you2idea@video:~$ watch 3yVIV4Cy2w4 [1:23:50]
// transcript — 1124 segments
0:02 Dee, you uh were promoted recently from principal to partner, I believe. Uh I
0:07 know you probably can't tell us all of Menllo's long-term plans for succession,
0:11 but I am curious how often you think about your upward trajectory at the
0:14 firm, and uh if there is more headroom for you to grow into, do you want to
0:18 become one of its core leaders down the road? Is that a possibility? Tell me
0:21 what it's like from your hot seat. Honestly, I I I'm very thankful that
0:27 they brought me in as somebody who had, you know, no real experience in venture.
0:31 Like I was really a person who just studied the craft from a distance,
0:35 right? I I write online. I read everything I can. I was a part of a
0:40 startup glean that went really well from the very beginning to to about the time
0:42 I left and it's still doing fantastically. I just don't have that
0:48 approach to how I see Menllo. I mean, I I joined this fantastic team um very
0:53 much to work as a team together and uh and reinvigorate what the firm uh stood
0:57 for. I mean, we've been around for 50 years. We're on our 17th fund. So, a
1:02 part of the old guard really in terms of how storied the firm is. Um but you know
1:09 with any time I think there is a time for resurgence and rebuilding of a firm
1:14 and uh I don't know what the future lies but I think every day about how what we
1:18 could be doing differently to be uh different in venture and if you look at
1:22 like the last four people that we've sort of hired at Menllo you have Tim
1:27 Tully who's a CTO of Splunk you have Joff Redern who is the CPO of Atlassian
1:33 you have Matt Craning who did a PhD from Stanford and sold a unicorn cyber
1:37 security company, you have me like these are people who've operated businesses.
1:41 And so one of the things that we are trying really hard to do is sort of
1:46 marry this set of people who have been in the weeds and sort of seen like the
1:51 brutality of what it takes to run a good company um with investors who get the
1:55 finances, who understand the long-term vision as well. And and we're very early
2:01 on that arc. Um, who knows what that future holds. But right now, my main
2:07 focus is, hey, let's focus on getting things right as a firm. How do we
2:11 invest? What are our principles? What do we stand for? And how do we get in uh
2:15 and partner with the best founders? To be honest, >> this week in startups is brought to you
2:22 by AWS activate. AWS activate helps startups bring their ideas to life. As
2:26 you build and scale your business, Activate credits grow with you to
2:30 support your changing needs. Apply to AWS activate today and receive up to
2:36 $100,000 in credits. Visit Northwest Registered agent. Starting
2:44 your business should be simple. With Northwest Registered Agent, you can form
2:48 your entire business identity in just 10 clicks and 10 minutes. From LLC's to
2:53 trademarks, domains to custom websites, they've got you covered. Get more
2:57 privacy, more options, and more done. Visit Northwestregistered
3:01 agent.com/twist today. Cruso cloud. Crusoe is the AI factory company. Reliable infrastructure
3:09 and expert support. Visit cruso.ai/startup to reserve your capacity for the latest
3:21 Hey everybody, welcome back to This Week in Startups. My name is Alex and I am
3:25 joined today by an illustrious venture capital panel. Starting off with my
3:29 co-host Jason Calakanis, who's currently still in Saudi Arabia. Jason, I hear the
3:33 traffic is fantastic in Riad. >> Uh yeah, I got I just got caught in a
3:38 little bit of the uh old Riad traffic, but I ate at a really great traditional
3:43 uh Saudi restaurant. We sit on the floor and uh you know, use the bread to pick
3:46 up the food. It was amazing. But we wrapped up our third day of Sabo Founder
3:51 University. So thank you to all my friends in the region. 60 startups all
3:57 from the region. Um and about 45 of them are from Saudi uh Saudi nationals
4:02 building incredible companies and um it's kind of like coming to Silicon
4:06 Valley in the 60s or 70s where there's a lot of energy, a lot of great founders,
4:10 but they're just starting this entrepreneurial journey and uh it's very
4:15 rewarding to meet with these incredible founding teams. They're doing fintech in
4:20 a major way. Uh they're doing construction tech in a major way.
4:24 There's a lot of real estate uh going on here. Uh and then you know every great
4:29 idea like you see in founders from America and uh we did a three-day
4:33 intensive talking about how to build companies. These are all year zero
4:37 companies and we're going to be doing two of these classes a year. Wow.
4:40 >> Two of these found university classes a year. So it's really exciting for me and
4:44 uh really proud of the work we're doing. Yeah. >> Because Jason needed more frequent flyer
4:49 miles. We finally solved that problem. All right. uh else on the panel on the
4:54 panel today we also have Jay um from uh Global Frontier Technology Ventures or
4:58 as I call it GFT Ventures. Jay, how you doing? >> I'm doing great. Thank you guys for
5:03 having me. This is really exciting. >> And we have Dee Doss whom everyone knows
5:07 from his high caffeine tweets. He's a partner, a new partner over at Menllo
5:11 Ventures. Dee, how are you? >> I'm fantastic, guys. I'm uh I'm really glad that we're all
5:17 here today because there's been a kind of a seismic shift in the venture
5:21 capital world. We saw a changing of the guard at SEOA with Brolaf both stepping
5:25 back from his role as kind of chief steward of that firm. Handed off the
5:30 reigns to Alfred Lynn and Pat Grady, two well-known names. But I got to say guys,
5:33 I'm a little bit shocked. I did not see this coming. Heard no rumors, no
5:38 rumbles, no premonitions. So, first I'm kind of curious, who knew? And uh if you
5:42 didn't know, are you surprised by this? Let's start with Jason who's already
5:43 laughing. >> Well, I'm I'm good friends with Ruaf for a long time. He brought me into the
5:48 venture business. He created the scouts program at Sequoia. I was the first
5:51 person he asked to do it with the Sequoia Scouts. He was on the board of
5:55 my company. He invested in Mahalo back in the day, 15 years ago. Um, and I've
5:59 known him all this time. One of the great venture capitalist, somebody I
6:03 learned a ton from. Uh, and I didn't know, um, but I did know that the firm
6:09 had, um, some spiciness going on with Shan Maguire being very public about his
6:14 feelings about the conflicts in the Middle East, etc. I'm not sure if that
6:19 contributed to it. I'm just catching up here on the other side of the planet.
6:23 Um, you know, and saw the Wall Street Journal say that, uh, maybe that had
6:27 something to do with it. I don't know. But they have a great tradition at
6:31 Sequoia with uh, these stewards. Obviously, Don Valentine started the the
6:35 firm and then he had Michael Moritz Douglone, two legends as well and they
6:42 um you know gave it over to Ruof and Alfred and now Alfred and another
6:47 partner are going to run it. So um you know best of luck to Ruof. He had one of
6:51 the great runs in the history of venture capital. Um, and that's a pretty intense
6:57 thing to do to run Sequoia, the literally most legendary um, and successful venture capital firm
7:03 in the history of venture capital. So, I wish him a lot of luck.
7:04 >> Yeah, >> DD, you work at a firm that has a a number of partners and kind of a
7:09 generational history. He's been around for a minute. Um, looking at the
7:13 headlines Sequoa has gone through, had to kind of divest his China India funds.
7:17 There was the FTX mess, the Shan Magcguire stuff that Jason mentioned,
7:21 there was the Clara board seat scrap. To me, that didn't seem like enough in
7:25 aggregate to force a change at a firm with the stature of Sequoia. So, I'm
7:28 just kind of curious if you expected this and uh if not, what might have
7:32 happened? >> I have no idea to be honest with you. I mean, the few times I've met with RUF, I
7:39 think he's a fantastic guy and I think everybody on the Sequoia team that I've
7:41 interacted with has been quite fantastic. Um, look, when you're a firm
7:46 like Sequoia, you're going to get scrutiny. I mean, you're you're you
7:50 know, historically the number one venture f firm and so whenever something
7:53 like this happens, I'm not surprised that so much scrutiny is drawn to that
7:58 firm, but um look, I'm excited for Alfred and Pat and uh they're both great
8:03 guys and I'm uh excited for them to take take the helm of stewardship at Sequoa.
8:07 >> All right, that's two safe answers. Jay, what do you got for us?
8:12 Um well the interesting thing was I just saw Roloff a few weeks ago at the
8:16 Stanford Business School Centennial Celebration and uh you know Rolof played
8:23 a big role in organizing some of the really interesting alumni panels. Um he
8:28 talked about the stewardship and uh it's always been something that um I think
8:32 many of us in the venture industry has admired Sequoia Capital 4. Um having
8:38 that um stewardship pass where you hand over the reigns to the next generation
8:43 before you get too stale and too crusty. Um and I think that's frankly been one
8:47 of the reasons that they've you know really um been able to ascend to the top
8:53 of the hill. Um I I remember when I started in the industry 20 plus years
8:57 ago, you know, there was Sequoa, but there was also Kleiner and a few other
9:02 firms and uh I think it's uh kind of undisputed where Sequoia is um in terms
9:07 of the hierarchy today. Um the great thing about this is um the stewardship
9:15 uh part of what I had heard um because um I was uh on a board together with Jim
9:20 Gats who was the prior stewart at Sequoia. Um he actually told me
9:23 something really interesting. He purposely tried to stay in the
9:27 background and you know show up less at the office sometimes to make sure the
9:32 leadership was handed over properly so that people would not be looking around
9:37 for him asking questions but they would actually make sure to ask the new
9:41 leaders and the Stewarts to actually make those right decisions. So maybe
9:45 Rolof is in that mode as well. >> I think that's just to build on that. Uh
9:50 Jay, that's what I saw happen with Michael Moritz, Sir Michael Moritz and
9:55 Doug Leone, you know, I they said they were handing off to Alfred and Ruof and
9:59 then I would come by the office for the next 5 to 10 years and they would still
10:02 be there. You've heard me talk so much on the pod about the importance of
10:05 renewable energy. That's why I'm so excited to talk to you about Cruso
10:09 today. Most AI infrastructure is still powered by fossil fuels, but Cruso has
10:14 an innovative energy first approach. They've actually built a
10:17 high-performance AI cloud platform that's powered by wind, hydro, and
10:22 geothermal energy in Iceland. Right now, they're using 100% geothermal and
10:26 hydroelect electric power to deploy the latest Nvidia Blackwell GPUs on Cruso
10:31 Cloud. This is the future, folks, and it's here today. That's how Cruso is
10:35 making energy and compute easier to access than ever before. So, spend less
10:39 time worrying about infrastructure and more time building. Visit
10:43 caruso.ai/startup AI/startup to apply for $100,000 in credits for virtualized Nvidia GB200
10:51 NVL72 on Caruso Cloud pending availability. >> Yeah. >> But they had this like tradition of like
11:12 I would say a decade long uh transition. I suspect that's what will happen with
11:16 RUF as well is that, you know, he'll be hanging around doing all the boards he's
11:20 on. But it's a numbersbased business, Alex. And if you look at RUF's run, over
11:27 $50 billion to LPs was distributed. It was insane. And it was insane from the
11:32 moment he got there. He did YouTube, he did Instagram. at that same time they
11:39 did New Bank. They did um uh Square, which he I think is still on the board
11:42 of um and they did, you know, the Sequoia Fund where they hold on to their
11:47 public shares and help their LPs decide what to do with those. Uh WhatsApp, it
11:52 was an amazing fund. I heard that fund was 21x, you know, that's a 21x is a big fund.
11:59 And of course, I did the scouts fund that I got to participate in and so just
12:05 brass tax. He put numbers on the board that we've never seen in the industry.
12:09 And when they when they look back on it, those are some very big numbers. And it
12:14 was put up during a time of increased competition, massive increased
12:19 competition. And they they stayed true to their knitting. They didn't get so
12:23 big that they became one of these mega funds. You know, even the funds they
12:27 just announced um were pretty modest in size given what Sequoia is capable of.
12:33 And they've never lost money for an LP. That was the other uh very proud thing
12:36 that you know they had going for them in the history of the firm. Never lost a
12:41 dollar for LPs. But it's um you know the changing of guard has to happen. And
12:45 then LPs do judge you on your secession plans as a solo GP in our firm. I get
12:50 that question a lot. Are you you know what's going on? Are you going to
12:52 retire? We going to have a fifth fund? What's going on? I have to be honest
12:56 with them. Okay, I haven't decided yet. And so that works against you if you're
13:01 a solo GP. and um they have a lot of serious uh firms as LPs. So, it's
13:06 >> it's a big deal. >> DD, you uh were promoted recently from
13:11 principal to partner, I believe. Uh I know you probably can't tell us all of
13:15 Menllo's long-term plans for succession, but I am curious how often you think
13:19 about your upper trajectory at the firm and uh if there is more headroom for you
13:22 to grow into, do you want to become one of its core leaders down the road? Is
13:26 that a possibility? Tell me what it's like from your hot seat. Honestly, I I
13:31 I'm very thankful that they brought me in as somebody who had, you know, no
13:36 real experience in venture. Like I was really a person who just studied the
13:40 craft from a distance, right? I I write online. I read everything I can. I was a
13:45 part of a startup glean that went really well from the very beginning to to about
13:48 the time I left and it's still doing fantastically. I just don't have that
13:53 approach to how I see Menllo. I mean, I I joined this fantastic team um very
13:59 much to work as a team together and uh and reinvigorate what the firm uh stood
14:03 for. I mean, we've been around for 50 years. We're on our 17th fund. So, a
14:08 part of the old guard really in terms of how storied the firm is. Um but, you
14:14 know, with any time, I think there is a time for resurgence and rebuilding of a
14:19 firm. And uh I don't know what the future lies, but I think every day about
14:23 how what we could be doing differently to be uh different in venture. And if
14:28 you look at like the last four people that we've sort of hired at Menllo, you
14:33 have Tim Tully who is a CTO of Splunk. You have Joff Redern who is the CPO of
14:38 Atlassian. You have Matt Craning who did a PhD from Stanford and sold a unicorn
14:42 cyber security company. You have me like these are people who've operated
14:46 businesses. And so one of the things that we are trying really hard to do is
14:52 sort of marry this set of people who have been in the weeds and sort of seen
14:56 like the brutality of what it takes to run a good company um with investors who
15:01 get the finances who understand the long-term vision as well. And and we're
15:06 very early on that arc. Um who knows what that future holds. But right now my
15:12 main focus is hey let's focus on getting things right as a firm. How do we
15:17 invest? What are our principles? What do we stand for? And how do we get in uh
15:21 and partner with the best founders to be honest? >> What is the uh middle of ventures media
15:26 training budget per year? >> Whatever it is, I think it all goes to
15:30 me now. [laughter] >> Um and I've, >> you know, there was a time when venture
15:35 capitalists didn't do media. They just very quietly behind the scenes. I think
15:40 I might have had a little bit of uh I might I might be to blame for being the
15:44 first venture capitalist to >> podcastate Jal. >> Yeah. Now everybody if you're a venture
15:48 capitalist you have to have a podcast. [laughter] >> But it is the big change that Dee points
15:54 Dee uh points out which is uh the industry went from in my lifetime uh
15:58 being people who were professional finance people or who got into it right
16:04 out of school. Um Steve Jervson um you know I just had him on the program and
16:07 he did do a little time in tech but he got into venture very early and um you
16:12 know Ruof worked at PayPal obviously but then got into venture very early in his
16:19 career and now it's founders expect um that people in venture have some scar
16:23 tissue and have been in the trenches. So that's a real kind of a different uh
16:29 vibe than it was. And it's also an industry in massive transition right
16:34 now. Like I think we all represent the original boutique venture kind of model,
16:40 smaller funds, you know, uh really handcrafted. But then you have these you
16:45 know and Harowitz giant platforms you know many different sector funds
16:49 billions of dollars under management that you know it sort of trends you
16:54 towards average returns or you know um you know indexing the industry uh um in
16:59 most cases. So there really is two venture industries and I think Sequoia
17:03 has done a great job of staying true to the traditional venture industry. Um but
17:08 you know RUOF is still young. So, the the question I have is after he takes a
17:14 little break, I wonder if he's gonna start a firm or go work with Elon at a company. I mean,
17:21 he's an he was an operator 20 years ago, so I I wonder what's next for him. I
17:26 have no idea. I haven't talked to him. >> I think we're all going to be waiting to
17:29 see what Roloff chooses. But, I want to go back to the idea, Jason. You talked
17:32 about venture capital changing. Uh Rolof had gone on a bit of a media tour before
17:36 he stepped back. And one of the things that he said that we talked about a
17:39 little bit a couple weeks ago was that throwing more money into Silicon Valley
17:42 quote doesn't yield more great companies. Uh Jason, we started off
17:47 today with you discussing 60 companies that you're talking to in Riad, 45 of
17:51 which are Saudi based. Not a historical hub of startup formation, let's be
17:55 honest. Uh but it seems that there's a lot of founders out there who want to
18:00 build. So is Roloff kind of wrong about you know capital not helping build more
18:03 great companies because it feels like today going back to DD talking about
18:06 Glean and all the other major companies that are doing well today that we're
18:10 seeing an enormous density of great companies being built and and formed.
18:15 >> Yeah. in in America and Silicon Valley um for sure there's too much capital
18:20 chasing too few really great ideas and that means uh you can see it in the
18:26 valuations and you know people are running up valuations to points that may
18:32 break the model if you're a seed investor I was talking to a seed
18:36 investor just today who you know you know let's say they put 250k into a
18:42 company at a $40 million seed round okay If the company becomes worth a billion
18:46 dollars and they get diluted by half, I I mean, what are they going to return to
18:51 their investors, you know, they they own a very small fraction of that company,
18:56 less than 1% of it and like a quarter percentage of it. They're going to
18:58 return two and a half million, five million from their fund if it's a
19:03 unicorn. So, it's an incredibly hard business and a lot of the math just
19:06 doesn't pencil out. And I think the other thing RUF was saying during his
19:11 tour was that it was a return-free risk venture capital at this point in time
19:15 which was very funny. Um and that got a little bit of weight but yeah we are an
19:19 industry in transition. Um and it's unclear to a lot of LPs it's unclear to
19:24 a lot of VC firms you know how the returns will happen um and if we can
19:29 return the amount of capital being deployed. It's a big TBD.
19:33 >> Yeah. Uh Jay your first fund was 140 million if memory serves. So, kind of
19:38 the opposite of a multi-billion dollar uh fund. Are you going to be able to
19:42 return all of that? And uh what's your take on more capital and not leading to
19:46 more great companies? >> Yeah, I I think there's a couple of
19:50 things that come to mind. So, first off, um innovation is everywhere. So, whether
19:55 it's in Riad or Seoul or Tokyo, um there's some great companies coming out
19:58 of that. The other thing to keep in mind is while the US venture capital
20:04 ecosystem is primarily private capital. >> Hey, listen. We meet a lot of early
20:07 stage founders here at launch, my investment company, and some they don't
20:10 have a lot of traction yet. They just have an idea. Maybe they haven't even
20:13 finished their product. They've just got an MVP, but they still need investors
20:18 and accelerators like ours to take them seriously. And you know what? We can't
20:22 just wire money to your Gmail or your PayPal. [laughter] That's not how it
20:25 works, folks. We need to know that you're a legit and official business. We
20:29 need to know your company is incorporated. That's why you need
20:33 Northwest Registered agent. It's the service that will help you run your
20:37 business the right way from day one. In 10 clicks and in under 10 minutes,
20:41 you're going to file for your LLC or a CC Corp if you're a startup, get a
20:44 domain name, launch your official website, claim your business email, and
20:48 even fasttrack your trademark application, which some people forget to
20:51 do. We're talking about more than just company formation. This is your entire
20:55 identity as a business. Go to northwestregistered.comtwist and show the world you're in business
21:04 and make sure you use that URL/twist so where the primary objective or the sole
21:15 objectives is really pure financial return. There's plenty of regions as we
21:20 all know that there is actually a strategic element uh to funding going
21:25 into venture capital governmentdriven funding which started in Israel been
21:31 adopted in parts of Asia including South Korea, Japan, Singapore and other
21:36 locations where they want to actually build the startup ecosystem uh primarily
21:41 to make sure that uh that there's job creation, there's innovation and so um a
21:46 lot of these countries um and a lot of the funds that are in
21:51 located in these countries they don't necessarily benchmark against the S&P
21:56 500 index funds as long as they are generating a reasonable return they are
22:00 creating jobs and they're creating innovation for those ecosystems so
22:03 that's I think important to keep in mind globally um I think second point is that
22:10 um there's a lot of venture capital firms out there and uh I think anybody
22:15 that's uh starting a venture firm when I started Ed my first venture capital firm
22:20 uh back in the day called Translink Capital and I asked the same question
22:25 before we started GFT Ventures is does the world need another venture capital
22:30 firm right and unless there's a clear reason for existence um it's really
22:35 difficult to justify because there's so many great firms there's so much capital
22:39 out there um when uh my co-founding partner Jeff Herps and I yeah you a
22:43 couple of recovering corporate ex-corporate venture capital guys um the
22:47 ex Samsung guy, the exvidia guy teamed up to launch GFT ventures. We had a very
22:53 specific agenda, GF being global frontier tech. So we're a frontier tech
22:57 fund, but we had already been investing in AI and data science companies for
23:03 over a decade. um we saw the growth the potential coming up and we wanted to
23:08 really concentrate our efforts on that specific category and uh it turned out
23:13 that uh it was very serendipitous a year after um we launched the fund and we're
23:18 about to wrap up our final closing chachi PT gets announced the whole world
23:23 gets a sense of you know the impact the massive impact that AI brings to the
23:27 table and I think that really benefited us and I think it helps for us a little
23:31 bit to be OGs so to where we've already invested in companies like Soundown AI which are now
23:37 public companies three years in you know companies that are coming out of the
23:42 entrepreneurs uh the lieutenants from those companies starting new companies
23:46 um getting founder referrals and whatnot has really helped us so far. Uh, DD, I
23:50 want to go back to Glean for a second because if memory serves, the company
23:54 crossed 100 million ARR in like February or March of this year. And I feel like
23:58 if you go back to the era of Box before Box was public, if you reached 100
24:02 million AR, it was heralded as like this really big moment. Like it was an
24:05 accomplishment. You can go public now. Well done. You've done the thing. Now I
24:09 feel like Glean's announcement was kind of forgotten because so many companies
24:12 are reaching, you know, eight and nine figure AR milestones. So that's why I
24:16 say it feels like today we are seeing more great companies built because
24:20 they're reaching such scale so quickly. Am I overindexing on the names that I
24:23 know DD or are we actually seeing a greater number of outstanding startups
24:28 actually be formed and scale today? >> I think there's a couple of points that
24:31 I'd make here. Number one, I think the simple point is like Glean is a boring
24:36 B2B top-own sales business. Like nobody outside venture and startups has any
24:40 business caring about Gleon and and they shouldn't, right? like you know I don't
24:43 expect New York Times to run a piece on glean it's not chatpt right so this does
24:49 not meaningfully impact that many lives outside knowledge workers and certain
24:53 categories of companies so I'm not I'm not shocked that this is not a global
24:59 sensation um number two I would say is um it is worth noting that um Glean
25:04 included but sort of all companies at that growth stage are raising at
25:09 valuations that are so big and so forwardlooking that you know it does make sense that
25:15 the media wants to cover those the biggest companies with the biggest
25:19 potential outcomes and biggest potential growth tracks. Um and and and Glean too
25:24 maybe in a world before Glean could IPO but when we look at the company we're
25:30 see we're like okay we could go and IPO now but let's you know fortify sort of
25:35 the bank balance and then try to shoot for higher when is the right time to go
25:39 IPO I'll give you another anecdote like I heard this recently from a a growth
25:44 stage company that we were trying um to invest in and these founders you know we
25:48 we sort of asked them like hey so what are your plans of going public and I
25:52 think they broke character for a second and they're like well you know
25:55 everything serves us well like I don't think we need to like why why why would
25:59 we do that >> um and we're like well you know it's kind of important to us so [laughter]
26:06 that that that happens um and and so we are seeing a shift wi with how big
26:11 growth stage companies in that 100 million plus ARR bracket are looking at
26:16 governance why would you want to go public you can raise infinite money in
26:20 private private markets if you continue to grow um you don't have to do all of
26:25 this reporting to the SEC it is it just makes your life a lot more easy and you
26:30 get the liquidity that you wanted so you know the the the sort of balance of when
26:36 to to go public is also changing um the private markets didn't have this kind of
26:39 capital maybe at the time that Box was there to support an indefinite series of
26:44 growth rounds um so that that is changing >> yeah uh you know again what's your Oh,
26:50 no. I was going to call you in to respond to that. So, perfectly
26:52 serendipitous. >> Well, yeah. I mean, it seems like Stripe
26:56 has decided that they're going to be private forever. [laughter]
27:00 And, uh, you know, speaking of like seed funds and angel funds, the scouts fund,
27:04 the first scouts fund, I did Uber famously and then um, less famously, Sam
27:09 Waltman did Stripe in that scouts fund and that I think is the highest multiple
27:16 fund on cash that Sequoia ever did. Um and now with secondary markets and the
27:22 ability to swap investors out in years 12, 13, 14 like SpaceX and Stripe are
27:27 doing, you know, it is creating some liquidity for venture, but you would be,
27:33 you know, much better served to have it actually be public companies and
27:36 distribute to your LPs the public shares. That's what LPs really want is
27:40 to get those public shares and then make their own decision of what to do with
27:43 them. Um, so it's it's an industry in transition. um great founders are coming
27:48 from anywhere to Jay's point it really is a global industry and yep they're
27:54 these industries are being jump started but if you look at the Scandinavian
27:59 countries uh Sweden as specifically Israel obviously uh and then you go to
28:05 Australia with Canva uh and Atlassian you know now you're starting to see
28:09 decacorns come out of these regions it's not just like the occasional unicorn and
28:13 like oh Spotify is worth a billion dollars back in the So now Spotify is, I
28:17 believe, worth over hundred billion dollars. >> 128. >> Yeah. So you got, you know, a hundred
28:23 billion dollar company coming out of a country of 30 million people. At um
28:29 Atlassian is also up in that range. Um I don't know off the top of my head where
28:32 they're at, but then Canvas at 40 billion I think in the private markets.
28:36 These are not small companies anymore. Talent can come from anywhere. Great
28:40 founders come from everywhere. Specifically, they used to land on our
28:44 shores. we used to welcome them here a lot more than we do uh at the current
28:48 moment even with the you know Trump saying he was going to put those green
28:50 cards I'm still going to follow up with him about that but those green cards on
28:56 the diplomas um but yeah these companies are uh being formed all around the world
29:00 and the secrets are out you know just being here in Saudi for the last three
29:05 days they're listening to our podcasts they're reading our news sources they're
29:09 on the substacks they know the techniques they're asking me about
29:14 Raul's product market fit engine blog post and the talk he gave three years
29:19 ago on this podcast like they're up on it. So the secrets are out and talent
29:24 comes from anywhere. So it's it's there's a very bright future here. We
29:29 did have a four-year pause under Lena Khan where there was no M&A and I think
29:35 that had when that um you know indigestion gets cleared and and we can kind of move some of the
29:41 companies that should have been bought and consolidated and get more DPI. I
29:45 think people feel a lot different about the industry. But I know a lot of
29:48 venture capitalists now who are just saying this is too hard. This is too
29:54 hard. I'm quitting. Uh and I that's not the case with RU. I don't think but and
29:58 they were succeeding but there we all know on this call many folks who are not
30:02 going to raise their next fund they're just like it was it was this has been
30:06 too hard there's no DPI in fact if you want to get rich it's not the perfect
30:10 way to get rich it used to be in people's mind oh I become a venture
30:13 capitalist I'll be a billionaire no venture capitalists are not becoming
30:16 billionaires hey startup founders are you tired of losing deals to endless
30:20 procurement cycles and complex contract negotiations there's a better way to
30:25 sell your SAS product AWS marketplace place isn't just another sales channel.
30:29 It's your shortcut to enterprise customers. When you list on AWS
30:33 Marketplace, your software charges appear directly on your customer's
30:37 existing AWS bill. No separate invoicing, no procurement headaches, no
30:41 waiting months for approvals. But here's the best part. AWS actually incentivizes
30:45 buyers to purchase from your listing with credits, helping you land your
30:50 first 20 customers. And after that, AWS provides you with a budget to fund even
30:54 more deals. Plus, you get one-click deployment, free trial capabilities, and
30:59 access to committed spend budgets that enterprises are already planning to use.
31:04 So, stop watching your competitors close deals faster. Join thousands of
31:08 successful startups already selling on AWS Marketplace. Ready to accelerate
31:14 your sales cycle? Visit AWS Marketplace today and turn your biggest procurement
31:25 their funds do two or three, they got to chop up their, you know, uh, funds, you
31:31 know, with four partners, five partners. They're not actually bringing down as
31:34 much money as you might think because they own such a small percentage of
31:38 startups. Used, you know, it used to be the the series A, the seed round, they
31:43 would get 15%, 20% of a company. Now the seed round is five, six, 7% of the
31:47 company. The series A might be only 10% of the company. It's um it's a it's an
31:51 industry in transition. Yeah. >> Yeah. For sure. I mean, one thing I
31:55 would add though is despite there's more competition, there's more challenges.
31:59 For sure, some of these companies are growing at a rate that I've never seen
32:04 in my 20 years. I mean, it's just the potential outcomes of some of these
32:07 companies where, you know, everybody knows that lovable hit 100 million ARR
32:12 in less than 12 months. We have other companies that are trying to beat that
32:17 record right now. And so if you extrapolate some of these companies um
32:21 and the growth rates that they have >> and again you know the good news is a
32:27 lot of these AI especially AI application AI platform companies
32:31 they're growing on existing infrastructure that it's built been
32:35 built for decades connectivity is there mobile app distribution all of those
32:40 things are in place and on top of that more recently you know there's actually
32:44 a willingness to pay shockingly right? People understand that there is actually
32:50 a cost for every inference um that goes into it and you know thanks to OpenAI
32:55 and others they've actually been able to be trained to actually pay for the
33:00 utility that they get from some of these applications. So I've I've never seen
33:03 anything like it in my career. >> I think that last point Jay made is I've
33:07 never heard anybody make it actually so crisply but I think it's so important to
33:11 think about. We all think, "Oh, cloud computing, the infrastructures, the
33:14 rails, the bandwidth, sure, all that's set up." But what's also been set up is
33:19 that businesses had such a great experience paying $100 a month or $500 a
33:23 month for a piece of SAS software that they're like, "Yeah, this thing's as
33:27 good as Salesforce or Slack or HubSpot. [snorts] >> It's so worth it." Yeah,
33:31 >> it's so worth it. And so when all these AI tools came out and it was like $40 a
33:36 person to be on quad for the enterprise account, I was like, "Yeah." Oh, and oh,
33:41 Grock wants to charge us to bring it on. Oh, there's a $200 version. Absolutely.
33:44 I'll pay for some people on the team to have the $200 version. if it makes them
33:50 1% more efficient. If a developer wants cursor and co-pilot and five versions of
33:55 it and they use two a month, businesses are just very frisky about that and they
34:01 understand I think that making existing high performers higher performers is
34:06 better than hiring more people >> right >> so that's just to build on your
34:10 exceptional point Jay that is also part of it that goes into why these startups
34:14 are doing so well do we hire another designer or is there a design tool that
34:18 this designer can use that makes them go faster around Figma. Do we hire the
34:22 sixth developer or just give the other five another tool? >> It's a pretty easy decision for
34:27 management. >> I think Jason's talking about the B2B case here, Jay, but when I was thinking
34:31 about the company you might be discussing that's trying to raise
34:34 lovable to 100 million AR, I was thinking of Higsfield which recently
34:37 raised and is growing quite quickly. That's B TOC. So a slightly different
34:41 point I think. Are you seeing the same >> it's not so certainly there's a B2B
34:47 customer base um B TOC customer base for sure. um they fall into the category of
34:51 very similar to Canva. They actually sell for short form video creation and
34:55 this is our co-investment with Menllo obviously um they actually sell to
35:01 creators uh and they do short form video generation for social media right so if
35:06 you think about who the major customers are including the Mr. beasts of the
35:11 world and whatnot. These are not individuals per se, right? These are
35:16 actually small enterprises. Some of them are quite big and uh they are looking
35:21 for platforms that actually generate, you know, high quality realistic video
35:25 so that they can actually supplement their own efforts to actually have these
35:30 studio setups, camera setups and whatnot. And they've done a fantastic
35:35 job. They have grown and this is since they tweeted themselves public
35:41 information. They've grown um 60x in the last 6 months. I've never seen anything
35:45 like it. It's crazy. >> 60x. So >> 1 million ARR to over 70 plus in a
35:52 little over six months. >> So Jay, one thing Jason likes to talk
35:56 about though is there is sampling, there is testing, people have to play with
35:59 things. I I'm curious if you can share anything about the the revenue health at
36:03 that company. Is that ARR sticking around like we would expect traditional
36:06 enterprise SAS ARR? Is it a little bit more loose? What's it like?
36:11 >> Yeah, it's um it's too early to say, but it's certainly somewhere in between. So,
36:15 it's not like, you know, BTOC revenue where people try something out and the
36:19 minute they get get a better deal or a better feature from somewhere else,
36:23 they'll drop it and move on. It's not as sticky obviously as enterprise revenue,
36:27 but the company is actually um moving into that category as well. But again,
36:32 the canvas segment of what we call proumers, yeah, >> um is a massive segment and they are
36:38 sticky. They are loyal. If they find a platform that works, why would they
36:42 switch over? So, um yeah, they're actually, you know, accelerating revenue
36:46 uh to a rate that I've never seen in my career before. >> DD, I want to get you to weigh in on the
36:51 willingness to pay in the AI era because I think this is a major tailwind for
36:55 startups of all sizes. I mean, look, I think Jay said said exactly what's going on and and Jason
37:01 said it too, like there is immense willingness to pay and try new things.
37:04 Um, when it comes to like like thinking about like growth versus retention is
37:08 often like a thing that people in venture talk about. Um and I and I think
37:12 the point that's really missing here is you know when you can grow today in a
37:18 productled motion faster than ever before and if you actually compare those
37:24 retentions retention cohorts to enterprise businesses you're not going
37:27 to see the same kind of retention. Um but what you actually see in in great
37:31 businesses is you end up seeing a smile curve. And my favorite graph for this
37:35 is, you know, I've tweeted this multiple multiple times is you look at the chat
37:39 PT retention cohorts. Um, if you looked at, there's this great article, funnily
37:43 enough, this is a great article Sequoia put out a long time ago, which is
37:47 talking about generative AI act one or I think it was act two, I'm not sure. It's
37:51 they said, you know, the growth is here, but the retention is not. Uh if you
37:56 compare 1 month retention on chat GPT to any other product in the market say like
38:02 classic YouTube or a WhatsApp um it's far far from that retention. It was
38:06 something like a 40% maybe less whereas other products are at 80 to 90. Um and
38:11 then if you look at the cohort retention curves over time, holy hell have has
38:16 that changed. Like it has become a 90% retention product over time. though you
38:20 know the two common things I read and I see all the time is people um they whine
38:23 about retention and they whine about margins. Growth I think is way way way
38:28 harder than either fixing retention or margins. So as an investor I am very
38:33 comfortable you know uh backing companies who are able to grow and then
38:38 think about how we can figure out the retention and the margin story and we're
38:42 seeing that at these companies like people complain about cursor margins all
38:47 the time. Um but but you know what like they're doing some interesting stuff.
38:51 The likelihood that Cursor fixes their margin structures, the likelihood that
38:55 Anthropic fixes their margin structures is far more than another company growing
39:00 into tens and hundreds of billions of dollars of revenue scale. Um, so you
39:05 know, I I'll put it put it that way. >> Also, I think the uh the retention
39:08 numbers matter a little bit less when the top of your funnel is 800 million
39:12 weekly active users. I mean, you're not selling to 15 people, so you need to
39:16 keep 10 of them. you have the whole world essentially as a potential
39:19 customer and OpenAI's done a lot of work in India DD to build out um Chad GPD go
39:24 and then they also launched a Indian language model benchmark recently which
39:28 I felt was indicative of where we're seeing a lot of AI demand which would be
39:31 in this case India >> India is an interesting story especially
39:35 when it relates to chachi I'm really really curious how this plays out
39:38 because you know I I'd worked at Google prior to this and we were focused on a
39:41 lot of the India efforts and one thing that's really really surprising was
39:46 surprising to me then is the India internet view is very different from
39:52 what the American view is. So for example, it was kind of like I I took it
39:56 for granted that search is always the biggest Google product and then there's
39:59 you know maybe a YouTube maps things like that. >> In India YouTube was far far ahead of
40:05 search as a product. In fact people didn't see search as the same kind of
40:10 valuable utility even though it was a really high number as people in in in
40:14 the west would. And so I think what what's really going to be interesting
40:18 for chat GBT is people are adopting it but language and typing out queries is
40:23 not fundamentally as widespread in that market as it is in say an American
40:28 market. Um and so it'll be super interesting to see how that plays out. I
40:33 think video audio these sorts of multiple languages are going to be a
40:36 really interesting phenomena when it comes to AI in India and also you know
40:39 willingness to pay for software in India is far far less than in in America. So,
40:43 >> well, I mean that'll change with time, but I do have the chart you were talking
40:47 about. Here is the smile curve from uh Chad GPD and DD just be a VC for me for
40:52 a second. Um, when you see this, what's the first thing you notice? And, uh,
40:55 talk to people as if they can't see the chart because a lot of folks are on
40:57 audio as they hear this. >> Okay, so let me try to describe this.
41:01 Um, when I had tweeted this out a while ago, I called this the product manager's
41:05 wet dream. I think this is absolutely when you're a product manager, you look
41:09 at things like cohort retention charts. What a cohort retention chart is, and
41:13 I'm not going to put all the caveats in here, is if I have a 100% of users on
41:19 day zero for a given week, how many of those users return to pay me or return
41:25 to the product? There's two kinds on week 2, three, four, and down the line.
41:30 Um, now when you look at those weeks stacked up over time, what you're really
41:34 looking for both as a PM and as an investor is you want the curves to look
41:39 like they're going up. You want more retention. So from month one in if
41:42 you're looking at this graph it used to be a 60% at month one and you see this
41:48 go up over time for every incremental week and now it's about 90%. And this
41:54 entire graph not only does it sort of decay over time but then you see what's
41:59 called a smile curve which is people actually come back and pay more. So
42:04 after they may have turned, they may have cancelled, they come back and they
42:07 go like the same user comes back in maybe month 10 and goes like, you know
42:11 what, I missed that. I need chat GPT again. I'm going to go and pay more. And
42:16 a smile curve is the most beautiful oneline description of I have product
42:21 market fit. People will churn and go like, nah, just kidding. I'm back. Um,
42:25 and that's what's beautiful about um that that graph. It goes up and to the
42:28 right, up and to the left in this case actually. >> And that was for Gemini's product. This
42:34 was for Chachi PT. Um >> we we have a Gemini white chart here,
42:36 Jason. >> No, it's fine. I'm just Yeah, it's just impressive to see that the brand is so
42:43 strong. It's This would go back to the sampling thing we were talking about
42:46 earlier. People like will start using a product and then they forget they used
42:51 it uh and then six months later, a year later, they go to it and it's like, "Oh,
42:55 you already have an account. Oh yeah, there was the project I worked on. Yeah,
42:59 now I'm ready to pay for it because the product has proven itself." That is the
43:03 one strange thing about this moment in time in this technology wave is that so
43:09 many of the um products are providing so much value that people will pay for
43:16 them. Um and to think like you know proumers you know content creators are
43:22 willing to just buy 10 tools a month for $15 to $150 each. Like it's just 10
43:28 years ago it was like pulling teeth to get them to pay for anything. They were
43:31 just like so cheap. They, you know, I'll just figure out a way to do it for free.
43:34 I'll use open source software if I have to, whatever. And now they're just like,
43:37 yeah, I'm making money. I need to I need the best possible tool. I'm not trying
43:40 to save money. I'm trying to make better I want to bring up something that we're
44:03 hearing from a lot of uh launch founders in the accelerator or at founder U. Uh
44:08 there's a lot of reports that the bar for preede is just getting higher and
44:12 higher and higher and so people are kind of curious uh for you guys to answer
44:16 what is a reasonable set of venture expectations for preede companies. uh
44:20 and people are particularly asking why is there so much of a revenue
44:23 expectation for companies that used to be at that stage couple of founders and
44:27 an idea and uh Jay I want to start with you on this one current expectations and
44:31 why things have changed >> yeah it's interesting I I think um
44:37 this whole AI boom has masked the fact that it's actually a tough tough
44:42 environment out there for everybody else um and so if you think about kind of a
44:48 lot of the capital that kind rushed in into the industry. And these include
44:53 non-traditional sources from private equity firms to sovereign wealth funds
44:57 and whatnot that we're trying to get into the act. And that kind of
45:00 culminated at the peak of the bubble in 2021. A lot of that money is actually
45:06 kind of gone away. And so there's actually uh as Jason pointed out
45:10 earlier, a lot of the seed funds or preed funds that were actually funding
45:14 those kind of opportunities, they're having trouble raising their funds,
45:18 right? So they're having their challenges. Not a lot of preede seed
45:23 funds are actually actively investing as they were just two three years ago. And
45:28 so obviously the funding environment for those startups that are just coming out
45:32 in preede is obviously very very challenging. And so you know even for us
45:38 when we launched in 2021 the quality of the companies that we're seeing then
45:41 versus what we're seeing today and the quality of the deals in terms of bang
45:46 for the buck valuations that we can get. It's so much better now. I mean, we have
45:51 invested uh alongside with, you know, you guys at launch. Um, yeah. In a
45:57 profitable 1 million AR company at sub 20 million post money valuation,
46:02 >> right? And this company has grown 5x in the last, you know, several months. So,
46:06 there's some really, really good companies out there. And so, if you're
46:09 an investor and you have the capital, you're going to be picky. You're going
46:13 to pick and choose the companies that have great product market fit, great
46:16 background of the founders that are actually showing traction and I don't
46:20 necessarily have to take the risk of pre-revenue opportunities because I can
46:24 actually validate my due diligence. Basically, the market does for me and I
46:27 love it. >> Yeah. It's like there's zero to one and then there's zero to 1 million. Exactly.
46:33 >> These are like two different proof points. Like zero to one, you know, you
46:37 got one customer or whatever or >> you launch the product. like 0 to 1
46:42 million you can't really fake right and you are a function of your
46:45 opportunities. So if there's no companies you know in the seat stage knocking on your door
46:52 with a million dollars in revenue well by definition you're going to invest in
46:56 them to help them get to a million. But if there's 20 who've knocked on your
47:00 door this week and they all have between a half million and 2 million well now
47:03 you're going to make the best choice out of that group. And I've been trying to
47:07 explain this to founders who were lolly gagging, who were taking their time, who
47:13 didn't have a sense of urgency, and then they met reality, and they said, "Well,
47:17 I don't understand. Like, I I was able to raise money for my last startup, and
47:21 I'm further along this time." And I'm like, "You are assuming that you're
47:26 competing against your former self. you're competing against another group
47:31 of founders who are coming who have a company that went to 60 million in
47:35 revenue in this amount of time. Sure, the valuation is much higher, but
47:40 they've eliminated a ton of risk. So, it's very much like the public markets
47:44 today. If you've got a company that has very low margins and very slow growth
47:49 and you're up against Uber or Coinbase or Google or Facebook or Google or
47:54 Amazon and people are looking at those companies go, "Wow, these companies are
47:59 growing revenue on big numbers with great products and they have incredible
48:02 margins and they have momentum and network effects. There's a flight to
48:06 quality." That same kind of thing has happened even as early as seed now and
48:10 series A. Um, >> yeah, I want to jump in here and maybe
48:14 say like there's there's almost like there's two stories of founders really.
48:19 And if you look at the data, it becomes super clear, which is the volume of
48:22 capital deployed in venture is at the highest it's ever been, but the number
48:27 of deals that that capital is chasing is actually shrinking right now. Um, I
48:32 don't know the exact number, but on one hand, you have founders who are like,
48:36 "Holy stop knocking down my door trying to fund me." And on the other
48:39 hand, especially at the earlier stage where the metrics are fewer and far
48:43 between, where founders are like, you know, I I think I'm awesome. I think
48:47 this product is working. Why is nobody taking my call? Um, so yeah, I think the
48:52 data does support that as well. >> All right, just backing up DD really
48:56 quick here with some data. Here's a chart from uh the KPMG Q3 venture pulse.
49:01 Um, and as you can see here, I'll just sports cast a little bit. It's a chart
49:05 showing how much money VCs invest and then the deal count over time and deal
49:09 count peaked in late 21 early 22 and it's been in kind of a secular decline
49:13 since then even though capital has returned to the market. So we're seeing
49:17 a return of dollars DD but not a return of deals which I presume that means your
49:22 no percentage is going up over at Menllo. >> Yeah. Um I mean look Menllo specifically
49:28 is um there was another beautiful graph Peter Walker put out on like you know
49:32 fund returns based on the strategy whether it's a spray or prey or or a um
49:39 a select fund um and um a selective fund and I think Menllo is still very
49:41 traditional that way like we like to pick we like to do lower volume we like
49:45 to work and spend time with our founders. This is why we do lower volume
49:49 deals. Um the reality as like basic eighth graders in math will tell you is
49:54 if you do a more concentrated strategy the variance is much higher. If you do a
49:58 spray and prey strategy the variance is lower. Um what is not so obvious is
50:02 typically I believe that what that chart said too is a spray and prey strategy
50:06 has a lower median return than a concentrated strategy. So obviously at
50:10 Melo we hope that we're not at that median. We hope like we're definitely an
50:14 outlier when we're doing those select deals. Um but man it's it's it's it's
50:19 not easy, right? Like uh everyone is chasing those select founders. Um, so
50:24 how do you go and actually prove that this that you can find them and then add
50:28 value is I think still very tough >> and I think Jay you have to make sure
50:32 you don't overpay because then absolutely >> just to you know
50:37 >> explain to founders who are listening here exactly how hard our job is. Then
50:42 founders want to break the record for their accelerator and get the highest.
50:45 They want to get 1 million more than the last founder, you know, said at the
50:49 poker game they got and they're in a competition which means then we own a
50:52 smaller amount which means then on the exit we get less to return and so the
50:58 game becomes harder and harder um in terms of eventually getting a return for
51:06 your LPs. So it's um I would say perhaps the hardest job in the ecosystem is
51:10 being an investor. I think it actually is. Now, you can't cry for them because
51:14 they get paid huge salaries, you know, and it's it is a pretty great job when
51:18 you have the diversification of 10 bets or 30 bets in your fund, whatever it is.
51:23 Um, but you don't have to sit there grinding your teeth at night. But this
51:28 is the best time possible to be an entrepreneur who can execute and who's
51:32 revenue focused. If you can grow your company, you know, I was telling the
51:36 founders in, you know, when I was out here on my trip, it they said, "Who gets
51:40 funded?" I said the person who's growing 20% a month, person who's growing 5% a
51:46 month today because there's so many deals to look at that people are start
51:51 you you have a choice between which high growth company you want to invest in.
51:54 Exactly. That's a very different world than it was you know 10 20 years ago.
51:59 >> But Jason explain to me how you said earlier that we're seeing VCs kind of
52:03 give up and walk away because maybe this isn't the place for them. And then, you
52:05 know, ever since we've had that point from you, we've talked about how there's
52:08 so many great companies to invest in. They're growing faster. AI payment
52:12 tailwinds. Explain the disconnect between those two points for me.
52:16 >> You know, it's it's just classic supply demand. There were far far too many VCs
52:22 and we saw that break when the private equity folks, as Jay referenced earlier,
52:26 came down and they started competing and they didn't do due diligence. They just
52:30 said, "Oh, if any of these firms do a deal, we'll just do we'll assume that
52:34 that company's been successful and we'll do their next round."
52:37 >> Just think about how crazy that is. That assumes that, you know, if our firm has
52:42 a good track record or or or DD or Jay's have good track records, there's a
52:45 person coming in and just blindly betting on that when we all know that we
52:51 make mistakes, that we are far from perfect in our decision-making. We we in
52:55 fact if you ask most VCs which company did you think in your portfolio was
52:58 going to be the breakout and then which one actually broke out they wouldn't be
53:03 able to tell you at at that time in the first year. So um there was just far too
53:08 much supply of capital um but and there's still a large number of
53:13 companies. um that that's true as well, but if you're going to put larger
53:17 amounts into the winners, that means there's less left over for the rest of
53:22 the the kids in the class, which if you think about it in Darwinian sense, if
53:26 this was, you know, like an ecosystem and these are all different species,
53:32 >> um what we're now seeing is the the species of >> um founders who can generate revenue um
53:39 are going to get a lot more of the calories in the ecosystem. They're
53:42 they're the sharks in this. They're the apex predators. And if you can't get
53:47 revenue, >> you know, you just catch I mean, one way to think about it is remember we had
53:54 this unprecedented bull market leading up to 2021, right? And if you were,
54:00 let's say, an entrepreneur turned angel investor that was betting on YC
54:04 companies that were almost guaranteed to raise the next round of financing and
54:08 you would have automatic writeups. It was a good time to play and those
54:13 results culminated in launching a microVC fund, right? And life was great.
54:18 Life life was easy. Just continue betting on those companies, right? And
54:23 now the world has changed. We're living in a different world. You know, there
54:26 was a time where, you know, the tide would raise old boats. Uh it's become a
54:31 lot more difficult now. And so the ones that actually have experience, have the
54:35 data pattern recognition, have a reputation with the entrepreneurs are
54:39 still going to be able to find those opportunities. But if not, and you've
54:44 been part of that crowd and you've just been kind of riding that wave, it's it's
54:47 a lot harder. So those are the folks Jason I think uh refers to that are not
54:51 going to be able to raise their next fund because they haven't returned
54:54 capital. >> Yeah. >> And they weren't doing they were blind
54:58 betting in a lot of cases. They just had a network. They bet. They thought they
55:03 were experts at this because the markups happened. >> Exactly.
55:06 >> But then the fundamentals weren't there. And then they did all of their bets if
55:11 they're micro fund because I was LPS in some of them. They might have done all
55:14 their bets in an 18-month window when the mark the valuations were peaking. So
55:18 there was no time um >> diversification. Yeah. >> No time diversification. Thank you, Jay.
55:22 And so that was one of the things I learned from RUF and and Doug Leone and
55:26 Bill Gurley, the people who kind of mentored me when I was coming up is
55:29 like, hey, take your time. You don't have to put it all to work in 18 months.
55:33 You take if you if you deploy over three or four years, which is typically how
55:37 funds used to work, four years, not two or 18 months or some people would deploy
55:41 in a year. Well, you would have, you know, some, you know, uh, time
55:46 diversification as well. And they didn't have that. Uh, and so here we are,
55:51 folks. Um, this Yeah, one of the primary drivers of, >> you know, venture capital return is
55:58 really timing, right? You have to be in the game at the right vintage
56:03 >> uh so that you can exit at the peak and go in low and it's just the way it is.
56:06 >> Yeah. >> Jar, I should wanted to talk to you about entry prices because everything
56:11 that I'm seeing from data sources indicates that we're seeing essentially
56:14 median pre- money valuations get back towards where we were in 2021. But we've
56:19 also discussed quite a lot about how companies have more revenue. they're
56:22 growing more quickly. So, does it kind of net out okay that we're seeing higher
56:26 prices today because the companies are of higher value and therefore just going
56:29 to be more durable to grow into those prices? >> I I I think it is. I I think you know
56:34 it's become a little bit easier quite frankly in terms of discussing valuation
56:40 because now we can actually base uh base the valuation on a revenue multiple,
56:45 right? And as we mentioned earlier, uh we're more than happy to wait to
56:49 actually see some early traction, >> uh and give a fair valuation based upon
56:53 kind of what the, >> you know, generated revenue or AR at
56:57 that particular point in time is or at least what the expected one would be 12
57:01 months from now and have a reasonable conversation about what the appropriate
57:05 multiple is instead of just trying to draw numbers out of thin air. So while I
57:10 I believe medium valuations are kind of normalized somewhat, the underlying
57:14 revenue growth is actually much better these days. And so thus we're getting
57:19 more better I would say better priced opportunities. >> Maybe I'll add some color to that.
57:23 >> Oh dude, please. >> Like I think the median valuations I
57:27 agree with Jay's point, but you know what's interesting is if you look at the
57:30 95th percentile, that's a whole different story, right? Like the median
57:33 valuations look like it's kind of reasonable. Oh yeah, look a little
57:36 uptick this year. That's nice, but things are growing. I agree. On the
57:41 extremes, I mean, it's it's crazy out there, right? Like you have multiple
57:46 companies with no revenue raising at a billion dollars. Um, you have, you know,
57:51 I've had in this past week multiple people say, "We're AI guys, so I need
57:56 $100 million because here's this cool result. No business, no nothing." And
57:59 I'm like, "This is a recurring phenomena." So, you know, and and some
58:04 of them are going to raise those rounds. um whether whether I say yes or no. So I
58:09 I do think there is also a bit of a a story um there as well at the median. I
58:14 think yeah it's fine. I mean like for growing so fast if you're you look at
58:17 anthropic right like anthropic is literally the fastest growing software
58:23 company of all time zero 100 million a billion and then this year tracking to
58:27 10 billion. These are madeup numbers like you can't tell people this.
58:31 >> You got to show this chart. I mean, this is mindblowing.
58:34 >> I've seen it. It's crazy. >> Here is the chart uh from our dear
58:37 friends over at the information. Giving them some credit uh of revenue growth
58:42 from both OpenAI and Anthropic. This comes from a story, guys, that came out
58:46 this week uh indicating that Anthropic has raised its revenue projections. And
58:50 as you can see here, it's grown from incredibly little to quite a lot. Uh 1
58:54 billion error at the start of the year to 7 billion at the last thing that I
58:58 heard. Though, DD sounds like 10 billion might be the new number. I mean around
59:01 that amount. I mean I I'm following the information leaks. These are not
59:06 investor comments. I um this is how much information I I I get about Anthropic.
59:11 But but look, I mean the reality is Anthropic has has always underestimated
59:16 their own numbers. >> So So this projection is not as wild as
59:22 it might seem. if you if you know the history of how often they have
59:26 undersshot their actual goal which is every single time every single year
59:30 they've undersshot their own goals. So, you know, I think I think it's it's it's
59:34 just insane how much growth there actually is for the absolute top
59:38 companies. One last thing I want to say Jason said the hardest job is is is in
59:41 investors. That's absolutely not true. The hardest job is definitely a
59:46 founders. Um, man. Oh my god. >> I think maybe he was saying like chance
59:49 of success is is >> Yeah, I'm talking more about like the I
59:51 know I'm just >> the conversation, but yeah, [laughter]
59:54 >> but um >> this is going to get clipped and put on
59:58 VC brags. I can tell. >> No, no, no. There's two different
60:00 things. Like if you really want to make the big money, be a founder for sure. Uh
60:04 and then joining these great companies is a clearer path to compensation. But
60:10 VCs don't have to work 996. Um and they're not. I mean, yeah, that's that's
60:15 very true. I think >> what what what are VC hours if if
60:19 engineers have to work 996 a day? Uh, >> what is it like?
60:21 >> I mean, I worked I would say I probably work 60 70 hours a week and people on my
60:26 team work 50 to 70. >> DD, how much do you work? >> I I I don't not work. Like I think I
60:31 work all the time. I don't think the work is as intense as it was maybe when
60:36 I was at a startup. But I mean, you know, look, >> like I'll be just candid like I'm I'm
60:40 new in this industry. Like, and I think like the only thing that I have to add
60:44 is is is hours. That's like the only thing I can control is how much
60:47 information I'm ingesting. I'm able to process and then helping the people that
60:51 I'm trying to help. And so, you know, that that that means that that frankly
60:55 like I will like I will return texts at 1:00 a.m. I am up working all the time.
61:00 Um I I don't have a family yet. And so at some point maybe that will change,
61:04 but right now like this is this is my life. >> All right. Uh Jay, just because we're
61:08 doing this apparently, how much do you work? And are you working the uh the
61:13 1024 that I hear VCs love to rock? >> Well, I I think I think as you know,
61:18 Jason alluded to, I think, you know, all of us have to be constantly on, right?
61:23 So, if you actually count the hours that you're off, you know, you're sleeping,
61:27 you know, uh bathroom breaks and whatnot, >> um maybe you you have some, you know,
61:32 private hobbies that you enjoy. I love to watch movies. I'll play some games
61:37 once in a while, but ex excluding all of that, like I'm constantly on and you
61:42 know, uh everybody knows this, but I'm have this kind of bad habit like I have
61:48 a zero inbox habit. So I will have to clear my inbox before going to bed and
61:52 the first thing I do when I wake up grab my phone and go through my emails and
61:56 texts and messages and whatnot. And so I think most functioning VCs are basically
62:01 trained to work like that because that's the expectation. You know, you kind of
62:05 have to keep pace with your founders. >> You have to keep pace with the founders
62:09 and then you have to the deals are getting done so quickly now
62:14 >> that you know if you need time to do diligence, well that's on you. you you
62:18 better move quick because a founder can just say like yeah you know um we don't
62:22 have time to wait we'll talk to you in the next round and if you are able to
62:27 get in the next round so you really need >> on the the diligence I can share um yeah
62:31 go ahead you know there there was an interesting anecdote I'm obviously not
62:33 going to name the people involved but you know there was a a close friend
62:37 founder of mine who was raising this round and um and and you know at some
62:42 point he was like hey can you look through my data room like tell me if I'm
62:45 doing things right um this is kind of my first rodeo doing this kind of round. Um, and and I
62:50 look through it and I give him some feedback at the end of the day and he
62:53 goes like, "Hey man, we already have term sheets." I'm like, "Dude,
62:57 [laughter] you didn't have you didn't have a data room. Like, what do you
63:00 mean? Like, you didn't have your financials on there. What do you mean
63:03 you have a term sheet?" He's like, "Dude, I'm just telling you what
63:06 happened, man. Like, I I I don't know how. I don't know what I did but it is
63:11 actually true that because of the speed of these deals and speed is a
63:16 differentiating factor in order for many people to win deals that um look there
63:20 are some cases where diligence is just not happening. That's the reality
63:24 >> we just we just went through a lesson in 2021 about not doing diligence,
63:28 investing too quickly and assigning unicorn valuations to revenue free
63:32 companies. What the are we doing now? FTX. I mean, you're speaking of Sequoia
63:37 and other firms. A lot of them just drafted on each other's supposed
63:43 diligence. And it is when the market gets hot, and I've lived through now a
63:48 couple of bubbles, like three, I think four. Yeah. And I I always see the same
63:53 thing. Um people lack discipline, so they don't do diligence, right? Um so
63:58 they suspend disbelief. Okay. Number two, they get really greedy. So they
64:02 don't take the opportunity to liquidate positions when they maybe have the
64:05 opportunity on. They hold on too long, etc. Um, and then I see people actually
64:11 acting um I see people acting unethically and that happens in a bubble
64:17 as well. And you'll see this ZD like you'll start to see people who retrade
64:21 deals on either side. It could be founders, it could be entrepreneurs. Um,
64:25 you know, you'll have a founder sign a term sheet for a convertible note at one
64:31 valuation and then another VC pays at a different valuation. They're in the same
64:34 round. One person has MFN, another person has a side letter. Nobody knows
64:39 the complete picture of what's going on. And so, we've had to unravel some of
64:43 these things that have occurred. I don't recommend anybody do anything other than
64:46 standard documents and being upfront with everybody because when people find
64:50 out that you gave a special deal to one firm or that somebody had some special
64:55 side letter or whatever it is um and they might have MFN in their documents,
64:58 you may have to go correct that in the next round and the valuation's gone up
65:01 now. Yeah, just always standard documents and and don't play any games.
65:06 Um you know and uh yeah, just best advice. people get very weird. And then
65:10 the other thing that happens is people, you know, um sometimes uh they forget
65:15 who helped get them here. You know, we'll have, you know, you see this every
65:19 time there's a bubble. People will be like, "Oh, you got an amazing deal. You
65:22 have to give up your board seat. You have to give up your PRAA. You have to
65:26 give up your information rights." Like, well, we invested in you three years ago
65:29 and nobody else believed in you. Why are you asking us to give up all of these
65:33 rights? and the founder will say, "Oh, the VC who was doing this round is
65:36 saying if you don't give them up, they're not going to do the round and
65:39 they're not, you know, all kinds of shenanigans occur." Um, just being
65:43 standard and being upfront and like you can really see people maybe start
65:47 playing short-term games instead of long-term games. I'm a long-term game
65:52 guy. Like really like the long-term game of uh everybody just being respectful
65:57 and not trying to get over on people. I saw there was somebody talking I think
66:01 Jason Lmin said he saw like a couple of founders just abscondone with the money.
66:05 So when we get these peak moments and then people don't do due diligence you
66:08 could have interlopers come into the industry and everybody knows those
66:12 stories as well. >> Dy uh are you see I'm sorry Jay are you
66:16 seeing similar levels of uh of malfeasants and poor behavior as we are
66:22 in um let's say a hot market. I mean, fortunately, I haven't directly
66:26 experienced as much, but I'm sure it's out there. Um, we've heard, you know,
66:30 stories uh from our colleagues out there. [snorts] I I do think that the
66:36 the level of FOMO is getting to kind of bubble levels for sure. Um, I've heard
66:41 stories now of high growth founders being chased at airport security lines,
66:47 people showing up unannounced at doorsteps with term sheets. I mean,
66:52 things are getting pretty frothy again. And so, um, >> yeah,
66:56 >> you know, again, understandably, nobody wants to miss out on the next, you know,
67:01 open AI, anthropic, lovable, whatever that is, but it's it's getting out of
67:03 control. >> All right, so one way that founders create FOMO. Uh, and I actually have a
67:10 tweet here from from Dee is by doing uh intelligent work on social media. Uh,
67:13 this is a tweet from Dee saying, "This is the ultimate Tik Tok growth marketing
67:18 guide every Gen Z founder is using." And one thing I'm really bored of is
67:21 expensively slickly produced launch videos DD. Uh but it seems that because
67:25 everyone knows you can now go from zero to 100 million ARR faster, they're more
67:30 desperate to grow revenue uh from kind of day zero versus maybe a little bit
67:32 later when they have better fundamentals, economics. Um and you're
67:36 kind of tongue-in-cheek playing into this here, but is it healthy for the
67:41 startup land to index so heavily on I would say like inroup virality over on X
67:48 or Tik Tok? Um, I I actually like don't mind it. I don't think it matters. I
67:52 think the problem really is when the product does not follow that marketing,
67:55 right? Like the the fact that you're doing like viral distribution campaigns
68:00 is is immaterial to me. Like X is a pretty terrible place to do viral
68:03 distribution campaigns in terms of the volume and audience you reach. So I
68:07 think founders doing it on X are maybe more clout chasing than business
68:11 chasing. Look, the real audience is probably on the other like Instagram and
68:16 and Tik Tok and Reddit and things like that. And um and I think that's fair.
68:19 Look, like if you're trying to grow your product really fast, like absolutely you
68:23 should be employing um all the tricks of the trade to do that. If you do that and
68:27 your product is absolutely then then you're going to have a hard time,
68:30 right? Like it's just going to you're going to try to run behind something
68:33 that you can't keep up with. So that's not great. Um, and on the flip side of
68:37 this, what's super fascinating to me, this was fascinating to me in the last
68:40 couple of weeks actually, is I've been doing this all the time. I I suggest you
68:43 guys do it if you have like a lot of free time. But, um, do you know how we
68:50 know that LLMs and chat GPT often when you ask it a question, it will summarize
68:53 from a bunch of web results, right? And a lot of those web results happen to be
68:59 Reddit results. And so there are entire companies built on spamming Reddit in
69:04 with high quality content that's completely AI generated where they sneak
69:09 your company that they're trying to sell in there in ways that trust me like most
69:14 humans including myself would not know that this is fake at at face value.
69:19 >> And so what's happening is like it's not just the Tik Tok and Instagram stuff. It
69:24 is also like this insidious nature in LinkedIn and in Reddit where there's
69:28 these the not only sponsored content but these automatically algorithmically
69:32 generated content from like basically bot farms of an anonymous accounts that
69:36 are influencing people's behavior. >> Wow. >> And slop is an interesting terminology.
69:40 I actually had this interesting conversation the other day where like
69:44 the real question is it is only slop when we know it's AI generated. But the
69:49 reality is in most cases people don't know. They be a stupid person or just an
69:54 unsophisticated person reading it, not realizing it's slop. Yeah.
69:56 >> Well, well, it's not only that, though. The quality of some of these short form
70:01 video creation is mind-blowing. I I challenge you to notice a difference.
70:05 Just a year ago, two years ago, you could tell, right? Everybody's
70:08 everything is still in just the mouth is moving. Nowadays, it's so sophisticated,
70:13 multiple camera angles. I mean, look, the point that was made earlier about,
70:18 you know, viral growth generation, some of the smartest guys are using these AI
70:22 tools to do it. Think about the fact that instead of having to record these
70:26 short form videos multiple times a day, you can actually create a video
70:32 likeness, virtual likeness of yourself using AI, having scripts that are
70:37 autogenerated using generative AI and just having them automatically posted to
70:42 a specific targeted audience that again you use Aentic AI to specifically
70:46 target. We just closed an investment in a company and I've never done this
70:51 before. They are a AI chatbot company and again why would you invest in an AI
70:54 chatbot company? Because they're are changing the game and the way they
70:59 fundraised they actually found investors all using their own tools the due
71:03 diligence the pitch deck and even all the due diligence questions you would
71:07 come to their website and you would be able to actually utilize their own
71:11 chatbot to generate the engines. I love that. And so, you know, there are so
71:16 many AI tools these days that are making every step of the startup business
71:21 process so much more efficient. You know, if you're not taking advantage of
71:24 that, I don't think you're doing your job right. >> What's the company that you just made an
71:28 investment into? >> Uh, this is a company called Lizer.
71:31 Shout out to Lizer. >> LYZ. >> If you want to look it up, it's Lyz.ai.
71:41 If you're listening into this live, I have not heard of this company. Um,
71:45 >> you'll be hearing about it. >> Okay. >> But I just love the ESOS that they were
71:49 basically eating their own dog food in their fundraising process. And they have
71:53 a little bit of a shout out on a LinkedIn post to announce to other
71:58 founders to utilize their own service to be able to actually raise your series C,
72:03 series A. I want to loop back to what Dee said about um insidiously basically
72:10 SpawnCon being put into human forums. Uh this is kind of the dead internet
72:14 theory. DD, are we at risk of a of reaching a tipping point in which we've
72:17 automated so much content generation that we wind up in a world when it's
72:21 just bots watching bots and humans are just left by the wayside? And I ask
72:25 because I I was expecting a more negative reaction to the the Clo style
72:29 hype videos from y'all, but instead very much a different response, which is
72:33 good. why you ask questions, but it makes me worry that if you guys are this
72:36 positive on it, we're going to see so much of it that it could become a
72:40 prepoundonderance. >> I think look, it's it's just not our my
72:45 position to say, right? Like if I was at Google or at Reddit, I would want to
72:49 tamp down on this. Absolutely. Right. I don't want my my platform to be spammed
72:55 with with with AI generated content. Um but on the founder side like look if
72:59 that is an avenue that you that is generating um uh engagement for you I
73:04 can't complain if they want to use that to to grow their business. Um so so I I
73:10 really do think that it like I I I hate that internet theory. I hate the fact
73:14 that this exists at a philosophical level. I don't think that should happen.
73:18 You know there's this um there's this great graph called uh which people are
73:21 calling the new flipping. I don't know exactly how they uh got this data, but
73:27 it shows how much of the internet's content is human generated versus
73:32 AIDated over time. And uh and and what does that mean like for the future of
73:36 how even like these great products like chat GPT work? Like it's just going to
73:42 be a loop of eating its own slop and and then and and turning out stuff that is
73:46 not human generated at It it means an opportunity, the opportunity for us as
73:52 humans to in some way, you know, authenticate that the content we're
73:57 making is in fact us and not AI. And I think what you're going to see is like
74:00 in Star Wars when they say, "Hey, we don't want your kind in here on Moss
74:03 Eisley." And they don't let the droids into the bar. That's happening now. No
74:11 AI. So people are now putting on their movies or, you know, on their stories,
74:16 no AI. This includes no AI. There's no AI added to this. So, it's going to be
74:21 kind of like acoustic or organic food. People are going to start labeling
74:25 things human only or 100% human as a reaction to this. Now, I love the
74:29 storytelling. Like, so clearly, I'm not sure if their business will be
74:32 successful or not. We've had the founder on here. He's super spicy, but they know
74:37 how to storytell. And storytelling is important because you the ability to
74:41 tell a story is something that Elon does exceptionally well when he runs his
74:46 companies. Steve Jobs does exceptionally well when he does his stories. Travis
74:50 and Uber did this exceptionally well. They told the story of why this needs to
74:54 exist. And to do it in a short form video and make it punchy because today's
74:59 tools allow you to do that. If if that explains your value proposition to users
75:05 faster than tool tips in the app or word of mouth, great. We have a company
75:09 Howie, we're investors in. We seated the company um and they just did like their
75:13 own launch video about like doing meetings and a lot of VCs use this Howie
75:17 software to do meetings and book them. They've got human in the loop to make
75:22 sure it does what it does correctly. Um that ad just added like um a lot of
75:28 brand value to them. They added like a vibe of like this isn't just a regular
75:35 service. This is like we actually care enough about the service to tell the
75:38 story in a really interesting way. I kind of like it actually. It's kind of
75:42 the difference between somebody who makes like a cheap $8, you know, $3
75:47 t-shirt merch that nobody's ever going to wear and then somebody makes some
75:52 really interesting great piece of merch that you actually use in the world. Um,
75:57 it's kind of like that. But I I love some of these launch videos. I go I
76:00 could watch them all day if they're done well. >> All right. Well, color me wrong on that
76:05 one. Guys, I have to take us to a conclusion here. We could talk for the
76:08 next three days. I know, but I do want to give each of you a chance to shout
76:11 out a portfolio company. Tradition that I do these. Uh so Jay, who is your
76:16 current favorite child and why? >> All of our babies are cute and
76:19 beautiful. [laughter] Um but I do want to give a shout out since we've talked about Hicksfield
76:23 already >> uh to Abacus and uh Jason. I hope they're on your favorite list as well.
76:28 But >> I just love the fact that this entrepreneur bootstrapped his way
76:35 >> to a million-dollar AR. And as we all know, while every consumer out there has
76:40 now tried some form of AI agent, whether it's ChachiPT or whatever, um there's
76:45 certain enterprises and certain industries where you're literally banned
76:51 from using it, right? And so I think the fact that in the financial industry or
76:55 the healthcare industry where your data cannot leave the prem uh you have
76:59 companies like Abacus that come from the industry know these pain points and
77:03 they've built a model where they basically have created kind of a I would
77:09 say a AI foundry service in a way where they enable the enterprise customers to
77:15 basically train on your own data. They provide all the tools and the
77:18 infrastructure uh using open source models and they are able to even provide
77:24 a application generation platform where you can build your own in-house version
77:29 of chat tpt to be used for in-house compliance rule lookup policies and all
77:34 of these things that you know would be great to have on your fingertips.
77:39 They've screened out for hallucinations and whatnot to make sure it's 100%
77:44 accurate. And once it's been proven and tested in an internal environment, guess
77:47 what? They're going to try it with partners and customers. >> Yeah.
77:51 >> And so it's just a great great model and just love the grid of the entrepreneur
77:55 to actually start this from scratch, >> bootstrap it all the way to a
77:58 million-dollar ARR and now they're off to the races. >> Goabacus.co is the URL if you want to
78:03 check it out. Dee, uh, who is your favorite port and why is it open router?
78:07 >> [laughter] >> Well, I I don't think Open Router needs
78:11 another shout for me given that Elon tweets about it like five times a day.
78:16 Um, but [laughter] um >> I mean it's got the best charts online,
78:20 man. I love it. [snorts] >> Um, look, I'll I'll talk a little bit
78:23 about Open Router. I'll maybe do an actual shout that I think deserves uh
78:27 needs it more maybe. Um, Open Router, look, fantastic business. It's part of
78:31 my thesis that if you are a if you can be a productled growth company, you must
78:35 be a productled growth company. There's various versions of an open router that
78:39 could have gone and sold B2B to enterprises, but they were are
78:42 absolutely going to be steamrolled by this massive thing that has um awareness
78:47 in the in the broader world and and they are so love that company. It's
78:50 fantastic. We're going to live in a multimodel world. People want to know
78:54 what's happening. There's 20 plus great models and hundreds of other models.
78:57 >> Sure. >> With different providers and people want
78:59 to know which providers are doing what and how can I access the different
79:01 models. So, >> but the company you love even more is I love open router. They don't need my
79:08 love anymore. They're they're they're they're they're kings. Um GoodFire is
79:13 the company. I would love to show that. >> Yes. >> And um and the reason um a little bit of
79:18 the backstory on Goodfire is look, it's a mechanistic interpretability company.
79:22 That's a fancy way of saying brain surgery for AI models. Um we don't
79:28 really understand how AI models work. We don't understand how they think. We rely
79:32 on them to give us thinking traces which are poor proxies for what's actually
79:36 going on inside their head. Um, and these are the top mechanistic
79:39 interpretability researchers who started teams at anthropic, deep mind, open AAI
79:44 who've come together to set out on this mission to really understand what's
79:49 going on as in in AI models as it becomes ubiquitous. I think it's
79:52 absolutely fundamental for society for us to understand this because we cannot
79:56 trust black boxes with, you know, huge decisions. Um, and I think they have
79:59 tremendously cruel scientific breakthroughs that um, they will
80:03 announce at some point that are going to be extremely valuable.
80:06 >> I was excited about Goodfire if we got into deep tech because I know that Jay's
80:09 made some investments into robotics companies and when I saw that they were
80:12 an AI interpretability research company, I was like, yes, that. Um, but we got to
80:16 move on. Jason, last question is for you. Who is your favorite portco or at
80:20 least the one you want to shout out on the show? >> Well, I mean, I could have done Abacus,
80:24 but I'll do a different one. Um, and spread the love. Next visit uh AI. This
80:30 is an AI powered um you know uh clinical notetaker except it works in a very
80:36 specific vertical which is uh psychiatry and that has very specific note
80:41 takingaking details as you could imagine and this is a great co-founding team
80:48 with a psychiatrist and an AI specialist and they very quickly got this to work
80:53 and you can imagine psychiatrists who are doing counseling or just sessions
80:58 and prescribing drugs drugs and a lot of other modalities. Um, they spend like
81:03 half their time, a third of their time just doing paperwork and this stuff is
81:07 just nailed it. The fidelity when you go after something narrow uh as a startup
81:13 and you get it right, it can really pay off. And so this is one of the things we
81:16 try to teach people in the accelerator. They're they're concerned, oh VCs are
81:20 not going to be impressed because it's such a small idea. Like trading a stock
81:25 for free is a very small idea called Robin Hood. Like watching your taxi come
81:32 to you on a Google map and paying for it is a very small idea, but it's a
81:36 profound idea that then things were built on top of like Robin Hood is not
81:41 just trading a stock for free. Now you can get margin loans, you can do crypto,
81:46 you can do prediction market, Jason, they do mortgages now. Okay. I wasn't
81:50 even aware of that one, but you know, it's um I always like this laser focus.
81:54 I tell people like you can turn on a flashlight and just like kind of point
81:59 in the forest and like, "Yeah, we're going to do something out there." When
82:02 you take the laser pointer and you're like, "We're going to do that." See that
82:05 thing right there? Right there. That's what we're doing. That laser, we're
82:08 going to do it really, really well and make it perfect so the customer has no
82:13 choice but to use this product and they love it more than anything they've ever
82:17 had. That's kind of the magic in that year zero or year one. Just do one thing
82:21 better than everybody in the world that makes that customer just so delighted
82:25 they won't shut up about it. And that's when your PS score gets like nine or 10.
82:30 And so everybody wants to do, you know, the co-pilot that transcribes what
82:34 you're saying. But man, just getting in there and knowing that this person is
82:39 taking this ADH manication on this level and it's this code and it's this type of
82:44 ADHD medicine. And it's not the generic, it's a specific one with a specific one.
82:48 Like, you got to get that right. You can't get that wrong, right? Or else
82:51 it's just not worth using. It's not like a hallucination when you're trying to
82:53 figure out what movie to watch this weekend. >> Favorite Paul Thomas Anderson. Jay, your
82:59 your favorite Paul Thomas Anderson. Speaking of movies, you say you like
83:01 movies. You have a >> Oh, >> you have Paul Thomas Anderson guy.
83:06 >> Yeah, the most recent one. What is it? This uh Leo,
83:09 >> one battle after another. >> Is that I was on the edge of my seat the
83:13 whole freaking time. That was crazy. >> It It is like a threehour like
83:17 >> Oh yeah, it's an experience. >> It's a marathon in a sprint. It's crazy.
83:23 >> Um but uh it's I you know my Paul Thomas Anderson favorite still remains The
83:26 Master and then >> Oh, that that movie was >> The Masters. That's next level. De's
83:32 looking at us like, "How do you guys have time for this? [laughter]
83:35 We're from a different generation. We cared about cinema." >> All right, everybody. See you next time.
83:41 >> All right, bye everybody. This has been Twist. We'll see you all soon.
83:43 >> This was so much fun, guys. Thanks. >> Great times. Thanks for doing it. Jay
$

Is investing REALLY the hardest job? A TWIST VC Roundtable (ft. Deedy Das and Jay Eum) | E2204

@thisweekinstartups 1:23:50 21 chapters
[fundraising and investment][AI agents and automation]
// chapters
// description

Register for Founder University Japan’s kickoff! https://luma.com/cm0x90mk * Today’s show: *On TWiST, Jason welcomes an all-star VC panel — Deedy Das of Menlo Partners and Jay Eum of GFT Ventures — for a deep dive into the shocking scale of early-stage AI raises, a transitional moment for investors, the growing importance of the “prosumer” market, ChatGPT’s insane smile curves, and much much more. IN THIS EPISODE - What the panelists make of Roelof Botha’s exit from Sequoia… and is he real

now: 0:00
// tags
[fundraising and investment][AI agents and automation]