tier one countries as well. So, so US is
15:49 going to pay more content monetization than say South America, maybe Brazil or
15:53 somewhere like that. So, you're still looking for good quality followers that
15:56 you're buying directly from Facebook. You're not buying them from some third
16:00 party kind of bot traffic and stuff like that. So, it's more difficult when you
16:05 talk about stuff like nostalgia or viral stuff. Um because then it's
16:09 really hard to target people. >> Yeah. Like quizzes. I mean, that would
16:11 be hard to target people. >> Yeah, it's really hard to target. So,
16:16 you tend to target age ages in in certain countries. That's really all you
16:20 can do. Um, but it's much easier if if you have like a hiking page, a camping
16:25 page, a fishing page. I've seen a huge amount of success in in those outdoor
16:30 niches. Uh, even for like shops and outdoor shops been posting stuff and
16:34 then really banking from content monetization as a kind of side side
16:39 hustle. So, it's Yeah, but you do have to kind of keep those followers as good
16:43 quality as you can. So, but once you bought the first 10,000, you don't need
16:47 to spend any more money. You're going to grow organically from there. And one
16:51 post can can bring you, you know, thousands of new followers overnight.
16:55 So, it happens quite quickly on once you've got the hang of posting the kind
16:58 of content that resonates. So, obviously, if you buy 10,000 people that
17:03 are into hiking, make sure you post hiking content. Don't go posting random
17:07 quizzes and and stuff from entertainment. It's not going to work
17:10 out. And once they're hooked on the kind of content you put on, they're very hard
17:15 to kind of change direction. So what happens is your content ends up looking
17:20 very similar. And that's fine. Most pages content is similar if it's
17:24 successful. >> I don't want to get too deep into it because I want to focus on some of the
17:29 other things we have. But general tips at the advertising side of things. I say
17:34 ad, but buying followers, doing it for a price that's really reasonable. What
17:37 type of content? What type of ad? What type of are what what type of approach
17:40 are you taking to buying those followers for because it is about economics,
17:43 right? You don't want to spend a ton of money out of the gate on that.
17:47 >> No. Well, you need to target not too broad, not too narrow. So, you're
17:51 talking maybe 50 to 100 million potential people. When you when you run
17:54 the ads, you'll see a a gauge that tells how many people you're targeting. So, I
17:59 mean, at the moment, Facebook's pretty good at broad targeting. So, even if you
18:02 go very broad with hiking, you're still probably going to going to do okay. the
18:06 biggest leave you've got is a creator because the the advert image and I would
18:10 just use just just use an image. Don't worry about video. Um that's the thing
18:13 that's going to pre-qualify the audience. So obviously you want to use a
18:17 hiking person. The AI is great for this. So just use a sora or midjourney image.
18:23 The thing we found that drives the cost down is actually a text at the top
18:28 saying do you love hiking? And then at the bottom you say press the thumb and
18:31 you have a little finger pointing down towards the follow button as it appears
18:34 on the mobile phone because most people on Facebook are on mobile and that
18:39 simple trick really is actually the thing that's driving sub two cents
18:44 click. So you can kind of go deeper into it but the best thing to do is keep it
18:47 simple. You know that buying the page followers should be an extremely simple
18:51 process and it's something that you kind of want to not overthink
18:58 work too by the way. I mean, we could do an entire I feel like we could do an entire episode just
19:04 on that. And I I would actually like to do that, but let's stick to the agenda
19:06 for today. I don't want to bury you with too many questions about that. I I want
19:09 to talk about something you've already said three or four times. It's in our
19:13 agenda, and it's this idea of original content, almost segueing into, hey,
19:17 we've we've got our 10,000 followers. Let's let's move on from that.
19:22 >> So, that's a that's an open-ended term, original content, good high quality
19:26 content, right? high quality. Like in the past, we've been taught to emulate
19:29 successful pages, right? Hey, you're in the hiking niche. Go look at what other
19:33 hiking content is working well, post a lot of that same stuff. Like, has much
19:37 changed in that world? Um, what what is high quality right now?
19:41 >> Well, the thing about Facebook is it's one of the few platforms that's not not
19:47 going actually not reducing AI. So, we have a golden opportunity here. we we we
19:51 can use AI and that's really two things have come together over the past year or
19:55 so is that the content monetization's come along and it pays well and we have
20:01 AI so it's really I mean I I use a $20 a month Sora subscription which I can make
20:05 unlimited content so the way is still to go from what works so if you're in the
20:10 camping niche I would find a successful camping page like camperville which has
20:15 been really blowing up of AI content then what I do is basically feet I will
20:19 download those images from the page, but I will not take those images and put
20:22 them onto my pages. I mean, that's basically stealing content and now you
20:26 can't do that on Facebook anyway. What I do is I upload them to Chat TP. I ask it
20:31 to create a sora prompt for an image or a real and then I'll actually create the
20:35 image from that. So, you've got the same context, the same message, possibly I
20:39 might change the message and then I'm creating my own content and that's
20:43 original and laugh and that's kind of my tactic at the moment. And you can do
20:47 that like I sat down last Sunday and made about 300 which is enough for a
20:51 month or so at least of original content. By original you can repost your
20:55 own stuff >> but you know you can repost your own stuff over and over again that will
20:59 still be original. It's when you take it from other pages it's not original.
21:05 What does a um what when it comes to this uh this approach is that what's
21:10 driving most of your success right now is an AIdriven approach of undoing
21:15 what's working well and if >> AI has changed everything.
21:17 >> Yeah. >> So for example with with Toby post that's text on image background
21:23 extremely successful they're just text posts but you get paid for them. I mean,
21:29 you get paid on my own pages. The most profitable ones are images, the post
21:33 type, then it's reals, then it's Tobies, but they're just text. So, they're so
21:37 easy to do. So, what I'll do is if I find a page that's successful with these
21:41 text posts, I'll basically copy off maybe 25, feed those into Chat GDP and
21:47 ask it to create 25 more but different. And then if you say, "Okay, I want these
21:51 for the hiking niche. Create me 50 in hiking niche." You you've got your
21:54 content. It's as easy as that. And then you can post that onto your what I
21:58 recommend doing you got a brand new hiking page you got 10,000 followers
22:02 just post Toby post for the first month free tack GDP just make sure you don't
22:07 use any guesswork don't use your intuition go and find a successful
22:12 outdoor page basically copy what they're doing feed that through the AI system to
22:17 create brand new content that's similar but different that is the best approach
22:22 right now and try and schedule this every hour even on a page a 10K because
22:27 content monetization is kind of a numbers game as well. So with links you
22:32 can get away with when I drive links to say quiz sites I could get away with
22:35 about six links a day to drive quite a lot of traffic but with content
22:38 monetization you want to really ramp up your posting frequency up to 48 times a
22:44 day as long as it's engaging content >> right >> so obviously you'll make more money
22:50 >> so AI AI plus content monetization is the that's the golden opportunity at the
22:53 moment >> and is that the focus for most people right now is hey I don't want to say
22:59 forget the links but the focus, right? The primary driver is let's keep people
23:03 on the platform. Let's go for content monetization. And that means posting
23:07 tons of engaging content. Don't worry about the links. Keep people there and
23:11 find what works and do it over and over and over again >> to a certain extent. But I found that if
23:16 you add a link into an image in the first comment actually increases reach.
23:20 >> So you can actually earn more by adding links into the first comment. And some
23:24 people have been saying this that goes against everything we we've known so far
23:28 that adding a link into the status area above an image is actually increasing
23:32 content monetization. So at the moment it's a real playground of experiments to
23:36 try and figure out what works. Obviously they Facebook they're changing the
23:40 goalpost all the time >> but kind of less than they were before.
23:43 They're kind of almost at production stage where they're going to stop
23:46 tweaking everything and we can kind of get more science on this and less
23:51 guesswork. But what we've seen is that you you can use a mix of links and
23:54 content monetization. It doesn't hurt the content monetization to send traffic
24:00 as well. You're increasing your revenue. >> Let's get a little bit into your
24:04 workflow. If you could talk about a successful workflow, maybe almost find
24:09 uh uh continuing along the timeline we've been discussing where we've gotten
24:13 our page to 10,000 likes. We've moved on from that. We've started to create
24:16 content. We figured out how to do that by finding what's working really well,
24:21 using AI to help us in terms of not guessing, but focusing on what's working
24:25 and then trying to emulate that in our page. What's a workflow look like for
24:28 you? You kind of hinted at it. You're like, "Hey, I just did this and that's
24:30 that's going to be a month's worth of content right there." Like, what's a
24:34 workflow look like for you with AI with the new content monetization program
24:37 going forward? >> So, obviously, we want to automate as
24:41 much as we can. So, what I'll do is create I'll think of everything as in
24:45 like buckets. It's like content buckets. So, I've got a bucket of reals and I've
24:48 got a bucket of Toby poster in a spreadsheet and I've got a bucket of
24:53 images. So, you have to systemize stuff because you're going to be posting
24:56 thousands of pieces of content. So, if you don't have a system, it's not going
24:59 to work for you when you start scaling that is. So, basically, I'll sit down
25:03 and I'll always bulk generate kind of 50 to even 500 pieces of content at a time.
25:08 So, I don't want to use any guess work. So, whatever niche I'm in, I'm going to
25:13 go to look at some other pages, and I use a tool called Ampify, which is just
25:18 a it based bas Facebook will not let you access uh any metrics on posts via the
25:23 API, the Facebook API. We used to do that a lot, but that all changed a few
25:27 years ago. So, I use a tool called post Facebook post scraper on amplify. And it
25:31 basically, it's like when you're looking for a timeline on Facebook, say, "Oh,
25:34 that's gone viral. That's gal." All this does is just put it into a spreadsheet
25:38 for you. You know, you can do like a thousand posts. Then I'm going to put
25:41 that into a Google sheet and I'm going to basically see which one's the most
25:46 viral by sorting this sorting the sheets by the most viral post. Then I'll take
25:50 the top 25 and if they're images, I'm going to use those. So like Toby post
25:54 and that kind of thing. I don't really worry about links um and reals as well.
25:59 So I'm going to create try and create about 250 images in that niche and
26:04 that's going to be my content for the next maybe three to six months on that
26:10 page. So the basic workflow is once those are in spreadsheet I'm going to
26:15 use post planner bulk upload CSV file and that's going to upload 3 days to a
26:20 week's worth of content so I can then walk away from that and go on and do the
26:25 next thing. So, I'll grow a page to about 40 50,000 followers organically from 10,000. Then
26:33 I'm going to scale horizontally. So, what that means is if you're saying the
26:37 camping niche, I might do a wild camping page. So, it's a subniche of the niche.
26:42 So, if I've got a fishing page, I might do a a river fishing page, but it's it's
26:47 close enough. So, you want to scale out to about three three to five pages in
26:51 that niche. And the thing is, you can use the same content on those pages, or
26:55 you can just add some more, like maybe 100 more reels or 100 more uh images to
26:59 that post. And I'm going to basically schedule to all of them, but mix it up.
27:03 So, last thing you want to do is schedule the same post to five pages at
27:07 the same time. That's going to look spammy. So, we just mix up and
27:11 spreadsheet. And that's basically how I grow horizontally across different
27:15 niches. So, you kind of want to get all your pages up to well over 50,000. Then,
27:18 you're going to see some really good income. Okay. So, you talked about having pages,
27:26 multiple pages in one niche, uh, one broad niche. Now, you talked also about
27:29 originality. Is there a conflict of interest in terms of publishing the same
27:33 type of stuff into different pages of yours, or does Facebook somehow
27:37 determine that these are all part of the same um broadcaster?
27:41 >> No, it it doesn't work like that. I mean, it it's kind of original but
27:47 similar looking. So, um, you'll notice that the the kind of content you you'll
27:51 end up posting that people respond to will look very similar. Um, it might be
27:55 kind of with fishing, it might be a certain kind of people being seeing a
28:01 lot of success with with comedy in in so like funny camping posts and stuff.
28:05 Funny dog post, dog niche is really good. By the way, there's no such thing
28:10 as oversaturation. You can have 10,000 camping pages and you'll do absolutely
28:14 fine. It's like there it's three over three billion people and they're all
28:18 hungry for good content. So it's not like SEO where you're trying to get to
28:21 number one. You're just trying to basically put out a lot of content. So
28:28 yeah, I mean it's it's it needs to be different enough that than other posts,
28:33 but it's only like a 10 to 20% difference. I've seen I've seen people
28:36 report that >> they they tweaked the font on on a meme
28:42 and and that's probably going to be enough. I mean, we don't know for sure.
28:47 I think it's about 20% original until we sort of start getting more signals from
28:50 Facebook about what originality means. They'll probably change the thresholds
28:54 anyway, but I just try and make stuff. You can clearly see it's different. But
28:59 the message, the captions that people are using at the moment are old captions
29:02 that we've been posting for the last decade. Yeah. >> So, the same in fact there's there's
29:07 some pages I've been studying recently and what they do is they they create
29:11 this kind of AI kind of like a gorilla like a cuddly gorilla in a real or an
29:16 image and they put the the most dusty old caption on top and they're doing
29:21 crazy stuff. So, like if you think about a page with 100,000 followers, well,
29:25 they're getting 100,000 reactions on these posts. So, that's 100% engagement
29:30 ratio. So, you can imagine the amount they're making. I mean, they're getting
29:35 millions, tens of millions of views on every single post, but they're just
29:38 taking an old caption and they're giving it a modern a modern layout and a
29:43 modern, you know, theme using AI. And that that's a great thing to do. You
29:45 don't have to reinvent the wheel. You just you're just presenting an effective
29:50 viral caption in in a new format, basically. And again, if you're listening and
29:56 you're watching me ask questions but not ask other questions, a lot of that is
30:01 strategic because we've had Andy on a couple years ago and he got super into
30:04 the weeds. And so again, I just want to encourage you go back and listen to
30:07 that. I'm trying to ask questions about what's changed, what's different,
30:10 utilizing AI in a different way. But I'm also leaving out some questions because
30:14 we covered it in depth two years ago. So >> just a reminder, go back and listen to
30:18 that, too, if you're if you're wondering about some of the gaps there. And a gap,
30:21 something that's changed a lot is image and video creation years ago. Um, and
30:27 forgive me, I I I I might get it exactly wrong, but there was Canva involved.
30:30 There was stock images involved. There was your own photography involved. There
30:33 was adding your overlays on top of things. It was a huge portion of the
30:37 workflow. And you've alluded to really using AI for that. Talk through how
30:41 we're actually getting images nowadays with the use of of AI and even videos to
30:45 some degree. >> Canvas taken a bit of a back seat. So it's only been in the last six months
30:51 we've been able to render reliable text over image and video and that that's
30:54 because of the tool. I used to use midjourney but it can never do text
30:57 >> right >> now with Sora which people think is a
31:01 video actually has a very powerful image generator. >> It's [clears throat] it's the same image
31:06 generate if you go into chat GDP and you um you put in generate me an image it's
31:10 the same thing as that but it's in its own kind of desk yeah it own kind of
31:14 navigational desktop thing. So basically what we do is we we can take an image a
31:19 meme with text and we can feed that into sor and it will produce perfect text
31:23 which we've only been able to do for the last kind of six months or so. So that's
31:27 really been a massive game changer because one of the biggest pains I've
31:31 had is is adding text overlays and it creates you can do it but you need tons
31:35 of code or expensive tools and stuff like that or you have to do it have to
31:39 hire a VA to do it one by one where AI has absolutely changed the game. you can
31:43 specify the different fonts or the meme styles and that kind of thing. So, for
31:47 the most part, Sora is actually the thing that's allowing me to to produce
31:53 bulk uh content with the text on top and not having to go into Canva and do it.
31:57 It's the same with reals and stuff. So, the the the video is less reliable. So,
32:02 people are still having to use Canva to put text over real or Camtasia or
32:06 something like that, some video editing software. But I'm sure that within the
32:10 next 6 months, you'll be able to do pretty perfect video with text on top as
32:15 well. So, it's it's all changing so fast, but it's it's the easiest thing at
32:19 the moment to actually create those kind of images and reals that are extremely
32:24 effective on Facebook. >> And I think that's important to keep in
32:26 mind like it's the concepts that people need to learn. We've hit a point where
32:31 AI can successfully do text over image, where they can successfully kind of
32:34 blend the whole thing. That hasn't been the case for a while. Whether it's Sora
32:37 at the time of you listening to this, whether it's something that's changed or
32:41 different, maybe midjourney has caught up, who knows? But I think it's kind of
32:44 the concepts of what can and can't be used right now. And a couple years ago,
32:48 that was not the case, you know. >> Um, >> let let me ask you a bit about um
32:56 um how h how the monetization side of things is working nowadays. We we
32:59 haven't really touched on monetization. It's been kind of this you're going to
33:02 earn money if you do these things, right? No. How does that look for a page
33:08 that's growing and just trying to walk people through what to expect uh within
33:12 you know within the range of of understanding that's very um quite
33:15 variable. >> Yeah. I mean the the worst part is waiting for the invite and and you don't
33:22 know if you got some sort of shadow ban. So basically Facebook never forgets and
33:26 I've I've just been hit hit on one of my pages for for reals because I I did
33:30 something I wasn't supposed to about seven years ago. So people people
33:35 forget, you know, that's why it makes it difficult to buy Facebook pages because
33:38 you don't really know what's happened in the past. It's always best to make them
33:41 from scratch and then you know that they're clean and healthy. So assuming
33:44 the page is healthy, you just have to wait for that monetization. Then as soon
33:50 as you get it, it's actually um quite simple that they basically add up the
33:54 the money you've earned on each post and you get a monthly uh payment to your
33:59 bank. So that side of the stuff has been this kind of you do have to set up your
34:03 bank details and stuff but yeah it's really straightforward and and really
34:07 they've been quite reliable at paying as well. So far, >> the bulk of your income, would you say
34:15 it's from viral content, content that goes viral, that's where kind of if you
34:18 were to look at the 8020 of it, or is it um, you know, is that less of where the
34:23 income comes? Or do you not even know, you know, is it just a check at the end
34:25 of the month and you're like, well, >> I got this many views this month and I
34:28 this much money. >> Yeah, that they're still rolling out
34:32 that you only were able to see it on mobile until about four months ago. And
34:37 now you can actually see how much you've earned on every post which is very
34:39 insightful because without that we wouldn't really know what if we're what
34:44 we're doing is right. So in the new pages experiment experience in in in the
34:49 latest version of when you go if you switch into your page and you go into
34:53 your page metrics if it's up to date you're going to have a sortable table
34:59 and you can sort by uh monetization. So that's a huge deal because then you
35:02 can look at your top 25 earning post and say, "What did I do right?" Because you
35:05 always want to double down on what works. And what you need to do is
35:08 basically cut anything that doesn't work. So over every kind of couple of
35:13 weeks or month, I'll go through all of my posts in the back end and I'll
35:17 basically say, I'm not posting these again. These 20% can can be killed, but
35:22 these 20% I've made the most money from. How can I make 20 more of those for each
35:27 one? So that that's the process I go for and that's how to maximize earnings
35:31 because you know and that's how everything ends up looking kind of
35:35 similar because your audience gets very hooked on a certain kind of content.
35:39 You're not going to be doing wildcard stuff. Um you can do some experiments
35:44 like 20% of your timeline can be an experiment but for the most part you're
35:47 feeding your audience what it is they want to see. So v variations on that.
35:51 Mhm. >> Um, how have you found video content to perform, especially now that you're able
35:56 to look at how it's performing on the monetization side of things? Uh, is it
36:00 does it drive a lot more engagement? Does it drive a lot more monetization
36:03 like or both? >> Yeah, reels are massive. In fact, they're they're the second biggest
36:09 earner on my pages and they get insane reach. The reach is very fast with reals
36:12 because they exist in their own timeline. So you see the normal timeline
36:16 on Facebook. Well, they're in a little horizontal timeline all in their own.
36:21 And that brings in like 95 plus% nonfollowers. So you can imagine that your the normal
36:28 ratio is kind of between 10 and 90% followers on post, but with reals, it's
36:32 almost always 90% nonfollowers who haven't seen your page yet. So it's the
36:37 best thing to actually bring in new followers is is posting reals. The only
36:42 downside to reals at the moment is it's so easy to get slapped for them. So if
36:46 you've got any kind of background music, man, it's just a minefield. They at the
36:51 moment they said you can't have reals that don't have enough animation in
36:54 them. So if you got like a static background with text on top, okay, you
36:59 you you're going to lose your content monetization and your reach is going to
37:03 go down. And once you've got one post that's been kind of slapped, then the
37:08 other post will kind of not be, you know, they won't get a reje and also if
37:13 you have like slideshows there's quite a few there's like five or
37:17 six real types they don't like at the moment so they do have to be pretty good
37:23 you know they do have to be like an actual kind of film but again with with
37:28 AI with V3 for example which is producing the best ress at the moment
37:33 but is quite expensive that's that's what they want they don't want this kind
37:38 of old-fashioned kind of content >> probably good time. My first thing I
37:43 wrote down from my notes so far is what is upsetting to Facebook? Like what
37:48 don't they like? What are things that are going to get you flagged and get you
37:51 in trouble? >> Unfortunately, the the rules have grown
37:55 massive lately. There's there's like four different pages with with rules you
37:58 have to learn. But, you know, if you want to make money on Facebook, you're
38:01 going to have to learn these. And they're not all about kind of like gore
38:06 and violence. I really hate that. I mean, there's people in in my mastermind
38:11 that have been had their accounts shut down for that. So, and they didn't
38:13 realize because they weren't watching their content close enough, which is
38:16 like people keep saying to me, "Why don't you automate all of your Facebook
38:20 with an A and all that stuff?" I said, "I could, but I need heavy human
38:24 oversight. I got to make sure every post doesn't break the terms of service and I
38:30 only need about 500 posts for like two months of content. So, I'd rather just
38:33 have heavy human oversight anyway because there are so many rules I have
38:36 to bear in mind, you know, even with backgrounds on on reals and that kind of
38:41 thing. So, yeah, I mean it you do need to know the community guidelines, the
38:45 terms of service and also there's a whole set of sub rules for content
38:49 monetization and as I said, it's easy to get kicked off. So, you need to know
38:53 this stuff. Well, I mean it's there's a million things you can do, but there's
38:57 like these 12 things you can't and and you need to know that because you know
39:01 this it sucks. >> What are the big ones? Like what are the
39:03 ones that you're constantly struggling with? The ones or maybe uh in that vein,
39:09 a second question would be what are the ones that are a little bit more nuanced
39:12 that if for example somebody like me were to go read them um I wouldn't pick
39:17 up on some of the nuance of the rules. So maybe a two-part question, like what
39:20 are the big ones that you're struggling with and what are the ones that are more
39:23 nuanced that would be harder to interpret from those rules? >> The big ones at the moment are basically
39:28 adult content, gore, violence, that kind of thing. The re the thing that Facebook
39:32 really hate is calling out a group of people. If you do any of that kind of
39:36 stuff, calling out a group of people, you'll get kicks off of Facebook so
39:40 fast, you'll be flying. But what they're not worried about now
39:44 is political content. They've actually wide opened the doors well about a year
39:48 ago to political content again. So you can actually post political opinions and
39:52 stuff and they're not fussed. They they were fussed before. So that's actually
39:55 opened up a lot. So you don't need to be so afraid to voice your political
39:58 opinions and that that actually leads to some extremely engaging posts and and a
40:04 lot there's a whole kind of subset of of political posting that's happening
40:07 that's discerning lots from content monetizations. Can we say any kind of
40:11 thing at the moment? So the more subtle ones are generally the kind of um
40:16 layouts of your of your images and stuff. So so there's like I say there's
40:21 certain things like uh if you have um a looping background on a reel. So say you
40:27 made a 10 second video in Sora because unless you pay a lot of money you can
40:31 only do short clips. If you loop that for the for like 10 seconds and 5
40:35 seconds you get your monetization taken away. So obviously that's really subtle
40:39 which is why you need to know. I didn't know. and affected some of my pages. So,
40:43 you have to be very white hat, you know, have to be kind of granny friendly. You
40:46 see a lot of pages like adult jokes and stuff, but I do know that those page
40:50 owners are always complaining about being put in Facebook jail and and not
40:53 being able to post for a couple of weeks. It's not great. So, you don't
40:57 need to do anything apart from white out on Facebook because it's so easy to to
41:02 earn money without any sort of shony tactics or anything like that. So,
41:06 >> is this part of the reason why you have 25 pages? Is it because even with your
41:11 best efforts to keep up with what is and isn't allowed, it's always changing.
41:16 It's complicated. It's nuanced. It varies. It's open to interpretation. Is
41:19 that part of the game? Is just understanding that if you go all in on
41:23 one, two, or three pages, like the chances that you will be able to keep
41:26 all the balls up in the air properly throughout the course of the time with
41:29 that is just maybe a bit too big of a risk >> to a certain extent. But I mean, if you
41:34 get a lot of um problems with your pages, it reflects on your your whole
41:37 Facebook account and every page you create will be affected. So to to you
41:43 don't get away with just having kind of pages that are knocked down like
41:46 Skittles, it will get back to you eventually. But I'm I'm small like I I
41:50 know people 500 pages and they're raking it in. Um obviously you need some
41:55 serious systems for that. So yeah, it's just more that I'm just want to be in
41:58 every single niche because I know so many profitable niches I'd love to be
42:04 in. Um I mean it's just there's so many opportunities. I'd love to have a 100
42:08 pages and the experiments you can run where you kind of have multiple pages
42:12 and then you crossost viral content to kind of you can basically treble your
42:17 income if you've got multiple pages in similar niches. So I'd love to be doing
42:21 kind of five or 10 of those a day. I should also add that there's a lot of
42:25 people noticing that if they engage with their comments, they're earning a lot
42:28 more. So, there is definitely an argument to to having maybe a smaller
42:33 amount of pages, but you're very engaged with. So, maybe you got five pages, but
42:37 you answer all the comments and people saying it's really helping their
42:40 monetization. They're getting much more money. >> Wow. So, interesting. It's a good segue.
42:45 I wanted to ask a question about this as we're kind of starting to come to an end
42:48 here, but we focused exclusively on building pages mostly around the content
42:52 monetization program, but you mentioned that links still help and in many ways
42:56 add value, actually help your page. Like, are you still seeing earnings from
43:00 other things besides just the content monetization program? And if so,
43:04 >> you know, we talk a lot this on this podcast about how to create a piece of
43:07 content and then get the maximum value for it. What are ways that people can
43:10 get maximum value for the content they're creating? Yes, creating
43:13 primarily for Facebook, but are there other ways you're earning money from
43:16 that content beyond just the monetization program? >> Sure, I'm still earning lots from links
43:22 and and I've seen a lot of pages still do merchandise. Just today I saw a page,
43:28 every post was a t-shirt. So those days are definitely not over. Um the holy
43:32 grail to me is having both. So the perfect page for me is is every post is
43:37 an image post and that image post is viral. making money from content
43:41 monetization and I have a link in the first comment going to one of my
43:45 websites. So, I'm basically doubling the revenue for me. That that's the most
43:48 interesting thing. But obviously, there's a lot of ways you can earn money
43:52 from Facebook. You know, you could you can do um you can post Amazon links
43:56 directly in Facebook. They let you do that. There's so many platforms that
44:01 don't. So, yeah. I mean, it depends what you want, what you're interested in
44:04 really. If you enjoy creating content, you're in a niche that you enjoy, like
44:08 fishing, I would just Yeah, I would I mean, you can make a website and then
44:12 send links to it and it works great still, but I mean content monetization,
44:17 the barrier of entry is so low and you can test stuff out. So, for me, it's
44:21 much more interesting at the moment than than links. >> You have I know you have a bunch of
44:26 involvement with students of yours. You have a mastermind. Like, talk a little
44:29 bit about what you're doing to help others succeed on Facebook. You've been
44:32 doing that for a while. I know it's tied to the hiker likes and um you know I've
44:37 I've taken part actually in in one of your courses from a year or two ago but
44:40 where is that at now? Where are you where are you spending your time when it
44:43 comes to that? >> Yeah. So in my mastermind there there's
44:49 I mean there's hundreds of students now. So a lot of my time is actually helping
44:53 those students out from some of the students are just starting out and and
44:55 they're just starting to grow their pages and there's a lot of kind of 101
44:59 questions there. But we've also got some people that are are incredible. I mean
45:04 that there's a a lot of people in there that are making um four five figures a
45:09 month um and and they've got a lot of pages and they really know what they're
45:12 doing. So so they're getting into the kind of really advanced tactics as well.
45:16 So it's yeah I mean it's really interesting. I mean I spend probably
45:20 about an hour a day just just talking to students and kind of helping them out to
45:24 kind of grow grow their pages and grow their monetization. And a lot of them
45:28 still are very much interested in sending traffic to their website as
45:32 well. So that's that's not gone away. >> And we didn't talk about that, but it's
45:34 obvious, I think, for people listening, like if you're able to send even some of
45:38 that traffic to your website, you're monetized via an ad network.
45:41 >> You have all the other things going for a traditional website that we've always
45:44 talked about here. Like like you said, you're double dipping. You can then
45:46 triple dip, >> build an email list. like in many ways,
45:51 yes, the percentage of people that are going to go from your Facebook post to
45:55 your website are small, but like you said, it's not hard to get a million,
45:58 two million, three million people to engage with a post of yours. So, you
46:03 don't need a high percentage of those. And so, there's a lot of different ways
46:06 to double and triple dip. >> Yeah. Yeah. I mean, there's a guy called
46:10 Jeff Rose. He's recently been all over social media because he's been making
46:15 120,000 from content monetization on a financial Facebook page and he said I
46:20 didn't really was interested in Facebook until they pay me hundreds of dollars
46:25 for this one viral post and then he got kind of interested in it and ended up
46:29 making six figures a year and that's in the financial niche which is
46:31 traditionally a really hard niche to actually um get engagement from and make
46:36 money from. So he ended up releasing a course and and just going really into
46:40 it. So, so yeah, I mean there's a huge opportunity at the moment and we're very
46:44 early to it as well. So, normally the worst thing about doing an online
46:47 business is you arrive just as everybody's leaving the pitch and
46:50 they've made all the money. Well, this is actually an opportunity that's that's
46:55 just come along. It's still in beta and so few people know about it. They're all
46:58 worrying about YouTube shorts and stuff. Well, this is an opportunity like
47:01 YouTube shorts, but hardly anyone is talking about it or doing it or trying
47:05 to figure out the science. So, if you get in now, you're actually going to be
47:08 really early to this. and there's no saturation at all. >> Andy, we'll include a link in the show
47:15 notes to what you have going on. Um, I have done personally just a little
47:18 thing. I've done a couple one-on-one calls over the years about Facebook and
47:21 you're incredibly informed and very helpful. So, I'll say that not a part of
47:24 your community, but definitely have enjoyed um some of the more advanced um
47:29 takes you've had on some of the stuff that we've done. Um, it's good to have
47:34 you back for a second time. Uh, I know the first one was super well received.
47:37 I'm sure this one will be the same way. Um, >> I can talk about stuff for hours, you
47:42 know, it's really interesting. >> It is fascinating. It's cool to see that
47:47 you've evolved with Facebook as it's evolved. It's cool to see the
47:50 monetization program continuing to evolve. I think a lot of people and we
47:54 were we were talking about the news episode. I remember a year or two ago
47:57 with Spencer doing his page and talking about like we didn't know if it was like
48:01 you said it was it was it was beta and we didn't know how long it was going to
48:03 be around for if it was going to be around for but it's really neat to see
48:06 it being here for two to three years and evolving which is such a good sign for
48:10 where it could go going forward. You know it's not um it's not going away.
48:15 >> No, it's just been born and it's just going to be a couple of years. I think a
48:18 couple years people have figured this out. It's going to be really good and it
48:21 should be stable for a while. at the moment they be messed around a bit quite
48:24 a lot but I think we're really going to pin down the science of this really soon
48:28 and once we do that and we figure out what signals are actually rewarding the
48:32 the the posts are getting the content monetization um there's going to be some
48:35 big money made I mean Facebook have paid out2 billion pounds to content creators
48:40 in in the past year just people like me it's people like you so anybody can do
48:45 it anybody can rob a page couple of hundred dollars to get the first 10,000
48:49 likes and then you're good to go you just start posting content And it's like
48:54 I said before with traffic, it's it's really good fun. It's the most fun
48:58 platform. It's way way quicker than SEO. It's way quicker than YouTube, like
49:03 probably by a factor of 25. So you can throw a page up and be earning next
49:07 month. So So that's the thing. I'm massively impatient. I want to be
49:10 earning money tomorrow. Then Facebook's the only platform that allows you to do
49:13 that at the moment. >> Love it. I'm sure that's going to peique
49:17 a lot of people's interest. Andy, thanks for coming back on. Another great
49:21 episode. Appreciate you. Yeah, we'll talk again soon. Cheers.
49:24 >> Cheers. Bye. >> Hey, before we wrap up, quick reminder.
49:28 If you want to see how AI tools like Chat GBT, Perplexity, and Google
49:32 actually see your brand, check out the new GEO snapshot audit from my agency,
49:37 2011 Creative. It shows how visible your business really is across five key
49:41 categories and what to fix so you start showing up in these AIdriven results.
49:45 And for a limited time, I'm giving Niche Pursuits listeners a free GEO snapshot
49:49 complete with your visibility score. and next steps to improve it. So, you can
50:01 snapshot. Claim your spot before they're