you2idea@video:~$ watch 7jEUQf6uqaM [1:23:34]
// transcript — 1192 segments
0:02 I think in general um my sense is that overall companies that have been
0:05 considering going public have now sort of opted to do that sort of route.
0:09 >> Okay. I I was asking because there's a great note in their S1 Jason you'll love
0:12 this. Uh they were talking about how they're using their AI powered virtual
0:16 agent chatbot and they say that our ability to control customer support
0:19 costs over time even as volume has gone up has contributed to an increase in
0:23 gross margin from 60% in fiscal 24 to 68 in fiscal 25 and even more. So
0:27 essentially they're automating things Jason static team size cost savings and
0:31 uh it's helping the company look more profitable. So kind of an AI story and a
0:35 fintech story a lot the the age of efficiency is upon us. Uh every unit in
0:41 every company um particularly in startups who are always resource
0:46 constrained they are the ones to first use these tools because they're resource
0:49 constrained. If they can save a they can turn a nickel into a dollar a startup's
0:53 going to do it. Now big companies like well we're spending $3 to get a dollar
0:56 in value and we can afford to do it because we're sitting on a bunch of
0:59 cash. There's no, you know, imperative. There's no existential dread about money at Apple
1:05 when you're sitting on hundreds of billions of dollars in cash. So yeah,
1:08 we'll get to it when we get to it. But at a startup, it's quite the opposite.
1:12 You're seeing that as well, I assume, lad. Is uh startups doing really
1:16 fascinating stuff with this technology already. >> Yeah, it's super exciting. I mean the
1:20 ramp on revenue for some of these companies is out of this world, right? I
1:25 mean between going from zero to a few hundred million in revenue in two three
1:28 years is something that I haven't seen in a very long time and there's multiple
1:33 companies doing that. So I think uh this is the big sea change and you see it in
1:36 enterprise adoption. You see it in all sorts of things. The company that um I
1:39 started with Jared and Eric and others that we mentioned earlier is basically
1:42 working on this for big enterprise. How can you help big enterprises really make
1:47 that adoption of AI and what applications should you provide for them
1:51 to be able to really thrive in this post AI world? So I think there's there's an
1:53 enormous amount of stuff to be done there. >> Yeah. And it's going to be really
1:59 interesting. The cynical take on this is a lot of people sampling AI solutions
2:03 and triing them and there'll be big churn issues and of course competition
2:09 issues and I guess the um optimist view of it which I'm primarily in that camp
2:14 is these things are providing massive value at very low price. Therefore, why
2:20 wouldn't you try it? It's like >> you know come get three hamburgers that
2:24 are grass-fed beef for 20 bucks. It's like how is that possible? Okay, I don't
2:27 need to know. I'm just going to order the burgers. Like, if you want to charge
2:31 me 20 bucks for something that saves me $2,000 a month. Okay.
2:37 >> And it's just wild to see how [gasps] mispriced some of these products are for
2:41 the value they're creating. >> This week in Startups is brought to you
2:46 by Squarespace. Turn your idea into a beautiful website. Go to
2:50 squarespace.com/twist for a free trial. When you're ready to
2:55 launch, use offer code twist to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or
2:59 domain. Sentry. Your team should be focused on shipping features, not
3:04 chasing down bugs. New users get three months free of the business plan, which
3:09 covers 150,000 errors. Go to centry.io/twist and use the code twist. And Pilot, focus
3:17 on your product. Let Pilot handle your bookkeeping. Pilot provides the most
3:22 reliable accounting, CFO, and tax services for startups and small
3:27 businesses. Head to pilot.com/twist All right, everybody. Welcome back to
3:37 This Week in Startups. I'm your host, Jason Calacanis. With me, my co-host,
3:42 Alex Wilhelm, and got a special guest today. Introduce our guest, Alex. Uh our
3:46 special guest today is the former founder of Mixer Labs and Color Health.
3:50 He helped incubate Brain and Co. but you probably know Allad Gil as an investor
3:54 per excelance. He has backed many many well-known names in the technology world
3:58 and Jason I believe commands the largest single AUM of any solo GP in the world.
4:02 All we're happy to have you. >> Oh, thanks for having me on board.
4:05 >> Yeah. What are you working on these days before we get into all this crazy news?
4:10 What what's uh tickling your fancy? What what are you excited?
4:11 >> Yeah, it's kind of a mix of stuff. Yeah, it's a mix of stuff. Um you know I guess
4:15 three things. One is uh recently launched a company uh with Jared
4:18 Kushner, Eric Woo and a few other folks to bring AI to the world's biggest
4:22 enterprises. So really excited about that. Um second area uh just investing.
4:28 So um you know a lot of the companies I got involved with early Replexity,
4:33 Harvey, Decagon, a bridge etc. on the AI side are obviously all seeing you know
4:37 real growth acceleration etc. And then third, there's kind of some side
4:40 projects I've been working on around building large scale monuments,
4:43 translating books using AI, a variety of different things. And so there's also
4:46 more of the societal or philanthropic stuff that I think has been really fun.
4:49 >> Amazing. >> Kind of those three areas. Yeah. >> What tell me about this uh translating
4:54 books with AI. >> Yeah, we're calling it Alexandria. Um
4:58 the basic idea is that if you look at um every society, we we've benefited since
5:02 the days of Alexandria, the Egyptian library, uh from large-scale access to human
5:07 knowledge and books. And so we're taking a thousand of the most important books
5:11 that are off of copyright and we're translating them, working in concert
5:15 with OpenAI and Enthropic and 11 Labs and a few other folks on um creating a
5:20 book uh a version of the book in every language, audio books in every language.
5:23 So anybody around the world can stream it, they can download it, they can
5:25 interact with it. you've actually built a book reader. Um, and so, you know,
5:29 we'll we'll be doing a launch for that in the next few months. But, uh, that's
5:33 been incredibly rewarding. And we've actually done machine versus human eval
5:37 uh, where people check, do they like more what we've done with translation or
5:42 what human translators have done >> and um, people prefer the machine
5:47 translated works by far and so that's been a really interesting and an
5:49 unexpected. >> What do you attribute it to? >> What do you attribute it to? I think um
5:55 it is often more modern language, although you can obviously tune that
5:59 based on your prompts. >> Um and then I think often it's more
6:02 concise and often it's more consistent. You have better QA, especially if you're
6:06 thinking about a long work or corpus. You can enforce certain things that a
6:09 human translator may or may not be able to do. >> Fascinating. It is.
6:14 >> I want to know how long until you add a zero to that and then another zero. When
6:17 is it 10,000? When is it 100? And what's stopping you from going to like a
6:20 million? There's a lot of books out of copyright a lot. Yeah, I think um we
6:23 decided to start with the things that we thought were books that often should
6:27 exist in other languages that just have never been translated because if you
6:30 look at it, there's maybe two dozen languages that cover 80% of humanity.
6:33 >> Yeah. >> And uh you know for even some of the
6:37 greatest works ever produced or at least the consensus from you know academics is
6:40 these are the greatest books ever produced there just aren't copies in all
6:43 sorts of languages. You know 20 30 40% of humanity can't access them. Um so we
6:46 just thought let's start with the stuff that's kind of obvious. I think to your
6:50 point, you could do um we have the infrastructure built now. So you could
6:54 run an arbitrary book through and if you really wanted to, you could turn this
6:57 into a service where anybody should be able to upload any book and then
7:00 basically have this output in terms of um every language, every audio book. Uh
7:05 we we we've also been looking at building AI guides to the book so you
7:09 can start interacting with it, asking questions, etc. So I think it's almost
7:13 like this modern library of Alexandria, right? We want to bring humanity's
7:17 knowledge to the world in an accessible way. So >> it's been fun.
7:23 >> So you have you also gone down like the bit tensor and distributed computing as
7:29 related to AI and LLM's rabbit hole. >> Yeah, I've looked at it a bit. Yeah.
7:32 What's your conclusion on it? >> I don't have one, but I made a small
7:37 investment in a um like a hedge fund that's looking at all the nodes of Bit
7:41 Tensor every day trying to figure out the different projects, buying you know,
7:47 the the tokens, etc. And it feels to me like now that we're in the sort of Sachs
7:53 era of crypto regulation, I feel more comfortable spending a little time
7:57 there. And I've always felt like distributed computing and would be a
8:04 viable coexistor to cloud computing for certain jobs. Um, and we'll move from
8:08 that set at home >> kind of, you know, I I don't want to say
8:13 silliness, but hobbyist, you know, toy to something more meaningful. And
8:19 perhaps at some point even if we're building out too much infrastructure, it
8:23 could be like Bitcoin and that people will start putting up infrastructure and
8:27 know they'll make um a high return on it and you could get some you know I don't
8:34 know scale that was not previously considered realistic in the same way
8:39 Bitcoin and the number of >> you know uh people participating and the
8:44 number of nodes is would be hard to comprehend. and 10 or 15 years ago,
8:48 right? >> Mhm. Yeah, it's an interesting question because I think in the case of um
8:53 anything that has strong economic viability, compute tends to collapse
8:58 into centralization. And so, for example, um to your point on bitcoining,
9:02 I think uh it's like the six or seven largest mining pools are over 50% of
9:05 Bitcoin volume. >> Yeah. >> And so that's centralization in terms of
9:10 buying of hardware, in terms of energy and negotiation for that. And so anytime
9:13 you have something with a huge economic output, it seems to almost always
9:17 centralize because of those economies of scale. >> Um, and then to your point, there's all
9:20 sorts of circumstances where you have more distribution either because it's
9:24 people who are just, you know, generating an extra bitcoin every once
9:27 in a while because they have some idle capacity, but on a volume basis that's
9:31 pretty low. If you want your business to succeed online, it has to stand out. And
9:35 that's why you need a beautiful worldclass website. The good news is you
9:39 don't have to hire an expensive designer anymore. Nor do you need a bunch of
9:44 developers. No. Squarespace has all the tools you need to claim your domain and
9:47 start building your company. Hey, maybe you got a product to sell. Maybe you
9:50 want to show off some samples of your work. Maybe you've got a new service
9:54 you're providing. Well, Squarespace is the all-in-one tool you need for your
9:59 business to grow and flourish. And they offer beautiful templates. Maybe you
10:03 want to start an online course or you're scheduling appointments for people.
10:06 Maybe you're generating client invoices. All of that is built into the product.
10:10 Everything you create with Squarespace is pre-optimized to show up in search
10:14 engines as well. So, you don't need to hire some expensive SEO person. Nope.
10:18 They're building your metad descriptions. They're setting you up
10:21 with an autogenerated site map. And the SEO is done before you even get started.
10:26 Plus, there's a new AI powered feature. It's called Blueprint, which makes it
10:30 easier than ever before to customize your website and make it really pop. So
10:34 check out squarespace.com/twist for a free trial. And when you're ready to
10:38 launch, go to squarespace.com/twist to get 10% off your first website or domain
10:50 or it could be things like steady at home which is more philanthropic or very
10:54 early bitcoin mining or crypto mining where you know there isn't that same
10:58 liquidity in terms of mining of the token. So it's a really interesting
11:01 question of when do you transition from decentralized to centralized and
11:06 >> the charact and it's an open consolidation that occurs because it's
11:10 not like you have to ask a gatekeeper. It's not like you have to go to you know
11:14 somebody and say I would like to participate in this. Can we cut a deal?
11:17 You're not like negotiating with Oracle or Microsoft. It's like you can just
11:21 participate and >> if you have innovations that you can
11:26 bring to bear. You you come up with your own chipsets. You come up with your own
11:30 power strategies. You >> have a cousin who works at a nuclear
11:35 facility in China and they >> they happen to give you a little space
11:38 for your for your nodes. All of a sudden you're up to the races. So I'm I'm super
11:43 bullish on it. Also like >> um if you just think about all the
11:46 inference that's occurring, it's going to be unlimited demand for this stuff. I
11:52 think I don't know that the demand curve ever. >> Um yeah, I don't know if it's going to
11:59 abate anytime soon. It would What's your take on it? Like the overbuild versus
12:04 >> you know the dark fiber analogy. Do do you have a position on it or does all
12:09 this stuff do you have in paradoxic way to a conclusion? Yeah, I don't have a
12:13 strong point of view on it. I do think there's some really interesting shifts
12:16 that are happening. So to your point on the inference side, eventually more and
12:19 more inference will happen on device. And so to some extent the distributed
12:22 comput notion may just be everybody's iPhone in some sense >> in terms of at least the inference side.
12:26 Um in terms of training, the thing I've been looking at most is the degree to
12:30 which energy costs will impact where training centers are actually going to
12:32 get built. >> Yeah. And one thing that I think is really under discussed is the fact that
12:39 given how early Europe has governed itself relative to energy, you know,
12:43 shutting down nuclear power plants in Germany and um being dependent on
12:48 Russian oil, etc. Um, it basically means that training data centers are unlikely
12:52 to go there because it's going to be too expensive to run them just because of
12:55 energy, ignoring regulation, ignoring everything else. which means that
12:58 basically all the training centers should end up in the Gulf and in the US
13:03 and the Gulf in part because under the Trump um AI plan uh basically there's
13:09 some extension of some rights relative to uh being able to run training in UAE
13:14 and a few other places and those are going to be places with low energy
13:16 costs. So I think there'll be parts of the US, parts of the Gulf where all the
13:20 training is going to run. Inference is probably more globally distributed in
13:24 part because of uh GDPR. So Europe will force it from a regulatory perspective,
13:28 but they're going to lose out on tons of GDP spend and capex spend because people
13:33 just won't build training centers there. So I think that's a little bit
13:35 underdised right now. >> It's quite a paradox because also in the
13:39 Middle East, they're adopting solar and batteries at an extraordinary pace.
13:44 These are people who it seems to me the people who understand energy are not
13:49 being particularly precious about where the energy comes from. In Texas, we have
13:52 the largest >> installed base of solar. And I can tell
13:57 you living in Texas, they're not super precious about, >> you know, where the energy comes from.
14:01 Is it the cheapest way to do it? Great. We can make a business out of that. We
14:04 got a grid. Let's compete. And that's what they're doing in the Middle East
14:08 where there's a lot of sun. There's a lot of sun and there's a lot of capital
14:12 >> to buy those solar panels. And you're right, they just their energy costs are
14:17 going to be so dimminimous. Um and they also have a populace in that region that
14:22 has been educated in the west over the last 30 or 40 years very quietly at the
14:26 top institutions who have now boomeranged back >> to Qatar to UAE to Saudi uh you know and
14:34 then of course you have Israel which is you know just a juggernaut per capita in
14:39 terms of startups. So it's I'm spending more time in the region. I'll probably
14:44 spend two weeks, three weeks, a year there >> um looking at startups and working with
14:48 different investors. Are you spending time in the region? >> A little bit. Yeah, I'm an investor in
14:53 um a few companies, some of whom have been bridged across Israel
14:56 traditionally. So that'd be things like trip action, it's not called Navan, etc.
14:59 But then also more recently a company called Eon, which is doing data infra,
15:03 one called Kella on the defense side, etc. So I have a a handful of
15:07 investments in Israel and then um obviously there's just really
15:09 fascinating things happening across the entire region. Yeah, it's going to be
15:12 really interesting when you can fly direct from, you know, Tel Aviv to Riad
15:21 to DOA to, you know, this is kind of mind-blowing in our lifetime that this
15:24 is happening. >> So, Allad, you mentioned Nvant, which is
15:27 going public right now. It's currently in a little bit of a limbo with the
15:30 government because the government shut down and such, but uh what can you tell
15:33 us about the company's, you know, road to IPO? >> Yeah, I can't really say anything. I
15:37 mean, um, you know, usually IPOs have quiet periods. I think um in general
15:41 >> I was hoping that didn't apply when the government was shut down but apparently
15:43 [laughter] not. >> In general um my understanding of what's
15:48 happening in a meta situation is just uh because of the government shutdown the
15:53 SEC for a short period was not reviewing or fully reviewing S1's and then they
15:57 actually issued a rule that would allow companies to still go public um if they
16:00 did certain filings and certain disclosures and then within a certain
16:04 time period they could go out. And so I think in general um my sense is that
16:07 overall companies that have been considering going public have now sort
16:11 of opted to do that sort of route. >> Okay. I I was asking because there's a
16:15 great note in their S1. Jason, you'll love this. Uh they were talking about
16:17 how they're using their AI powered virtual agent chatbot. And they say that
16:21 our ability to control customer support costs over time even as volume has gone
16:24 up has contributed to an increase in gross margin from 60% in fiscal 24 to 68
16:29 in fiscal 25 and even more. So essentially they're automating things.
16:34 Jason static team size cost savings and uh it's helping the company look more
16:37 profitable. So kind of an AI story and a fintech story a lot.
16:41 >> The the age of efficiency is upon us. Uh every unit in every company um
16:46 particularly in startups who are always resource constrained they are the ones
16:51 to first use these tools because they're resource constrained. If they can save a
16:54 they can turn a nickel into a dollar a startup's going to do it. Now big
16:58 companies like, well, we're spending $3 to get a dollar in value and we can
17:01 afford to do it because we're sitting on a bunch of cash. There's no,
17:05 you know, imperative. There's no existential dread about money at Apple
17:08 when you're sitting on hundreds of billions of dollars in cash. So, yeah,
17:12 we'll get to it when we get to it. But at a startup, it's quite the opposite.
17:15 You're seeing that as well, I assume, lad. Is uh startups doing really
17:19 fascinating stuff with this technology already. >> Yeah, it's super exciting. And the ramp
17:24 on revenue for some of these companies is out of this world, right? I mean,
17:29 between going from zero to a few hundred million in revenue in two three years is
17:32 something that I haven't seen in a very long time. And there's multiple
17:36 companies doing that. So I think uh this is the big sea change and you see it in
17:39 enterprise adoption. You see it in all sorts of things. The company that um I
17:42 started with Jared and Eric and others that we mentioned earlier is basically
17:46 working on this for big enterprise. How can you help big enterprises really make
17:50 that adoption of AI and what applications should you provide for them
17:54 to be able to really thrive in this post AAAI world? So, I think there's there's
17:57 an enormous amount of stuff to be done there. >> Yeah. And it's going to be really
18:02 interesting. The cynical take on this is a lot of people sampling AI solutions
18:07 and triing them and there'll be big churn issues and of course competition
18:13 issues. And I guess the um optimist view of it which I'm primarily in that camp
18:18 is these things are providing massive value at very low price. Therefore, why
18:23 wouldn't you try it? It's like, >> you know, come get three hamburgers that
18:28 are grass-fed beef for 20 bucks. It's like, how is that possible? Okay, I
18:31 don't need to know. I'm just going to order the burgers. Like, if you want to
18:34 charge me 20 bucks for something that saves me $2,000 a month. Okay.
18:41 >> And it's just wild to see how [sighs] mispriced some of these products are for
18:45 the value they're creating. >> Yeah, 100%. And some of them are uh
18:48 burning a lot of money along the way to get there. So, as uh to your point, the
18:53 pricing versus the value differential in one or two well-known cases are also
18:57 just leading to odd economics. But I think most of them are very solid in
19:00 terms of what they're providing the cash the potential cash flow to support the
19:03 business etc. >> So a lot on that point uh we're not seeing a lot of gross margin negative
19:08 businesses then because I've heard bits and pieces about people saying that some
19:10 companies are so enterprised that they're actually gross margin negative
19:14 which is so uneconomic as to make me worry but sounds like that's not the
19:18 case too often. No, I think there's one or two very high-profile versions of
19:22 that. And one could argue in those cases, they're basically trading
19:25 inference for market share. And so you could view it as a marketing funnel.
19:29 >> I've been working with and investing in founders for so long, I've got
19:33 supernatural startup powers. For example, I know your team is spending
19:36 too much time on debugging. Your engineers are chasing down bugs at 1:00
19:41 a.m., 8:00 a.m., and every time in between instead of building amazing new
19:46 features or pushing fresh code. Just admit it. you'll feel better. The
19:49 reality is from time to time your code is going to break. We all know that. But
19:53 it doesn't have to be the end of the world. Now there's Sentry. They're the
19:57 one-stop application monitoring platform that's not just going to tell you, "Hey,
20:00 something's broke," but what specifically happened, where, and most
20:04 importantly, why. Plus, they've added Sentry Logs. So now, when something goes
20:09 wrong, you get a complete report. No more random jobs that just don't run. No
20:13 more tab hopping, just actionable information with tons of context. And
20:17 that means faster fixes. And we want to give you three months free of Century's
20:22 team plan. That's right, f just for being a loyal Twist listener. That
20:26 covers 150,000 errors. Just go to century.io and use the code twist.
20:32 That's s n t r y.io and make sure you use that code twist so they know we sent
20:41 But I think in most cases, most of the companies I know are running at, you
20:44 know, quite healthy margins. and in some cases software plus one thing I've been
20:48 investing behind over the last two years kind of quietly is these AIdriven
20:52 rollouts. So can you fund the purchase of services businesses roll them up and
20:57 then increase margin dramatically using AI because effectively you're making the
21:00 people on those teams dramatically more productive and that's been a thesis
21:03 that's really been proving itself out quite strongly. There's two companies
21:06 I'm involved with in particular where we're seeing very strong lift
21:11 >> um and very strong execution relative to these really big opportunities because
21:13 services >> can you say the names of them or are they stealthy?
21:16 >> I can I can mention one of them. The other one's quite stealthy. Um the one
21:19 that is non- stealthy is called long lake >> and or long lake management. So lln and
21:25 um basically >> clever >> uh yeah very good. Um one of the
21:31 founders Alex is uh an exceptional PE person. uh Zach Frankl who's more
21:35 technical helped get it up and running and they um uh basically have a really
21:40 great team of both engineers but also private equity and operations people and
21:46 if you think about it the um the key for any sort of AI driven transformation is
21:50 you need if you're doing a rollup you need a PE person if you're not you just
21:54 need you know uh the sort of edict to do it then you need somebody to
21:57 operationally implement it a lot of the issues with adopting AI is not the AI a
22:00 lot of it's actually pretty easy to build given that AP API that we have
22:03 from Open AI and anthropic and others for Google. Um, it's usually the change
22:08 management. It's convincing the team to adopt it. It's aligning incentives. It's
22:12 saying, "Hey, we understand you really like this tool, but we're switching."
22:16 You know, it's all that kind of stuff. >> Real, right? The resistance.
22:19 >> The resistance is very real. Yeah. In some cases, maybe it's going to threaten
22:22 that person's job or perceptually do so. So, >> um, often when you're doing rollups for
22:27 AI, you need the PE person to be able to do good purchases. You need the ops
22:30 person to really help revamp the org. And then you need the engineers to
22:33 implement the AI and the workflow. And so very few of the rollup companies that
22:38 I've seen have this magical convergence of those three skill sets into one team.
22:42 >> Yeah, Athena isn't a rollup, but they're, you know, people think of them
22:46 as, and I'm the first investor in that company, as well as was the first
22:49 investor in Thumbtac, Jonathan's other company. Um, people think of it as like assistants,
22:57 right? uh virtual assistants uh in a different time zone at a different
23:00 price. But it's really an AI company because every time they can automate a
23:04 task across 10,000 assistants, if they can help one assistant schedule 5%
23:09 faster, right down the line, if they can help them book hotels faster, right down
23:14 the line, etc. Um and we have an investment in a company called Howie uh
23:17 that Austin Peter Smith is doing that is just doing one thing, scheduling better
23:21 than anybody. So there's a lot of people taking swings at this. I guess the
23:25 company this week of note, the main character energy goes to Amazon. Alex,
23:30 maybe you could tee up the breaking news from the last 48 hours uh about Amazon
23:36 and jobs and employment. >> Yeah. So, the New York Times
23:40 >> Yeah. New York Times got its hands on some internal documents from Amazon, the
23:44 cloud and e-commerce giant. These are from the 2024 time frame, so they're a
23:47 little bit dated, but essentially the company's investments in automation at
23:51 the warehouse level in particular are going to help it hire 160,000 fewer
23:57 people through 2027. And the times right that could save them up to about 30
24:00 cents per package that they pick and then deliver. 30 cents is not that much,
24:03 but if you multiply times billions of packages, it adds up quite quickly. and
24:07 all the work they've done over the last 10 to 15 years to build out robots and
24:11 increase automation in their warehouses will save them about 600,000 hires
24:16 through 2033 and the ultimate goal is to get to about three quarters automation
24:20 about 75%. Um, one of the major stories you talked about through the COVID era
24:23 was how many people Amazon hired to build out its warehouses as e-commerce
24:27 took off during that period of economic disruption. Now we're seeing the other
24:31 side of that and a lot of long-term bets by the company come good. Um, great news
24:34 for Amazon shareholders. all of us here who have 401ks. Pretty tough, I think,
24:38 Jason, looking ahead for the people who currently uh feed their families on $19
24:43 an hour Amazon warehouse jobs. >> What's your take, Lad? Uh seems
24:47 conservative to me, but what are your thoughts on automation, robotics?
24:52 >> Yeah, purpose-built humanoid. >> Yeah, it's interesting. It feels like um
24:55 for a long time, robotics was one of those areas that was always going to
24:59 happen and didn't quite, right? If you looked at the installed base of robots,
25:02 it was in the hundreds of thousands of new robots per year largely for
25:06 automotive and very specific industrial applications and it seems like now we're
25:09 going through a sea change and I think um you know it's kind of funny actually
25:12 if you ask what's a robot your dishwasher to some extent is a robot
25:15 right like a lot of things that we kind of take for granted now are robots um in
25:19 the modern era the things that are really emerging now are obviously some
25:21 of the things that were just mentioned relative to Amazon but also even
25:26 self-driving cars and Whimo and uh Tesla and what's happening there those are
25:28 robots right those are cars that drive themselves. There's a lot of startups
25:33 right now uh Pi and the bot company and a few others who are all building
25:38 nextgen sort of uh foundation models for robots. And so it seems like within the
25:41 next couple years we'll see a lot of these things substantiate. And there's
25:45 sort of two questions that come to mind for me. One is what proportion of the
25:48 winners will be incumbents versus startups. So for example, if you look at
25:53 self-driving, there was two dozen self-driving companies, but the winners
25:56 arguably are Whimo from Google and then Tesla, right? two incumbents actually
26:00 effectively have so far at least once self driving there's cool companies like
26:03 applied intuition and others who are providing pieces of this but you know
26:07 car OS and other things but I think um that's sort of clear winners at least so
26:10 far those two and robots it seems like Tesla will be one >> right through their optimist work and
26:15 then the question is who else is it a startup is it another incumbent is an
26:19 incumbent who buy the startup um is it at home robots which a lot of people are
26:23 working on uh which I I I view would be kind of awkward there's like a robot in
26:26 your living room and you walk in and you know it's like mopping or something. I'm
26:31 joking with that. Um or it's a >> um or is it an industrial application
26:34 more B2B which is sort of the Tesla Optimus sort of view and so I think
26:39 there's this big question of um you know who wins and why and then what
26:43 are the first application areas on top of that. >> Yeah, it was pretty obvious to me. I saw
26:48 Andy Jasse speak at a private event I don't know a couple months ago and um
26:54 you know was pretty bullish on AI and then a day later he did this public
26:58 missive um where he wrote hey AI is going to transform everything and we could see
27:06 different team sizes that was like a >> to me when a CEO that sophisticated
27:11 doesn't write that memo without a reason he was telegraphing internally
27:16 externally with partners Hey, you know, this is going to result in less jobs.
27:22 And um I I was on the Bull Work podcast, a political podcast, and I said, you
27:28 know, um I I don't see a world in, you know, the next 10 years where a human
27:33 being touches a package at an Amazon factory or to your doorstep.
27:37 >> Here's here's the quick clip. >> Jason, do you want to just run the clip?
27:40 >> Yeah, it's a little self-indulgent, but sure. Let's uh
27:42 >> It's this is literally your podcast. You're allowed to be self-indulgent.
27:44 Don't worry. I don't want to be too self-indulgent here. Quoting
27:48 >> we'll stop you. Anyways, here's Jason quoting himself
27:52 >> is where things could get really nutty. Um, and we're already starting and
27:55 that's where like the doomsday scenarios, Terminator ones kind of come
27:59 out of that group. Um, >> so what happens if you know all drivers
28:06 go away? Uh well, every self-driving car is four full-time jobs, and every uh
28:11 humanoid robot in a factory is five jobs, maybe six, because those jobs you
28:15 can you can work for maybe seven hours as a just physical limitation. As
28:18 humans, we're driving, you can work a 12-h hour shift. >> And those are those are going to be
28:24 here, folks. And before 2030, you're going to see Amazon, which has massively
28:28 invested in this, replace all factory workers and all drivers. The idea that
28:32 when you order something from Amazon, a human would touch it at any point in
28:37 that supply chain is insane. It will be 100% uh you know, robotic, which means all of
28:43 those workers are going away. Every Amazon worker, all those jobs, you UPS
28:49 gone, FedEx gone, every all of those are going to be gone. And those companies
28:52 will be more profitable. And when you order something, it's going to come
28:56 faster and cheaper and better. And your Uber will be half as much. But somebody
29:00 needs to retrain these people. And that's actually a very val What do you
29:04 think about job displacement, Alad? Um, obviously I have strong feelings that
29:09 this displacement is coming. Um, I don't know if anybody disagrees with that. I
29:12 guess we're all just going to debate timelines. Three years, 5 years, 7
29:17 years, 10 years. Do you think we're going to have societal issues with uh job
29:23 displacement? We're already seeing computer science graduates having a hard
29:28 time recently getting jobs. Uh, and I think most people are attributing it to
29:32 AI making the senior people more um, productive. So, what's your take on job
29:36 displacement? I'm curious. Probably the best part of being a founder is watching
29:41 a project that started as just an idea blossom into a full-fledged startup. The
29:46 worst part, it's bookkeeping. It's boring. It's detail- oriented. And it
29:50 takes time away from building your product. and hey, growing your team.
29:54 It's time for you to let Pilot take care of all this bookkeeping so you can get
29:58 back to running your company. Pilot's the largest accounting firm and it was
30:02 built just for startups. They understand the technology industry and the
30:05 landscape. They know the stakes and they're already trusted by amazing
30:09 companies we love like OpenAI, Scale, Air Table, and beyond. And you know
30:13 what? Pilot is about so much more than just getting your taxes done on time.
30:18 Pilot has a smart dashboard that puts all the essential metrics your startup
30:22 is tracking at your fingertip. And they have helpful adviserss who can walk you
30:26 through crucial financial decisions you're going to need to make in the
30:29 coming years. Plus, when it's time to raise your next round, Pilot COO and CFO
30:35 services are there to help. So, it's time to focus on your company and let
30:39 Pilot handle the books. And Twist listeners get $1,200 off their first
30:44 year. just go to pilot.com/twist >> Yeah, I mean I think any technology wave
30:55 uh definitely has uh job dispeling that comes with it. And so then the question
30:58 is what do you do from a retraining perspective? Um how do you think about
31:02 social safety nets? And then also how well you governed. If the you know if we
31:08 were governed remarkably well I'd say well we'll figure it out and we'll if
31:11 we're governed really badly then it's probably a different story in terms of
31:14 the degree to which you end up with uh you know different forms of unrest or
31:23 or other things you provide. So I think it's a pretty complex thing. Um but I do
31:29 think that it's it's pretty clear in certain areas that you're starting to
31:33 see shifts in terms of um labor particularly around you know customer
31:37 uh support may be one of the earliest places that I think ends up getting
31:40 impacted to some of the points made earlier. >> Yeah I think point Alex
31:45 >> oh just Salesforce said they're saving 100 million a year now on automated
31:49 customer support a lot just to back up your point it's a place where people are
31:51 finding enormous cost savings already which of course impacts jobs. Yeah. And
31:55 if you have like a temp or outsourced labor team or you've partnered with
31:59 somebody about it as a company, you're more likely to willing be willing to cut
32:01 that back than if it was your own employees, right? And so often when you
32:04 have these outsource or delegated systems, >> uh you're more willing to shut them off.
32:09 And so that could be some of the uh savings without actually changing
32:13 official employee headcount, but it it changes the virtual set of people that
32:16 you've hired. And I think that's >> that's why we're not seeing it in some
32:19 cases as much, right? It's kind of hidden because >> such a good point. Yeah. You outsourced
32:24 it already. So you're just ending a contract. You're not >> doing a plant shutdown. So in the United
32:30 States you have that >> it's not available warrant notice.
32:34 >> The warrant notice like warrant notice like you don't have to warn anybody.
32:36 It's like yeah I just got rid of a vendor. And I wonder if that is a pass
32:39 through >> where you still have to do a warn notice. Putting it aside. Um,
32:45 I will say I just had this realization as you were talking. I now as a default
32:53 do not go to, you know, the manufacturers's website to get an
32:55 answer. >> I go to an LLM. Why? The LLM has indexed all the Reddit threads, Kora threads,
33:03 Twitter threads, >> you know, uh, message boards of people
33:08 solving the problem on their own >> before the company even knows there's an
33:15 issue. and you so I think most organizations probably don't even know
33:20 what their true customer support >> uh request. >> Yeah. Yeah. And there's companies like
33:25 Decagon obviously helping with that and then um I think there's two other
33:28 implications of that or implications of all this. One is there are certain
33:31 countries that should be impacted sooner rather than later from a employment
33:33 perspective that we're not actually thinking about. Right. Because there are
33:36 certain types of jobs outsourced to specific regional hubs >> instead
33:42 etc. Sure. And then um I think the second thing and this is a point that
33:45 Nikesh Aurora at the CF Palto Networks has uh brought up with me in the past um
33:49 which I thought was a really good insight that you know he said this quite
33:53 publicly that they're using uh AI tools and foundation models and everything
33:55 else to iterate on product because customer support in some cases not all
34:00 just means your product isn't working good enough or the UI is hidden or
34:03 something else is going on. And so to some extent by iterating on product
34:08 faster, you're going to cascade into support as well from that perspective,
34:13 right? It's essentially if you have bots fixing every problem for you
34:17 automatically, your support load should go down, >> right?
34:19 >> And so there's all these really interesting sort of second or third
34:23 order things that that you know are really interesting to speculate on in
34:27 terms of the future world. It's really interesting to see the
34:30 number of people employed at these companies stay the same as their
34:34 earnings go up. >> Exactly. And this is why. Yeah. >> We've never seen that in our lifetime.
34:38 And this is >> if you were going to think about where to park money in the world.
34:44 >> I was hearing somebody who's like super liberal podcaster who hates America and
34:49 Trump, derangement syndrome, the whole thing. And he's like, I'm taking all of
34:53 my money out of the United States. >> Not you, Alex. I don't think you're
34:56 >> I was gonna say, dude, I'm sitting right here, not you.
34:59 >> You don't have TDS. >> Just got doxed. >> Yeah, exactly. [laughter] You don't have
35:03 TDS. You just have a love of democracy. It's slightly different.
35:06 >> And and I'm a capitalist. >> Yeah. Um and he said, I'm just putting
35:10 it I think United States is on the decline. I got to put my money in Europe
35:15 and every other thing. And I was like, >> a narco capitalism would argue the
35:21 opposite. [laughter] In fact, people are going to deploy this
35:25 technology aggressively >> uh in the most vibrant capital market on
35:31 the planet, the United States. >> Um, we could see Amazon, to my point
35:37 earlier, like what does Amazon look like with no delivery drivers? What does it
35:43 look like without wi with, you know, delivery times cut in half and running
35:48 24 hours a day? >> What does that even look like? Yeah, eventually it's just Jeff Bezos
35:54 and a bunch of bots though. >> I mean, back to the one person billion
35:59 dollar startup. Like maybe it's a, you know, 10 person trillion dollar startup
36:03 at some point if it's if it's that efficient. >> Um, here in Texas, they're delivering
36:11 stuff from Amazon warehouses so fast >> that I'm like, I don't need it that
36:14 fast. They literally like, would you like this from 4:00 a.m. to 8:00 a.m. or
36:17 8:00 a.m. >> to, you know, 10:00 a.m.? And I'm like, um,
36:25 >> it's 10 p.m., sir. I don't need it. I'm ordering a cable. It's 10 p.m.
36:28 >> tomorrow. Yeah, it's okay. At >> your leisure. [laughter]
36:31 >> Yeah. >> And like literally the drones are coming. Like if you live on a ranch or
36:37 something like that. I mean, the drones are going to be the ultimate.
36:40 >> Um, >> how crazy is it that >> Larry and Sergey bought every robotics
36:49 company for five years? what 1015 years ago and then they sold them all because
36:51 they couldn't figure out an application for it. I mean, >> yeah, they were so far ahead on so many
36:55 things. And so, I think a lot of creditors do in terms of being really uh
37:00 advanced on the curve. And, you know, there's the old saying that um I mean,
37:04 there there's there's two different things I think that apply here, but one
37:08 of them is just that um uh you know, a the features here is just not
37:12 distributed, then b um you know, often it's less a matter of um of uh uh who
37:18 but when. >> And this is a good example of a when, right? They they were just too early
37:24 >> and I think they've been remarkably early on all sorts of things. They
37:26 experimented with delivery. They experimented with uh internet using
37:30 weather balloons. They experimented with satellites. They exper you know because
37:33 eventually I think they sold their satellite company to Planet Labs for
37:35 somebody, right? But they had satellites. They had everything.
37:40 >> They were just too early on so much. So >> kudos to them, you know, for trying.
37:44 >> And you know, it's like a venture portfolio. You only have to hit on one.
37:47 And it looks like Whimo will be that one of the other bets. The Loom project was
37:54 too close to Earth. Turns out low Earth orbit better. You look at Google Glass.
37:59 >> Um that might actually be landing soon in the form of these Ray-B bands that no
38:03 everybody can't shut it about shut up about for meta. >> So they could have kept going with that.
38:07 I also think their Chromebooks and the Chrome operating system is eventually
38:11 where >> um AI lands. Like if you think about what will be the starting point for
38:20 every AI journey, where do you think that will occur? Do you think it's voice
38:26 and wearables, phones, dumb terminals? >> What do a new operating system? Where do
38:30 you think the endgame is for mass consumption, mass interaction of [sighs]
38:34 AI? >> Yeah, I think it depends on how good the companies are who are currently
38:38 providing all our hardware because the default state is they should win. Now
38:42 the question is are they going to win which I think is a separate question and
38:46 one could argue that there's been uh very little ondevice innovation in AI
38:52 and then the question is is that because they're waiting to see what works is it
38:57 because they're um you know uh investing and it takes time to build client
39:01 applications is it a lack of imagination and so I think there's this broader
39:05 question of why has so little AI been built >> into these devices so far and in some
39:09 cases um you know you look at something like theory it was never you know the
39:14 best voicebased system etc and so there's a there's a broader question of
39:18 um you know why is that and in some cases it's to protect users so for
39:22 example Apple has a very strong data privacy policy which means that they
39:25 don't have a lot of data that they normally would have for training that
39:27 Google has >> and so it's been purposeful but now in the AI era should that still apply or
39:32 not or how should you think about it as a company I think those are very
39:36 interesting probably ongoing questions in terms of where does that AI feature
39:39 come from the default should be the devices you use today or the devices
39:42 that should be the launching point for AI. Whether that actually happens, I
39:45 don't know. I mean, what do you think? >> Yeah, I've been thinking about Apple a
39:51 lot. Um, they are very good at making hardware. One of the greatest things
39:55 they ever did was get off of other people's chipsets and just make their
39:59 own, right? And that's been kind of the revolution. And they can make devices
40:03 that are higher margin, more powerful, leaprog everybody, low battery
40:06 consumption, solve so many problems for them. these laptops they build are
40:11 unnecessarily powerful and unnecessarily long battery lives because they've just optimized so
40:17 well. So, they actually have an advantage in that. And then >> there will be a time when people have
40:25 their LLMs um come up in um you know lawsuits and discovery and Sam Alman will be more
40:32 than happy to turn them over. He said like don't put your stuff in here folks
40:36 like we will >> you know have to hand them over you know
40:39 I think that's good that he was honest about that. So encrypted on your device
40:47 uh with an Apple phone, Apple Mini, Apple, you know, M17, whatever they get
40:51 to, you could actually run the LLM locally. >> All the, you know, context window could
40:58 be run locally on all your items and it could be running in the background
41:01 indexing your photos >> without ever putting them in the cloud
41:06 like Google and having your photos, you know, train Google's LLM, which I don't
41:09 think you really want to do. and Zuckerberg will do that in a heartbeat
41:13 obviously. So I I think they have a potential there. Yeah. >> Yeah. It's a really interesting question
41:17 because if you look at search as an analog and I don't think it's the
41:21 correct analog, right? Um but if you look at as an analog, basically Google
41:26 ended up paying Apple tens of billions of dollars a year to use it search
41:29 instead of developing its own. >> And it was all margin, right? You didn't
41:31 have to hire all the engineers. You didn't have to implement all this stuff.
41:34 You literally got paid money to just distribute somebody else's search. M
41:38 >> effectively it seems like that's the path that's been taken so far in LLMs
41:42 around foundation models and the question is is that the right approach
41:45 or wrong approach in this era because you're not just searching for things
41:48 >> it's not just a way to interface with the web it's the way to interface with
41:52 everything you're shifting the the the set the framework >> but from a deal perspective that deal
41:57 worked so well that I wonder if that's part of the framework that they're
41:59 thinking it I have no inside knowledge of I'm just saying if I if I had gone
42:03 through that historical arc maybe that's how I'd be thinking about things. Um,
42:07 and it may or may not apply to this different world of like uh AI doing sort
42:11 of all these various tasks for you and agents suddenly spawning up like in the
42:14 agentic world that's a very bad strategy potentially. >> I'm so uh I'm so bullish on Apple making
42:21 a big AI purchase. I just think they should just take out >> whatever LLM doesn't break, you know,
42:28 stay in the top three. They should just take out Perplexity is a great user
42:34 interface. They really know how to build >> slick interfaces uh the comment browser
42:38 and >> my lord just uh since the antitrust case >> think about how much traffic they could
42:47 spill over to duck.go Brave or Perplexity or anybody in that kind of
42:50 zone [clears throat] of excellence. It would be extraordinary for those
42:52 companies. >> And um >> yeah. >> Yeah. I led um Perplexity's first round.
43:00 >> Wow. And Arvin is one of the most uh impressive founders I've worked with in
43:03 a really long time. Like just a complete he's >> incredible at hiring, incredible at
43:08 execution, highly strategic, >> morphed into a very commercial person. I
43:11 mean, when I met him, um he was at OpenAI as a researcher, right? Uh and I
43:16 actually met him because I think he reached out to me on LinkedIn
43:20 and said, um, hey, I was, you know, I'm working at this lab at Berkeley and I
43:24 joined OpenAI like eight months ago and and this is when nobody was doing
43:27 generative AI stuff, right? I think I founded him in uh 22 sometime and um so we started
43:34 meeting up weekly and just brainstorming and you know he obviously came up with
43:38 perplexity and that's what he wanted to do and what he wanted to pursue and all
43:41 this stuff. Uh but I've just been impressed by how he's um really just
43:46 ramped so so quickly on so many areas. So it's it's been a very impressive
43:49 journey to watch. >> Yeah. Are companies sniffing around
43:53 Perplexity trying to snap it up a lot? >> No, I don't know. I'm not on the board
43:55 there or anything. So >> Okay. And now look at >> trying to get this breaking news. I like
43:59 it, Alex. >> Well, no, I'm just I mean Jason's been talking about his secrets. [laughter]
44:06 >> The different the difference. >> What's the worst thing that happened in
44:09 your childhood? Let's talk, you know, like >> no one cares about my secrets a lot.
44:12 That's that's that's the difference. My secrets are news. No, but I'm more just
44:15 asking the general point like how much interest is there from the incumbent
44:19 technology companies towards AI startups? because we've seen some
44:22 acquisitions, but Jason's keep seeing these interesting possible combinations
44:26 and I don't see as many of those >> uh in the market as we'd expect. So, I'm
44:28 just kind of curious about the the temperature or the appetite for that
44:32 kind of dealm. >> Yeah, I think it's because um you know
44:39 the uh the FTC has continued to be reasonably anti-large tech acquisitions
44:43 and that was started under the Biden administration um with Lena Khan and
44:46 others and I think that's just been continued into this administration. So I
44:51 think it has um as much to do with kind of a purview of how the government may
44:55 intervene. And that's not just the US government, it's also the EU, it's the
44:58 UK, right? The Figma deal was scuppered by the UK. It wasn't the US that did it.
45:02 And it almost feels like there's this um regulator Ron Robin where these
45:07 different groups are taking turns in terms of who's going to scupper which
45:09 thing so it isn't the same party every time. >> Yeah. They must be on a group chat.
45:13 They're like, "We're busy with stopping the totally inconsequential Figma Adobe
45:18 deal. Why don't you guys find an inconsequential robotics purchase by
45:23 Amazon for a two billion dollar company to block? And it's like,
45:26 >> how does the UK have that much power though, Jason? Like, the UK is this
45:30 little bankrupt off the coast of Europe, which is a natural economic block.
45:33 >> I I said this publicly many times. They should just ban you from using Adobe and
45:38 Figma products in the UK for ever [laughter] and just punish them if for blocking it.
45:43 They should just say like, "Okay, if you're going to block it, we're not
45:45 going to sell to your citizens. they can go use some open- source project. Hey,
45:50 um, speaking of interfaces, we have this sesame round which I'd like to go to,
45:55 but before we do, I think it'd be good to look at a poly market. Will Tesla
46:01 beat their quarterly earnings? So, I chose this Jason just to let everyone
46:04 know because we're getting into earnings season and you know I'm a big dweeb of
46:07 the public markets and I thought it's interesting that as we see sports
46:10 betting and prediction markets come together. It's important to keep in mind
46:14 that also people use these for what we used to use the stock market for which
46:18 was a surprise to me because why would you bother to use a different vehicle
46:22 for that but people seem really into it. >> Yeah. 80% chance they're going to beat
46:25 their quarterly earnings. I think you could really uh do well on these
46:30 prediction markets by looking at the historical data. Almost every company
46:35 tries to sandbag these earnings, right? A lot. They're always trying to
46:38 underestimate them so they can beat them. So beat is almost always the
46:44 default case. But this is an interesting if you were a large shareholder I guess
46:49 that you could use these prediction markets in some way to hedge you know
46:54 just like sometimes people collar stocks or something like that or get a little
46:57 extra juice. How do you think about putting aside just this one specific one
47:01 which you're welcome to comment on. >> Uh what do you think about these
47:06 prediction markets becoming just so um quickly integrated into our lives? I was
47:13 using one to gamble on uh the Emmys and made a little bit of money watching the
47:16 Emmys and then I did I was watching a boxing match. I won again. So obviously
47:20 >> these things are amazing since I've won two times in a row. If I lose then I'll
47:24 have a different opinion but for now my conf Yeah. My confirmation bias is these
47:28 things are awesome. >> They're fantastic. Yeah. Um yeah, you
47:31 know, it's interesting because this is one of those concepts that's existed for
47:35 years and there was crypto projects to do it and other and finally it's working
47:38 between Poly Market and Kelshi. >> Um and really if I look at it, it feels
47:43 like there's two or three big use cases, right? There's basically sports and
47:45 sports betting. >> Y >> and they took what was a really
47:49 complicated interface, not uh they did three things, right? One is suddenly
47:51 it's available in every state when it wasn't before because sports betting was
47:55 regulated on a state-of-state basis. They simplified the UI dramatically,
47:58 right? It used to be what's the spread and the point thing and the this and all
48:01 this complex stuff versus yeah >> who wins yes no >> so they simplified the UI it's like
48:07 swiping left right um and then there's kind of like um uh you know that that
48:11 global liquidity pool where you're suddenly reaching a much larger mass of
48:15 people and so you have way more crowd wisdom and that's sports is a huge area.
48:20 Um, politics when there's the political season is obviously a big area and one
48:24 could argue the stock market is just a prediction market, right? It's the same
48:28 thing. And so I always wonder where does this go? Can you start buying stocks or
48:35 um shares that are basically uh uh collateralized via crypto, you know,
48:38 there's also >> basically tokenized shares um >> uh through these markets at some point
48:45 like do these things converge? Are they completely separate? in which case a lot
48:48 of the financial speculation will continue to be the actual markets and
48:52 this becomes more sports and politics. So I've been kind of wondering like
48:56 where does this whole world go and um what sort of financial instruments
48:59 emerge either on top of this or does it go the other way right the New York
49:03 Stock Exchange announced that it was investing through ICE I think it was $2
49:07 billion in poly market do eventually the stock markets effectively become these
49:11 prediction markets because they are in some sense already. Yeah, I think if you
49:16 want to own the underlying asset, you buy the stock and you uh and if you want
49:23 to speculate uh and get extra juice on more acute, specific timebased moments
49:30 >> options, it's option trading. >> It's like you're doing it in a simple
49:34 way. Yeah. Simplifies options way down. Yeah. And that I think is the real
49:37 innovation here is you've collapsed these really complex speculative things,
49:44 sports betting, options, etc. >> And you've turned them into a yes. No.
49:48 >> Yeah. This is um when you're in the professional gambling circles
49:53 >> um and you're like the bottom rung of it as I am and I watch people try to do
49:58 side bets, what they call string bets. They make them very complicated which
50:03 for the people who are the sharps who are constructing these between the poker
50:07 sessions where they drop them out. It's like those option traders you know
50:10 they're coming up with some really interesting synthetic thing they want to
50:15 do like Michael Bur and the big short or whatever and then there's somebody like
50:19 Goldman trying to make it more complex to try to get an edge and they're all
50:22 just trying to get some little edge on it and you're right the simplification
50:25 of it. >> Yeah. you know, will OpenAI raise money at a billion dollar valuation in the
50:34 next two years. Well, I can't own >> um OpenAI shares. It's too complicated
50:42 you know, it's like, okay, it's a 60% chance. Great. I can make,
50:45 >> you know, whatever percent more on my money, I'll take it.
50:48 >> Yeah. It's a it's a transition from blogs to tweets, but from a financial
50:52 speculation perspective. >> Perfect analogy. Perfect analogy.
50:56 shorter form, fewer calories, you do more of them and they have more people
51:01 do it, easier to everybody can do it, etc. Yeah. >> Okay, let's talk about the Sesame
51:06 raising $250 million cuz I don't know what Sesame is. >> Yes, I thought you might not. So, this
51:12 is a company that came out of Stealth back in February. It's done a couple
51:17 things. One, it's built voice first AI, and its first two models that it put out
51:20 earlier this year, Jason, were popular enough that they racked up 5 million
51:24 minutes. But what's interesting about this company and why I wanted to bring
51:27 it up on the show today is they're also working on hardware. They're building
51:30 glasses for you. And I have um an image here from their oh let's call it their
51:35 lab or their office. Uh it doesn't really show us much. But the idea here
51:38 is back to the point about Google Glass being early is that Sesame wants to give
51:42 you some hardware that lets you chat with your personal AI agent or assistant
51:45 or friend or whatever you want to call it on the go. And they're taking the
51:48 hardware approach to it. And I think that explains the amount of capital
51:51 here. Just as background, how did they manage that? Well, they're founded by um
51:56 Brendan Aribe, the co-founder of Oculus and also the former CTO of Ubiquiti 6,
52:00 which was an AR startup. So, they have a lot of that AR um DNA in their veins.
52:08 >> Interesting. So, they worked at Ubiquiti, so they understand AR. Uh $250
52:16 million. And exactly how is the device going to work? Is there a demo of this
52:20 device out? Have they made a video of it? >> Very, very little. the Verge got to try
52:25 it and talked about it a little bit and that's where that image came and I do
52:28 have another one from the same post but it's pretty pretty nent. In fact, this
52:32 company is only putting out the beta of their iOS app now. They're actually
52:36 taking applications for the beta of their iOS app. So, it's very much under
52:40 wraps if you will. But the idea is and Sequoia wrote about this in a piece
52:44 explaining their investment Jason is that it's not just another AI voice chat
52:50 like your chat GPT instance for example. It's supposed to be more of like a
52:53 collaborator with you and with a focus on how it handles speech to make it seem
52:58 natural between you and um maybe your AI. One thing I'm sure you've noticed is
53:02 that if you chat with GPT5 and you make any sound while it's talking, it just
53:06 stops to give you space, which makes it almost impossible to converse. So, I'm
53:10 hoping that what they're doing here is making more natural communication with
53:14 AI, more personalized AI, and then making it functional on the go without
53:17 having to opt in to the Zuckerberg um I would say, you know, spyware empire.
53:22 What are your thoughts on wearables, Aladd? And this idea of like it's
53:27 persistently monitoring what you're doing in the world in what could only be
53:32 described as the most creepiest >> Truman Show concept ever, but the
53:36 benefits. >> Seriously, I didn't like it. [laughter] >> I I love The Truman Show in a dystopian
53:43 way. Like >> that's cool. Yeah. I think um Have you guys ever read this book called
53:47 Accelerondo? >> I have not. >> It's like a book. It's like a it's it's
53:53 it's a book with wonderful concepts. I think the book itself is a little bit
53:55 roughly written, but the the basic idea is it's the um >> you know f it's it's like the decades
54:02 leading up into the singularity where you have this technology discontinu
54:07 discontinuation and you know eventually at the point where every 10 years you
54:09 accomplish more than all of human progress then eventually every year you
54:12 accomplish more than everything ever before that etc. and things keep
54:15 accelerating and in it they have this notion of glasses which are effectively a form of external
54:21 memory. They're an agent. They act on your behalf. This book was written maybe
54:24 20 25 years ago. >> Yeah. 200. >> Very sort of looking. Yeah. And um
54:27 >> yeah, >> one of the really cool questions that it
54:31 raises is if so much of your memory and all these agents and all these things
54:35 you do is actually loaded in your device >> and you lose your device and somebody
54:39 else puts it on, how much of their personal of your personality or how much
54:43 of your memories or how much of >> your abilities is it absorbing as you
54:46 sort of augment as a human and you externalize stuff. >> Um and so I always thought that was a
54:50 really interesting almost like conceptual book. Like again there's lots
54:53 of really interesting ideas in that book. Um and this was one of them and is
54:58 one of the earliest versions of you know um glasses and human augmentation and all that kind of
55:04 stuff. So it's this interesting old concept that seems to again people are
55:06 iterating against. >> William Gibson had a similar concept
55:13 with um in his um virtual light the bridge series of like San Francisco
55:18 dystopian future. Um and he had this thing called God's little machine or
55:22 something. It was like a little zeppelin that flew above you in like a
55:26 threequarter shot like the Sims recorded your entire life indexed it and you
55:30 could pull it up and say, "Oh, when did Elad and I first meet or what was it
55:34 like when I, you know, the the first date I went on with my wife and
55:37 >> you could just kind of replay everything and then you have, of course, um,
55:41 Strange Days, the Katherine Bigalow film where you can put on a neural headset
55:45 and >> record your experience, then somebody else could put it on and live stream
55:51 your experience andor relive it. So these ideas are there and it really goes
55:56 to show how much of our consciousness and processing in the world is done
55:59 visually >> and that whole system >> could be uh the unlock for intelligence
56:08 and consciousness in some way is what some of the you know biology uh yeah I'm
56:14 sorry strange days um and it was called the squid superconducting quantum
56:18 interface device. Thank you, Producer Claude, for [laughter] coming to the
56:23 rescue here. Um, I do have some concerns about these things or being always on
56:27 and recording everybody all the time. >> I don't know if I'm going to win that
56:32 battle, though. You have concerns about this? No, >> you know, I'm in general a very paranoid
56:39 person, so I always have concerns. Um, but I think that uh it just comes back
56:43 to utility, right? What I think one thing that's been proven to us is um
56:47 people fluctuate between willing to sacrifice privacy in order to get access
56:50 to more stuff. That was Google Gmail, right? There was all these concerns
56:54 around Google reading your email reading it not really but a machine reading it
56:58 to generate ads and that was an issue but then you know hundreds of millions
57:00 of people adopted Gmail and then Facebook similarly people had concerns
57:03 about their own personal data and privacy and I think for a while um
57:08 Facebook actually was doing fine on it and probably what happened is because I
57:11 you know I sold my first company to Twitter and that was around 2009 and so
57:16 this was right as Facebook started paying attention to Twitter and I always
57:20 wonder if there's some alternate timeline or history or something else
57:22 where instead of trying to go after Twitter and media and public content,
57:26 >> Facebook leaned into its strengths because with the time it was a very
57:29 trusted privacy brand, right? It was your identity and it was your friends
57:32 and your friend group >> and it was viewed very differently. And
57:36 what if they had gone into banking and payments? What if they gone into
57:39 healthcare? What if they gone into all the things that were privacy native
57:42 almost what Apple ended up doing? >> That's a very interesting alternative
57:45 timeline for Facebook. >> Then maybe they will be the trusted
57:48 identity. Yeah. I don't know. It's it's an interesting concept, right, of like
57:51 they decided to go after Twitter. What if they decided to go after banking
57:55 >> at that moment in time when they were very trusted as like a you know, they
57:58 had all your stuff, but that was fine, right? Because it was just your friends
58:00 seeing it. >> It was your it was your social graph. It
58:05 was closed. They weren't trying to serve you ads. And Zuckerberg, in fact, hated
58:09 advertising. >> That was like he thought it was terrible. He didn't want to have ads on
58:15 the service until at some point somebody told him, "Well, you can make it free
58:18 and get billions of people to use it." >> And he was like, "Okay, fine." And then
58:21 Charles Samberg comes and the rest is >> and and this could have been an
58:24 alternate timeline. Maybe you would monetize through payments. And this has
58:26 happened a few times, right? I've talked to some of the people who worked on the
58:29 early browsers >> and it was the same thing. They're like,
58:31 "Is it going to be microp payments or ads?" >> And they ended up going down the ads
58:35 route, but there was an alternative universe where it was like microp
58:38 payments, right? And you you'd pay a >> maybe not kind of. I mean the technology
58:42 wasn't there [laughter] as the founder of a shortlived microp payment startup
58:47 back in 200 whatever you know I mean credit cards just weren't weren't there
58:50 I think the idea was good but I think we needed essentially >> you had one you had a microp payments
58:54 startup >> oh you did not you startup >> yeah it's called it's called contenture
59:00 we founded it at techrunch wrote about it we launched got customers and then we
59:03 failed and I had to go back to college >> oh okay wow you you were just too early
59:09 I kind of feel like yeah they were doing the brave attention token for a while.
59:12 That didn't take long. >> Oh, that's right. Yeah. >> Uh BAT, there's been a couple shots at
59:18 this and you know, one of the things I've learned is when we just talked
59:21 about it with, >> you know, Sergey being so ahead of the
59:26 curve that he was too ahead of the curve and then probably some
59:30 >> accounting wonks were like, "We're seven years into this, Sergey. Like, let's
59:33 pull the plug." And he was probably like, "All right, fine."
59:36 >> Um when if he had just stayed till year 11, it would have been like, "Oh, okay.
59:40 Now we own low earth orbit satellites. We had Starlink or >> which was Whimo, right? Yeah, which was
59:44 Whimo. But yeah, they could have had a couple others. So again, very forward
59:48 thinking company. I think they don't get enough credit for that.
59:51 >> I think this is where like Sergey and Larry just need to say we will be
59:56 willing to lose money on projects for 20 years, not just seven. And we don't care
60:01 what you think. Remember they were doing Google Fiber >> and I think that one got deprecated as
60:06 well. That would have been fascinating if they kept going along and pulled
60:09 [clears throat] that string because then you'd have fiber plus
60:12 >> um >> satellites, you'd have fiber, we'd have
60:16 flying cars, basically everything would be done. >> Well, you'd be out of business. We
60:20 couldn't invest anymore. >> Well, exactly. Be like Google's world.
60:24 But also that was like Larry had to go off balance sheet and use his personal
60:28 balance sheet to do >> he did three of them, I think. >> Kittyhawk, right?
60:32 >> Kittyhawk. Was he also in Archer? I think he might have also invested in
60:35 Archer. Yeah, I'm not sure. >> He was in at least two of them. Um, just
60:41 fascinating how close being too early is. But I I'm always encouraging
60:44 founders to to look in that startup graveyard. I think actually micro
60:49 payments as silly as it sounds built into a social network, a browser for
60:54 content. You know, this might be like Substack or, you know, a YouTube
60:58 competitor might be able to do very well with this where you could set your
61:02 >> what if you could set your browser to just say if I watch more than one minute
61:06 of a YouTube video, >> send the person one penny >> and uh if I watch, you know, a penny for
61:15 every second I watch of anything. And if I, you know, if I stay on a new a
61:19 document and I scroll down to the end, yeah, give them a penny. There's a lot
61:22 of people who might buy into that if there was some reward for it. I don't
61:26 know what that reward is. >> Well, I mean that was kind of what we
61:30 were trying to build, Jason. So, it was back then you couldn't do one penny. So,
61:33 you would put in $5 to your content account and then as you went around the
61:36 internet, we would hand out the money to people that you visited that had our
61:40 integration and people kind of liked it, but it was hard to get any sort of
61:42 momentum. >> Think about stable coins. Like, I wonder if coins are the unlock here. What do
61:48 you think about stable coins? >> Yeah. >> Yeah. I've been uh long interested in
61:53 them. I mean uh it's interesting to see some of these second order effects of
61:56 those now, right? In terms of the biggest holders of treasuries in some
62:00 cases amongst the biggest holders or are stable coin companies.
62:02 >> Yeah. >> So it's it's been fascinating to see
62:05 both their growth. I remember when Tether came out initially everybody
62:08 thought it was super sketchy >> are very uncertain in terms what the
62:10 assets are actually holding against the money. Yeah. >> And now obviously they're it seems like
62:14 they're fully collateralized between a mix of like gold, Bitcoin, and um
62:17 treasuries. >> They've done a great job cleaning it up.
62:21 Yeah. Yeah. So I, you know, it seems like it's going to be a really central
62:25 thing in general. And I think one of the things that people have underappreciated
62:28 about crypto, particularly people in the US, is the degree to which globally, for
62:32 example, that people don't have access to dollars. >> Yeah.
62:34 >> Because you're not allowed to by your government, and this is a way to buy
62:37 dollars, and this is a way to do simple transactions. Like all the stuff that we
62:40 take for granted here. >> But it also shows the path forward with
62:45 tokenizing shares and token, you know, things we've been talking about for
62:49 years. it feels like are finally going to happen. So, it's a it's a very
62:52 exciting era, I feel. >> Here we go. Tether is according
62:56 [clears throat] to producer Claude. Tether 127 billion in treasuries as of
63:02 Q2 2025. >> Number 18 global ranking ahead of South Korea and Circle 18 billion is in the
63:09 top 30. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. It's very under discussed how many
63:13 treasuries are actually held by crypto companies now. So one of the biggest
63:17 buyers of US government debt is the crypto industry. Like think about that.
63:20 What are the implications of that in the long run? If crypto gets 10 times bigger
63:26 and that 120 billion goes to 1.2 trillion. >> Mhm. >> What does that mean in terms of US
63:32 government's relationship to crypto? >> Think about that.
63:34 >> Yeah. >> Super interesting. >> Who's your daddy? It's kind of like the
63:37 China relationship. >> It's Tether. It's Tether. Tether.
63:39 >> Tether's your daddy. >> Paul is your daddy, I guess, in that
63:43 case. Well, and the interesting thing about Tether is um yeah, they did have
63:49 that really um spicy I'll use the word spicy. I don't want to get sued here,
63:52 but they were banned in a lot of regions. A lot of like regional action
63:55 taken against them. A lot of questions about those reserves. And they have gone
64:01 >> like on a five-year process of cleaning all that up. And there's like I think
64:06 they have according to the bill, the stablecoin bill that Sax was involved in
64:10 or talked about on the pod a bunch of times. >> I think they have a three-year window to
64:14 clean everything up in order to participate in the United States.
64:19 >> Uh so circles got the clear lane along with I guess their partnership with
64:23 Coinbase, but they have to Tether >> is going to clean up and the the guy
64:26 Paulo is his name. >> Paulo. Yes. who was like living in some
64:31 non, you know, the speculation was like none of the executives were available
64:34 and they were living in jurisdictions where you couldn't be deported
64:37 >> or picked up by a red notice. I don't know how much is that true. There were a
64:41 lot of tether truthers out there, you know, speculating. Um, but them figuring
64:48 out how to go legit if these stories of illegitimacy were in any way true is
64:52 like a story for the ages. That's going to be the next Sto movie, I think.
64:57 >> Yeah, it's pretty good. Um, I think one of the most
65:00 underhyped players in crypto right now perhaps is Stripe, >> who I think have been doing amazing
65:06 things in terms of um, stable coins and bridges and all the rest of it. And, you
65:10 know, I first invested in Stripe >> in 2010, I think. So, it's been kind of
65:16 a long road, but um, what an amazing >> next to act. I mean, obviously the
65:19 payment stuff is going to keep going and the SAS stuff will keep going, but I
65:22 think what they're doing in crypto is super interesting right now. They're
65:25 never going to go public and everything else. >> No, they definitely have. They're never
65:28 going to go public. This is my new prediction. >> Poly market.
65:33 >> I just >> infinite duration uh >> perpetual perpetual options on
65:38 hyperlquid. >> I Well, here's the thing. If you have that fluid of a market, if you're an
65:47 expert in transactions and commerce, what's to say they couldn't build and
65:51 you know the infrastructure to let people who are qualified purchasers
65:56 trade in and out of their private company and then slowly buy back all
65:58 their shares >> based on massive profitability and then
66:03 have a blackbox >> company that nobody understands what's
66:06 going on there. It's a tremendous advantage. And the Coulson brothers are
66:12 uh unique in their perspective of the world. I don't think they're
66:18 particularly driven by some outrageous um you know personal net worth on a
66:23 public market and the traditional accuchant of being an entrepreneur. They
66:28 seem very missiondriven and have very specific >> principled things they want to work on,
66:33 you know, like their think tanks, their science think tank, etc. So I
66:37 >> that could be amazing. I mean, I'm trying to think of the equivalent of
66:41 what's the largest private entity. >> Yeah, there's a couple of them. There's
66:45 like Coke Industries, there's Cargill. There's a bunch of these. Yeah, it's
66:49 kind of interesting. Bloomberg, right? >> Yes. >> Tons of cash and it's private. So,
66:57 >> I think people under um appreciate espec you know, Europe like a lot of the
67:00 market cap is actually these uh middle shot private companies in Germany for
67:04 example, >> these family businesses. VTOL Swissbased Dutch multinational energy and commodity
67:11 trading company. >> Yeah. Revenue $400 billion dollar in
67:18 >> Coke. Isn't Coke like >> Coke is number five? 125 billion.
67:23 >> Cargill should be on there. Like there's a bunch of these.
67:26 >> Cargill number four 160. >> Yeah. >> I'm trying to find a tech one. Huawei
67:31 number 10. I didn't know that they were private. >> Yeah. I mean I guess bite dance is a
67:35 private. Vance 14. >> That company. >> Yeah. >> Hey, a lot on the uh on the stripe
67:42 stablecoin point cuz I agree very much that they're they're leading. They
67:46 bought uh was it bridge for 1.1 billion and they just announced tempo their
67:50 their own kind of blockchain or L1 for for stable coin payments? I'm not asking
67:54 for internal information here, but like what do you think they're trying to do
67:57 with that? Is that just to make a better foundation, better rails for stables to
68:01 fit into the kind of existing e-commerce world or are they trying to solve a more
68:04 >> I I don't know fundamental issue with stable coins today that is not well
68:08 served by existing L1's and L2s. >> Yeah, I you know I think it's best to
68:12 just look at what the company says about all this stuff. Um >> because I I don't want to over interpret
68:17 or misinterpret what they're trying to do. Um I think fundamentally if I look
68:21 at what they've been building as a company over the years it's really this
68:26 focus on providing uh a piece of global infrastructure like Patrick used to talk
68:28 about it almost like containers ships and that enabled global commerce
68:32 >> for the world and so I think they're very missiondriven around you know this
68:36 interconnected web of commerce isn't that good for the world and how do we
68:39 help make it really easy for people and in particular developers to build things
68:44 against that so >> absolutely extraordinary what else do we
68:47 have on the docket Uh, we got maybe one more story left in us. What do we got?
68:51 >> Well, because we have a lot here, why don't we talk a little bit about the uh
68:55 the the fracus, Jason, with Anthropic and uh your bud David Sax.
68:59 >> Oo, that's spicy. >> Yeah, I know. >> We also have the OpenAI browser. Less
69:04 spicy. Let's go for the spice. >> Okay, let me just pull that up real
69:08 quick. I got to find >> I have some thoughts on it. >> I'm shocked. I'm shocked that you do.
69:14 >> You might not believe this, but I have opinions. I know for better or worse.
69:18 >> It's good. It's good. >> All right. So, uh, Anthropics Dario
69:24 Emmed wrote a public post this week responding to his critics. But to
69:27 understand what's going on, we have to go back in time a little bit to the one
69:31 big beautiful bill. Jason, we discussed here on the show that there was a
69:35 provision that eventually didn't make it in, but that would have banned states
69:38 from having state level AI regulations for a period of 10 years. Ended up
69:42 getting voted down 99 to1 in the Senate. Fast forward to recently, Jack Clark,
69:46 another co-founder of Open, sorry, of Enthropic, wrote a post, a summary of a
69:50 talk that he gave in which he said that he thinks other stakeholders in the
69:53 world should have a bit of a say in how we build AI as we build it. He's not a
69:57 doomer. He's definitely an optimist, but he thinks that we should listen to other
70:01 people. Uh, and then your friend David Sax comes in and he says that quote,
70:04 "Anthropic is running a sophisticated regulatory capture strategy based on
70:07 fear-mongering. [snorts] It is principally responsible for the state
70:10 regulatory frenzy that is damaging startups." Fast forward through some
70:14 back and forth and other people weighing in and we got Daario's um open letter
70:18 essentially saying, "Hey, what the hell's wrong with you guys? We love
70:21 startups. We work with them. We're in favor of a federal standard." And this
70:25 has become such a big deal, such a back and forth that CNBC is covering it. And
70:30 so Jason, I'm I'm incredibly curious why we have left the era of founder
70:33 friendliness and we're now seeing venture capitalists attack some of the
70:36 most successful companies in the history of startups. you know um this industry
70:43 left its boutique phase when Facebook hit scale. Uh Facebook just had far far
70:50 too much impact on society, elections, our children, Instagram. I think that
70:56 was the end of the innocence. Um, just if I were to pick, you know, a
71:01 demarcation point a lot of when >> we became so big that we couldn't be
71:06 looked at as the weirdos in California building cool stuff and then it became,
71:10 oh, how are these things damaging society? We should be questioning
71:14 everything about AI. We just did today talking about Amazon and job
71:17 displacement. We should be thinking about kids using these products. We
71:21 should be thinking about people getting oneshotted and getting, you know, and we
71:25 should be thinking about the truth and the search for truth. I think all these
71:28 things are valid discussions. I think what's at stake here is there is covert
71:34 um I don't know lobbyists uh and covert political actions to try
71:41 to regulate things. And though that does make me nervous. I just want to see all
71:46 the evidence of it um if that's actually happening or not. And I I I told Sax
71:51 this. He wasn't too pleased with me, Elad. But if this is the most important
71:57 technology of our lifetime, why wouldn't states have a right in the format of the
72:04 United States of America to, you know, chime in on it? You know, if they kids
72:09 access to it or how it's used in healthcare, how it's used in terms of
72:13 job displacement. What's your take on all this? Yeah, I think um at at this point in
72:19 time and I think industries evolve over time and the nature of how you regulate
72:22 those industries should evolve with it. But early on in industries, it's a bit
72:27 of a disaster to let each incremental state chime in >> on how to regulate it because
72:31 fundamentally there's a handful of states that effectively by fiat govern
72:35 what the rest of the country does, whether those the rest of the country
72:38 adopts things or not. It's it's almost the flip. Why should California be able
72:42 to govern AI for everyone in the US which effectively almost happened
72:46 through the Scott Weiner bill. So I actually view it on the other side of
72:49 this one where I think um the states should not intervene for now. It should
72:53 be federally mandated. There are both national security reasons to do that.
72:57 There are national competitive dynamics that drive that. So, uh, you know, my
73:03 view would be, um, and and this literally almost happened, right?
73:06 California was going to >> try and regulate how the rest of the
73:09 country deals with AI, which is a really bad idea. So, >> and it was based on the number the
73:15 amount of compute you have as if that is some sort of >> Well, the question is why should
73:21 California regulate it for at all a and then b for everyone else, which is fact.
73:24 I mean, it would have been national, which means it would have been global.
73:26 So, should California have the right to set national or global AI policy
73:30 effectively? >> Yeah. And the car example is a good one.
73:34 And so, that's one where I happen to be in favor of it. So, when you look at
73:38 these, it's always um >> uh it may have been the right thing to
73:41 do. The question is, should California have been able to do it? In other words,
73:45 >> correct. Yes. I was in favor of it. Yeah. >> Yeah. Yeah. It's like, let's separate
73:49 the do we agree with the thing? >> Yes. >> From how should that thing get done,
73:52 right? And I think those are two separate things. So, >> yeah. Yeah, and that's what I've been
73:56 trying to parse in my head because I, you know, yeah, we should have higher
74:01 gas standards and who cares if cars cost a little more. We we, you know, having
74:05 smog over cities and people losing, you know, months to years off their life
74:09 and, you know, asthma and all this kind of stuff. Yeah, it's obviously a tragedy
74:12 of the commons. It's a good thing that California did that in my mind, but
74:17 should Texas be forced to not buy the trucks they want that have the hauling
74:21 power and the price performance ratio that they want? I I picked Texas as a
74:26 place to live because I like less regulation. Um, and so it really does
74:31 come down to the operating system of America where the states are supposed to
74:35 have some sovereignty but then you have to super oppose it against well if we
74:41 are in fact in a global race with China, can we can we afford to slow ourselves
74:47 down? And that's like a very interesting this is >> probably there's a global race with
74:50 China and then there's the um there's the political side there's the the
74:54 military side of that there's the economic side of that there's the
74:58 political and cultural side of that >> and so I I disagree as well with hey we
75:01 should have every country on the planet weigh in on how AI models should get
75:05 built in the US. I think each country should have its own sovereign AI model
75:09 >> and there's lots of ways to accomplish that right like if I was running a
75:12 country I'd be very interested in that. I want my cultural values represented in
75:15 local models and things like that. So I >> sure >> agree with that. But the flip side of it
75:19 is um >> if anything perhaps the last few decades have shown us that perhaps we don't need
75:25 to solicit everybody's opinion on everything >> both in the context of a company and the
75:29 context of a country and the you know and so this is almost a throwback to
75:33 things that uh haven't really been working. It feels >> Yeah. If you were to put this against
75:39 high-speed trains, Alex, like there's a reason why we don't have them in America
75:43 because everybody gets to chime in on the highspeed train and then the
75:48 high-speed train, you know, is like, you know, it's [laughter]
75:50 in other countries, they're like, high-speed train has to be a straight
75:54 line, >> or else it can't go fast. And you know, >> but in China, there's been a lot of
76:01 studies discussing how both province and central planning has led to a dramatic
76:05 overbuild of economically inefficient highspeed rail. And so, we can all give
76:09 a thumbs up to the Shanghai Beijing line. Why not? But when you see the what
76:14 is it eight pillars and eight cross beams, there's some model that I'm
76:17 translating poorly here for how to build highspeed rail in China. And it's led to
76:23 a lot of misplaced spend. And so I agree that we should >> of that sp like that's often also
76:27 corruption. That's a bunch of stuff. It's not just >> but if you want centralized power all if
76:33 you don't want people to have say you're going to end up with a central power.
76:37 >> Well really what the question is is what are the things that should be regulated
76:40 by what level of government? M [clears throat] >> and that's that is something that has
76:44 been established and adjudicated in the US for >> centuries now right and that this falls
76:49 into line of those things which is >> how much should states be able to govern
76:56 >> on their own overall technology progress for the US and for the globe and that's
77:00 effectively what this issue really is right >> interstate commerce
77:04 >> not just interstate commerce it's effective de facto regulation of the
77:08 entire country >> right no I'm saying that because it's
77:11 that it should fall prey to that and therefore it could be limited in that
77:13 way. >> Exactly. Exactly. >> But what's what's interesting though is
77:17 we're talking almost about the wrong the wrong foe here because I think this is
77:21 why anthropic is, you know, being dragged into a bit of the mud here. But
77:25 the the the provision to bl to block state level AI rex was voted down nearly
77:29 unanimously in the Senate and partially because Republicans from the south
77:34 wanted to protect local industries. So, how do we get Congress to listen to this
77:38 perspective and do something intelligent and pass something that will preclude or
77:42 maybe just do better than state level regulations? Because Daario said in his
77:47 letter that they disagreed with the idea because um a blocked action without
77:51 offering a federal alternative. So, how do we get to one? How do we fix Congress?
77:58 >> I mean, there is there is this >> um I I I'd say three things on it. One
78:02 is I tend to stay away from politics. I'm the least uh cogent person to ask
78:05 about >> how to fix Congress or how to change, you know, like I'm that's not the world
78:11 that I tend to spend time in. Um, you know, I do think there's a number of
78:14 different approaches that we've taken in the past or historically
78:20 to federally mandate things. And one route is executive orders where they can
78:24 be applied. The other route has been acts of congress. You know, there's
78:26 three or four routes that are just standard. And the question is what best
78:31 applies here? Then I think it's back there's also the meta issue of where do
78:35 states cross the boundaries in terms of the areas that probably shouldn't apply
78:39 to them and is that a legal framework is that something else that already exists
78:45 and how do we interpret um you know the existing legal structures of the country
78:49 relative to some of these topics >> I think that's the granular piece that
78:53 you're talking about a lot I think is the key piece of this which uh downside
79:00 what concern do we have over AI that is not addressed by an existing law. If you
79:04 were to go in an AI and you ask it right now, how do I build a chemical weapon?
79:08 How do I build a biological weapon? It says, hey, I'm not going to do that.
79:11 It's already been solved by the teams. They've >> self-regulated.
79:17 >> So, okay, what's the next piece? Oh, um, how do we deal with the, you know, I
79:20 don't know, the termination >> the bioweapons stuff, the bioweapon
79:24 stuff is so overstated and I feel like that's the >> way that some of these companies have
79:31 been trying to uh cause distress and fear and regulators and others because
79:36 the reality is all the protocols for um building a a virus you can release
79:41 etc are on the web. >> Yeah. >> I mean I worked as a biologist for
79:44 almost a decade, right? and all these love protocols are out there. Um the
79:49 real issue is buying the equipment, using it, actually doing things in an
79:52 intelligent manner, ordering all the logos you'd need, etc. And you know, so
79:58 the extra information content in my opinion isn't high >> and the hard part is the physical world
80:03 stuff. And so whenever people raise that as an example, >> I view it as kind of a red herring where
80:09 where it's purposefully raised in attempt to cause fear in people so
80:12 they'll react and regulate something. So I do think those are bad bad examples
80:17 that people tend to use in general and it's purposeful. I think
80:19 >> it's per I agree and I always ask people tell me the next one tell me the next
80:24 one. Let's just get granular here for a minute. I have one like IP protection. I
80:29 think that that should be done. Uh that should be self-regulated by the industry
80:33 which they're starting to do. They're starting to say, "Hey,
80:37 >> even if you don't agree with how Sam's doing it at OpenAI," he's saying with
80:39 Sora, >> "Hey, if you're like, you know, the estate of Elvis or Martin Luther King,
80:47 we'll be gracious and turn off the ability to make Martin Luther King
80:50 saying inappropriate things." And they did. >> They didn't have to go the legal route.
80:55 Sam said, "We're good people. We're going to be aggressive in letting people
80:58 do things, but we're also going to be reasonable in turning them off."
81:01 >> I disagree with the approach. I think they should always get permission. But
81:04 okay, fine. He took a different route. They'll get the legal exposure. But
81:09 >> yeah, this is um a situation where we have to get into each one. I was just
81:14 thinking when you were talking about um you know, bombs and I was like, remember
81:17 fertilizer bombs? Everybody was like, "Oh my god, you know, the internet's
81:21 causing this, the tour network, uh you know, dark web, everybody knows." And
81:24 it's like, you still got to get the fertilizer. Every piece of every bag of
81:31 fertilizer has IDs in it. Like in the chips from what I understand, there's
81:35 like some secret way that they watermark every bag of fertilizer. So if you blow
81:39 something up and then if you buy them, you need to register and they've got
81:42 some, >> you know, I mean, who knows how the government is implementing this after
81:50 the 911 because the first before 911, they tried to blow up the World Trade
81:52 Center with a fertilizer bomb. They succeeded in blowing up Oklahoma City.
81:56 Two different groups of terrorists, domestic and international.
81:59 >> They they solved this problem. I bet you they have like ways of tracking
82:03 fertilizer where like the second the person leaves the fertilizer store,
82:09 there's like a camera on their license plate. They're being tracked by a drone.
82:13 Like the government took this seriously. >> There's so many like simple solutions to
82:16 this. So >> yeah, that's why I stopped fertilizing my my garden. I was worried that uh I
82:21 get tracked down. >> Yeah. So you you you laugh, but the only
82:25 time I've actually gotten pulled out at the airport and put into a small room
82:28 was after going home to Oregon to my parents house and I was walking around
82:33 the backyard a lot and I popped a uh some sort of test at TSA for possible
82:36 fertilizer. >> That happened too >> and they like
82:39 >> I've never been treated as a criminal quite like that. They're like, "Is there
82:42 anything in here that's explosive?" I'm like, "I don't know. weed, but
82:46 please don't find that." And it was so Oh, sorry. We're live. Uh edit that out,
82:51 I guess. Um, but it was just it was so surreal, but it it can catch you. And
82:55 >> they uh they literally asked me like, "Have you been doing gardening?" I was
82:59 like, "No, how's that relevant?" I didn't [laughter] know what they were
83:00 talking about. >> Like, I've been helping startups grow.
83:05 >> I don't get it. >> by spreading manure. >> Yeah, exactly.
83:10 >> Uh, all right. Listen, this has been another amazing episode of This Week in
83:16 Startup Salon. Thank you for joining us today. What a great guest. Uh, where can
83:19 people find you? I mean, you got a Twitter account. You're pretty active.
83:21 Yeah. >> Yeah, Twitter. They can find me uh at a log. And pleasure to be on. Thanks for
83:25 including me. >> All right. Uh, and we'll see you all next time on this week in Startups.
$

Amazon’s “Age of Efficiency,” LLM distribution, AI wearable worries, and more with Elad Gil | E2197

@thisweekinstartups 1:23:34 20 chapters
[AI agents and automation][fundraising and investment]
// chapters
// description

Today’s show: *Amazon’s dropping a LOT of employees for AI and robots… are Jason’s darkest predictions coming true? Legendary investor Elad Gil joins Jason and Alex for the full show today! Together, they’re digging into the Amazon news, looking back at Jason’s predictions from just last month, and theorizing about just how many people will lose their jobs to computers, and what we’re going to do about it. (Is it possible the US hasn’t been massively hit by job displacement so far because tho

now: 0:00
// tags
[AI agents and automation][fundraising and investment]